The ESA Watch » Kristen Lingley a policy watch site on the Endangered Species Act Fri, 13 Dec 2013 22:24:27 +0000 en-US hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.5.1 ESA Newsletter 12-6-13 /2013/12/06/esa-newsletter-12-6-13/ /2013/12/06/esa-newsletter-12-6-13/#comments Fri, 06 Dec 2013 16:55:40 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=1141 Continue reading →]]> Issues

FWS Announces Extension of Comment Period for the Northern Long-Eared Bat. This week, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) announced the extension of the comment period for the Northern Long-Eared Bat. On October 2, 2013, the FWS proposed listing the bat as endangered yet found critical habitat for the species was not yet determinable.  According to FWS, the extension of the comment period for the proposed rule is “to ensure the public has sufficient time to comment on the proposal for this wide-ranging species that involves many stakeholders.” Comments on the proposed rule must be submitted by January 2, 2014. Additional information is also available in the Federal Register HERE.

IPAA and API Comment on Proposed Designation of the Western Distinct Population Segment of the Yellow-billed Cuckoo. This week, the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) and the American Petroleum Institute (API) submitted comments on the proposed designation of the Western Distinct Population Segment of the yellow-billed cuckoo as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). According to the comments:

“The Service’s proposed listing determination for the proposed western DPS of the yellow-billed cuckoo is flawed and fails to meet the standard required under ESA Section 4. As this proposal does not meet the minimum analytical requirements required for designation of a species as threatened or endangered under the ESA and its implementing regulations, the Associations request that the Service withdraw its listing determination.”

The Associations also noted there is no current basis to identify or propose the designation of critical habitat for the cuckoo, stating:

“Given the fact that so little is known about the population and habitat of the proposed western  DPS of the yellow-billed cuckoo, the Service cannot identify characteristics common to those habitats that would allow it to designate critical habitat.”

The Association’s comments also state the FWS has failed to identify and establish a relationship between the data on habitat conditions, the species status, and whether conditions or threats necessitate a listing under the ESA – a “fundamental flaw” in the proposed rule. Read the full comments from the Associations to the FWS HERE.

Unified Agenda Items for Endangered Species Act. Last week, the Obama Administration posted their Unified Agenda for Fall 2013 which lists regulatory items the administration plans to pursue, including a number of items that are relevant to the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Of particular note are proposed rules regarding:

  • ESA Section 7 Consultation Regulations and Incidental Take Statements;
  • Implementing Changes to the Regulations for Designating Critical Habitat;
  • Policy Regarding Implementation of Section 4(b)(2) of the Endangered Species Act;
  • and the definition of “Destruction or Adverse Modification” of Critical Habitat.

A link to the Department of Interior’s complete Unified Agenda can be found HERE. A link to the offshore species can be found under the Department of Commerce (NOAA) located HERE.

In the News

Sage grouse plan impacts ranchers disproportionately, OCA says. Capital Press. Some Oregon ranchers would be disproportionately harmed by grazing restrictions under a proposed plan to protect sage grouse, according to leaders of a state cattlemen’s group. The U.S. Bureau of Land Management recently offered a draft plan for managing the greater sage grouse, a candidate for federal protection under the Endangered Species Act.

Hickenlooper ‘Sage-Grouse’ appointment spurs ‘cautious optimism’ from rural conservatives. The Complete Colorado. The search for a state-based solution to the potential listing of the Greater Sage-Grouse to the list of endangered species has a new advocate, according to Moffat County Commissioner John Kinkaid. According to Kinkaid, Gov. John Hickenlooper has appointed John Swartout to lead the effort to push back against the addition of the sage-grouse to the list of protected species under the Endangered Species Act.

Garfield County says BLM emails help make the case on sage-grouse. Post Independent. A series of internal emails between U.S. Bureau of Land Management officials and wildlife experts in late 2011 suggest some reservations about a National Technical Team (NTT) report that was used as a basis for coming up with a plan to protect the greater sage-grouse. In particular, some comments by BLM officials during the early stages of a federal study to determine the bird’s habitat in northwest Colorado and other Western states seem to question the science behind the NTT’s recommended protective measures.

Public Responds to Sage Grouse Plan. Fairfield Sun Times. Just before Thanksgiving, the governor’s Greater Sage-grouse Habitat Conservation Advisory Council completed a statewide tour for public input on the plan to divert a federal listing of the sage grouse to the Endangered Species List. The council stopped in Dillon, Baker, Miles City, Billings, Lewistown, Glasgow, and Malta; all areas with core sage grouse habitat, each of which will be affected by the plan approved by the Governor next month.

Planning complete to save prairie-chicken. Amarillo Globe News. The planning is finished and endorsed so now it’s time for landowners to say “yes” or “no” to helping keep a vanishing bird off a list of threatened species. Texas Parks & Wildlife Department will host a meeting Dec. 12 in Pampa to educate landowners about the Lesser Prairie-Chicken Range-wide Conservation Plan and the landowner enrollment process.

To list or not to list. Petroleum News. The clock is ticking for Montana to convince the federal government that the sage grouse is not threatened or endangered in the state. In 2010, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service determined the bird warranted federal protection, but was precluded from being listed simply because other species were worse off. Dissatisfied environmental groups sued, and a federal judge ruled the agency must make a decision about the listing by September 2015.

Information meetings scheduled for Texas prairie chicken conservation. Lone Star Outdoor News. Texas Parks & Wildlife Department will host two informational meetings in December for private landowners regarding the Lesser Prairie-Chicken Range-wide Conservation Plan and the landowner enrollment process. The meeting for landowners in the southern plains will be held in Sundown School at 7 p.m. Dec. 11.

]]>
/2013/12/06/esa-newsletter-12-6-13/feed/ 0
ESA Newsletter 11-22-13 /2013/11/22/esa-newsletter-11-22-13/ /2013/11/22/esa-newsletter-11-22-13/#comments Fri, 22 Nov 2013 21:29:17 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=1112 Continue reading →]]> Issues

Western Energy Alliance Sends Letter to Sec. Jewell on Greater Sage-Grouse (GSG). This week, the Western Energy Alliance sent a letter to Department of the Interior (DOI) Secretary Sally Jewell regarding the proposed listing of the Greater sage-grouse under the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA). The letter highlights, among other items, concerns surrounding two seintific documents distributed by the DOI regarding the GSG. These documents include A Report on National Greater Sage-Grouse Conservation Measures by the National Technical Team (NTT Report) and the Greater Sage-Grouse Conservation Objectives Final Report (COT Report). According to the letter:

“Many of the reports relied upon to justify onerous management prescriptions for GSG have been prepared by a small group of interested and well-funded personnel that often co-author papers together and review one another’s work, thereby failing to meet the most basic of scientific standards.

“…The Alliance has a real interest in ensuring documents like the NTT and COT Reports: (1) represent the best available science and adhere to high standards of quality, objectivity, transparency and integrity under presidential and DOI memoranda and orders and the Data Quality Act; (2) comport with the agencies’ statutory multiple-use mandates and preserve valid existing rights; and (3) adequately consider the extensive state and local GSG conservation efforts already in place.”

The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) released three proposed plans to protect the GSG on November 1st, 2013. The plan includes Utah, Idaho, and Nevada along with parts of California and Montana. The public has 90 days to submit comment.

Federal Legislation Introduced on the Endangered Species Act. This week, Senators Rand Paul (R-KY), Dean Heller (R-NV) and Rep. Mark Amodei (NV-2) introduced the Endangered Species Management Self-Determination Act, a bill focused on providing state governors the power to regulate intrastate endangered species and intrastate threatened species.

According to Senator Paul, the bill is an important step in ensuring better protection of endangered species:

“This bill will better protect endangered species by allowing a more tailored response as implemented by the states. The Endangered Species Management Self-Determination Act ensures that local needs will be considered in the regulation process and places the decision-making into the hands of the states by allowing them to choose whether regulation occurs on the state or federal level.”

Senator Heller also noted that protecting the environment and protecting the economy can go hand in hand:

“We have a responsibility to be good stewards of wildlife and the habitat that they rely on.  In Nevada, we have been working hard to protect both the sage grouse and our economy, which is why I am working hard with the Governor, the delegation, and Nevadans to prevent a listing for the bird.”

Congressman Amodei also emphasized the important role of increasing Gubernatorial flexibility in protecting endangered species.

“Giving governors greater flexibility would go a long way mitigating the one-size-fits-all impact of the ESA, which is threatening to shutdown vast swatches of the American West, including Nevada. Governor Brian Sandoval has met the challenge posed by the looming sage grouse listing and that kind of leadership deserves respect from federal land managers.”

Congressman Amodei also urged his constituents this week to engage in two public comment periods regarding a proposed listing of the bi-state sage grouse and the Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the Greater sage-grouse. His full comments are available on his website HERE.

In the News

Sage Grouse Rules Pose Problems for County Government, Business. Big Sky Business Journal. In an effort to prevent the listing of Sage Grouse as an endangered species, political leaders in the state are scrambling to establish their own management plan that will help preserve species habitat, while still allowing some economic development. In that effort, six months ago, Governor Steve Bullock appointed the Greater Sage Grouse Habitat Conservation Advisory Council to draft a strategy. The Council’s proposal is now available for public scrutiny and is the subject of seven public meetings throughout the state.

Agency again approves Kinder Morgan’s Ruby Pipeline. Associated Press. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruled in the groups’ favor in October 2012, concluding that BLM and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service hadn’t done enough to ensure protection of the threatened Lahontan cutthroat trout and other rare fish in Wyoming, northern Utah, northern Nevada and southern Oregon. It also agreed with their claims the agency had failed to provide enough information about the cumulative loss of sagebrush habitat that the sage grouse and other species depend upon in the Great Basin and high desert.

Interior listed 81 plants and animals in past year, reducing backlog. E&E News (sub req’d). The Interior Department over the past year listed 81 species as endangered or threatened, reducing its backlog of imperiled candidate species to fewer than 150 for the first time since the 1970s, according to a federal report. The new listing decisions, many of them compelled by a legal settlement with environmental groups, leave just 146 species on the candidate list: 94 animals and 52 plants.

Gov. John Hickenlooper to visit Craig. Steamboat Today. Moffat County Commissioners joined other counties Oct. 31 in officially requesting Hickenlooper take part in conversations about sage grouse habitats and the Bureau of Land Management’s Environmental Impact Statement that would limit the use of certain habitats, according to a statement put out by Scott McInnis, executive director of the Associated Governments of Northwest Colorado.

Utah legislator proposes state defense fund against environmentalists. Standard-Examiner. Sen. David Hinkins, R-Orangeville, said he will run legislation during the 2014 session that would create an environmental defense fund in anticipation of looming court fights with environmentalists. He anticipates conflict over sage grouse, as well as the beardtongue flower, which grows over oil shale areas and which some claim may be put on the protected species list — potentially shutting down access to the oil shale.

Bingham wind project review on hold. Morning Sentinel. First Wind is working to address the concerns of the department regarding the protection of bat habitats, a spokesman said in an email on Monday. “We remain hopeful the DEP will complete its review in an expeditious manner so that the region can realize the positive economic and environmental impacts of the Bingham project,” said First Wind spokesman John Lamontagne in an email Monday.

]]>
/2013/11/22/esa-newsletter-11-22-13/feed/ 0
ESA Newsletter 11-15-13 /2013/11/15/esa-newsletter-11-15-13/ /2013/11/15/esa-newsletter-11-15-13/#comments Fri, 15 Nov 2013 16:39:07 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=1083 Continue reading →]]> Issues

No ESA Listing for Gunnison’s Prairie Dog. This week, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) announced the Gunnison’s prairie dog does not warrant listing under the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA). According to the FWS announcement in the Federal Register:

“The best available information indicates that populations of both subspecies are stable and that there are no threats causing or projected to cause either subspecies to be at risk of extinction. This action also removes the Gunnison’s prairie dog from our candidate list.”

According to the Associated Press, potential threats to the prairie dog such as agriculture, urbanization, and oil and gas operations are not seen by the FWS as threats to the species survival. WildEarth Guardians petitioned to list all populations of the prairie dog species in 2004. In 2008, only one subspecies was ruled warranting protection and WildEarth Guardians moved forward to challenge the ruling. The group’s Endangered Species Advocate Taylor Jones was critical of this week’s decision by the FWS and stated the federal government has “dodged its responsibility” to protect the species.

Proposed Bi-State Sage Grouse Cause for Concern for Nevada. News of the bi-state sage grouse’s proposed listing as threatened under the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA) has some Nevada residents worried.  The bi-state sage grouse, one of two sage grouse populations, inhabits roughly 1.8 million acres in California and Nevada. Last week, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) state supervisor for Nevada Ted Koch held an open house in Wellington, NV to answer residents’ questions and concerns regarding the proposed listing. While he noted the decision was not a “done deal,” many residents expressed their concerns with the proposal.

Among them was rancher Dick Huntsberger, who expressed his apprehensions given the sage grouse habitat efforts he has already implemented on his grazing allotments. According to the Reno Gazette-Journal:

“Huntsberger, who said he’s been involved going back 12 years under former Gov. Kenny Guinn, said it is frustrating they’ve taken all these steps to conserve the sage grouse and its habitat to prevent listing. He said he’s concerned, as are many, that he’ll be kicked off his grazing allotments. Koch said the special rule was designed to help those who already were protecting sage grouse habitat so they can continue doing so.”

FWS state supervisor Ted Koch noted that actions underway that are consistent with the Bi-State Sage Grouse Local Area Working Group Action Plan will be recognized as efforts working to conserve the species and will not require additional regulatory review.  The comment period for the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) and listing of the bird ends December 27th.

Congressmen Call for Delisting of Gray Wolf. This week, seventy five members of Congress sent a letter to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) Director Dan Ashe. The letter called on the FWS to delist the gray wolf, an action they note as “long overdue.”

According to the letter:

“The statutory purpose of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) is to recover species to the point where they are no longer considered ‘endangered’ or ‘threatened. The gray wolf is currently found in 46 countries around the world and has been placed in the classification of ‘least concern’ globally for risk of extinction…This is a clear indication that this species is not endangered or threatened.”

The letter also emphasizes the important and effective role of the states in managing recovered wolf populations. A complete copy of the letter is available HERE.

In the News

Wyoming ranchers, outfitter say seismic exploration hurt wells, deer hunting. Casper Star Tribune. Two south-central Wyoming ranchers and a hunting outfitter said seismic exploration on prime hunting land drove away deer, could harm water wells and hurt sage grouse protection. Ranchers Sharon Salisbury O’Toole and Patrick O’Toole complained to the Wyoming Oil and Gas Conservation Commission in person in Casper on Tuesday, saying the exploration company, GRMR Oil & Gas LLC of Broomfield, Colo., didn’t file a big enough bond for their work.

Bi-state sage grouse is threatened species. News Review. “Nevada has a pretty unique history in terms of coming up with relatively pragmatic, practical solutions around both development interests and conservation,” wildlife ecologist John Tull said. “We would want to see that the economic interests that are at play be able to continue to work in Nevada, so we don’t suffer any more in terms of our economic downslide. I think we’re recovering, but it’s been slow. And sage grouse, if they’re listed, and we don’t do anything, many things would probably come to a screeching halt.”

Neil Kornze picked to lead BLM. Denver Business Journal. Kornze faces confirmation by the U.S. Senate. U.S. Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, told the Salt Lake Tribune that while “the fact that Mr. Kornze is from the West is a good thing,” he plans to bring up such issues as sage grouse management and hydraulic fracturing as Kornze’s nomination is considered. In Colorado, some 1.7 million acres of BLM land are habitat for the greater sage grouse, whose dwindling numbers have led state and federal officials to weigh restrictions on energy development and grazing to protect the bird.

Energy Advisory Board hears Garfield County sage grouse presentation. Post Independent. rfield County officials made a presentation Thursday night to a packed Energy Advisory Board meeting about the county’s $200,000 greater sage grouse conservation plan.

BLM offers protections for sage grouse. Great Falls Tribune. The Lewistown office of the Bureau of Land Management released a plan Friday for public comment that proposes ways to protect sage grouse habitat on federal lands in central and eastern Montana. The bird, whose prairie habitat is declining across the West, could be federally protected under the Endangered Species Act if state and federal agencies don’t act first.

Don’t accept potential sage-grouse listing. Reno Gazette Journal (LTE by Rachael Krysiak, Reno). The recent news that the bi-state sage grouse is being considered for under the endangered species act only highlights that ambiguity. Nevada doesn’t have to accept this listing. In fact, there are active steps that we can take to protect the sage grouse. By collaborating on a solution, out-of-state and federal leaders have an opportunity to use conservation designations to preserve habitat while at the same providing the assurance that traditional ways of life, like hunting, grazing and mining, are maintained.

BLM issues power line decision: Landowners aim to fight planned path. Idaho State Journal. Legal counsel for the citizens’ task forces in both Power and Cassia county, Doug Balfour said the BLM decision came as no surprise. He said rules regarding sage grouse habitat are in flux and the federal agency based its placement decisions on old rules.   According to the BLM website on the Gateway West project, impacts to sage grouse habitat on public lands were analyzed and incorporated into the environmental statement.

Lawsuit Launched to Speed Recovery of Endangered California Frogs. Center for Biological Diversity (Press Release). The Center for Biological Diversity filed a formal notice of intent to sue the Interior Department today for failing to develop a recovery plan for Southern California’s mountain yellow-legged frogs. Although these frogs have been protected under the Endangered Species Act for over a decade, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has yet to develop the recovery plan that’s needed to save them from extinction.

]]>
/2013/11/15/esa-newsletter-11-15-13/feed/ 0
IPAA ESA Newsletter – 11/1/13 /2013/11/01/ipaa-esa-newsletter-11113/ /2013/11/01/ipaa-esa-newsletter-11113/#comments Fri, 01 Nov 2013 17:58:00 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=1036 Continue reading →]]> Issues

Coloradoans Concerned With Potential Sage Grouse Listing. In Colorado, commissioners from Garfield, Mesa, Moffat and Rio Blanco counties have called on Governor Hickenlooper to intervene in the Bureau of Land Management’s efforts to list the greater sage grouse under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). According to the Denver Post, the commissioners believe “the consequences of the Bureau of Land Management’s decision about how to manage 1.8 million acres of land extends well beyond the well-being of the bird.”

Governor Hickenlooper also reiterated his support for a state-based plan:

“Given the unique landscapes and natural resources in Colorado, a Colorado-based solution is more practical that one handed down by the federal government. We hope the Bureau of Land Management will look at the public-private partnerships that have been so successful in Colorado as a model on how to get things done.”

Comments to Congressional Endangered Species Act Working Group. The Congressional Endangered Species Act Working Group is requesting comments on Endangered Species Act (ESA) improvements. IPAA plans to submit comments to the working group but would appreciate your input on ESA improvements. Please send recommendations or comments you may have to Kristen Lingley at Klingley@ipaa.org by November 6, 2013.  If your company would like to submit individual comments, they can be submitted on the ESA Working Group Website HERE.

BLM Proposes Plans for Greater Sage Grouse. On Friday November 1st, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) released three proposed plans to protect the Greater sage grouse in Utah, Idaho, and Nevada along with parts of California and Montana. The proposed plans include three draft environmental impact statements (EIS) covering 31 million acres of sage grouse habitat on BLM and Forest Service lands. These drafts are a part of the National Greater Sage-Grouse Planning Strategy being developed to protect the sage grouse population across the west. The public has 90 days to submit comment. E&E News (sub req’d) and Deseret News reports on the news.

Western Energy Alliance Video on Protecting Wildlife While Producing Energy. The Western Energy Alliance has released a video on how oil and natural gas companies are producing energy while protecting our natural environment and wildlife.  The video features Brian Maxfield, Senior Biologist with the Utah Department of Natural Resources talking about a nesting project to protect breeding ferruginous hawks; and Denny Behrens of the Colorado Mule Deer Association describing habitat restoration projects funded by companies, even as the federal government decreases wildlife and habitat funding. Watch the full video HERE.

Arkansas Groups Dispute Critical Habitat Designation for Listed Mussels. This week, the Association of Arkansas Counties (ACC) and several other organizations submitted joint comment to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) regarding the proposed designation of critical habitat for two mussels listed under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The Neosho mucket, listed as endangered, and the Rabbitsfoot, listed as threatened, are both fresh water mussels found in the state. In their comments, the organizations urge a 36 percent reduction in the geographic area being proposed as critical habitat. According to the comments:

The Service’s proposed rule will designate a total of 769.2 river miles in Arkansas as critical habitat for Neosho muckets and rabbitsfoot mussels.  The proposed critical habitat designations will directly impact 31 Arkansas counties, and, if finalized as proposed, the targeted watershed will cover approximately 42% of the entire geographical area of Arkansas.

Randy Zook, President & CEO of the Arkansas State Chamber of Commerce/Associated Industries of Arkansas  emphasized the potential economic impacts such a listing could have in the Associations news release:

“The direct impact on the economic operation of counties, cities, agricultural operations and many business and industrial operations is potentially very costly. And the indirect impact of lost jobs, reduced or eliminated development, and avoidance of necessary repairs and improvements greatly increases the negative impact on our state’s economy. Additional damage to our economy will then follow in the form of lost tax revenue, increased unemployment claims, damage from unrepaired roads and bridges, and increases in transportation costs.”

The comments emphasize that a reduction in the critical habitat designation is supported by scientific findings and would better account for the social and economic impacts the current designation could have on the state. Read the Arkansas Association Counties news release HERE and the filed comments HERE.

In the News

Enviros to sue Interior, DOD over pumping’s impacts to river, endangered species. E&E News (sub req’d). Two environmental groups have notified the Interior and Defense departments that they plan to sue to force them to comply with a federal court order and develop a mitigation plan that would allow an Army base in Arizona to tap groundwater without harming the San Pedro River and two endangered species.

Proposal would list bistate sage grouse as threatened. Los Angeles Times. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has announced a proposal to list the bistate sage grouse as threatened under the Endangered Species Act, affording special protections to about 5,000 birds along the California-Nevada border.

Wyo. drilling proposal threatens prime sage grouse habitat — enviro petition. E&E News (sub req’d). A coalition of environmental groups is asking the Interior Department to slow down planned oil and natural gas drilling activity inside prime greater sage grouse habitat in eastern Wyoming. WildEarth Guardians recently sent a formal petition to Interior Secretary Sally Jewell asking the agency to exercise its authority over subsurface mineral rights in the area and forbid new well pads and associated infrastructure such as roads inside a state-designated core sage grouse area until it has finalized resource plan amendments designed to protect grouse in the region.

Comment due on mussel habitats in Ohio, elsewhere. Associated Press. The government is looking for additional public comment on a proposal to protect freshwater mussel habitats in Ohio and 11 other states. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has re-opened the public comment period until Monday. The old deadline was June 10. 

Santa Barbara Wildflower Proposed for Endangered Species Act Protection With 5,785 Acres of Critical Habitat. Center for Biological Diversity (Press Release). Following an agreement with the Center for Biological Diversity, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed Endangered Species Act protection today for a rare wildflower found only in Santa Barbara County. The proposal to protect the Vandenberg monkeyflower results from a 2011 settlement with the Center to speed decisions on 757 imperiled plants and animals across the country. The proposal includes 5,785 acres of protected habitat.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service reopens comment on wolverine threatened status. Missoulian. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is reopening public comment on a proposed rule to list the North American wolverine ast threatened under the Endangered Species Act. The service published the proposed rule – and a special rule to tailor Endangered Species Act prohibitions that would apply to the wolverine – in February and took public comment through May 6. 

Pennsylvania Game Commission tries to rescue dwindling number of bats. Tribune Live. Endangered species regulations have been responsible for delaying projects for Snyder Associated Companies for years, costing thousands of dollars for studies. The regulations also eliminated about 20 gravel-dredging jobs on the Allegheny River in 2009, although the company transferred most of those employees for other jobs. 

]]>
/2013/11/01/ipaa-esa-newsletter-11113/feed/ 0
IPAA ESA Newsletter – 10/25/13 /2013/10/25/ipaa-esa-newsletter-102513/ /2013/10/25/ipaa-esa-newsletter-102513/#comments Fri, 25 Oct 2013 15:21:22 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=1004 Continue reading →]]> Issues

Dunes Sagebrush Lizard Intervention Granted. This week, two motions to intervene in the proposed listing of the Dunes Sagebrush Lizard under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) were granted. The motions were brought by the Comptroller of Public Accounts of the State of Texas, Susan Combs, and collectively by the American Petroleum Institute, the Independent Petroleum Association of America, the New Mexico Oil and Gas Association, the Permian Basin Petroleum Association, and the Texas Oil & Gas Association.

According to the Summary Opinion and Order: “The applicants have moved to intervene in this matter as of right, or alternatively, for permissive intervention. Their motions have not been opposed. For the reasons that follow, the Court will grant both applicants’ motions to intervene.”

FWS Endorses WAFWA’s LPC Range-Wide Conservation Plan. This week, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) endorsed the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies’ (WAFWA) Lesser Prairie-Chicken Range-Wide Conservation Plan. The plan is a collaborative effort between Texas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Kansas and Colorado to conserve the bird while avoiding a federal listing under the Endangered Species Act (ESA).

FWS Service Director Dan Ashe expressed his support for the plan in a news release this week:

“The unprecedented collaborative efforts of WAFWA and the five state wildlife agencies have produced a sound conservation plan for the lesser prairie-chicken. We applaud the states’ commitment to lead conservation actions across the bird’s range.”

Carter Smith, WAFWA president and Texas Parks and Wildlife Department executive director, also stated his excitement:

“Years of due diligence have gone into this plan, guided by scientific research and monitoring, and developed with input from landowners, agriculture, wind and oil and gas interests and other stakeholders. We can now work at the local level to implement the plan, facilitate more conservation for the bird while allowing sustainable land use and responsible economic development, and hopefully preclude the need to list this species.”

Senator Jim Inhofe from Oklahoma, also supported the announcement in The Oklahoman stating the plan was “a good next step” to preclude a federal listing of the species.  Representative Tim Huelskamp (KS-1) also expressed his support, yet noted the need for continued monitoring of the potential listing.

“A listing threatens jobs, families, and the very way of life enjoyed by millions living in rural America. I encourage the administration to allow the range-wide conservation plan to do its work, to not list the bird, and allow the voluntary efforts of private individuals, state and local agencies to do their work in protecting the Lesser Prairie Chicken.”

Upcoming Comments on Surrogate and Programmatic ITS NOPR. The National Endangered Species Act Reform Coalition (NESARC) will be filing comments on the proposed rulemaking on the treatment of surrogates and programmatic actions in incidental take statements that are due on November 4, 2013. IPAA is also considering whether to file their own comments. If you would like to provide input on this proposed rulemaking please contact Kristen Lingley at Klingley@ipaa.org.

USDA Submits Comments on Proposed Lesser Prairie Chicken Listing. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) has submitted comments in regard to their concern over the proposed listing of the Lesser prairie chicken under the Endangered Species Act. According to their comments:

“Within USDA, three agencies, the Farm Service Agency (FSA), the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS), and the Forest Service (FS) have programs or activities that would be impacted by the potential listing of the LEPC.  USDA also notes that these programs or activities can be used to protect, enhance, or restore LEPC habitat, thus minimizing or eliminating the need for the listing. “

Read their full comments on how a federal listing of the LPC could impact wildlife and plants in the habitat region online at Regulations.gov.

In the News

Can the Sage Grouse and The Energy Boom Co-Exist? Montana Energy Review. The Greater Sage Grouse, a chicken-sized bird that is still hunted as game in many parts of the West, including Montana, is under consideration by the federal Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) for possible listing under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Potentially impacting 11 Western states, the designation could seal off large portions of the state from agricultural uses or energy development, including the development of renewable energy projects.

County preparing comments on sage grouse. Reno Gazette Journal. The Bi-State Sage Grouse population has been determined to be a distinct population from other sage grouse and they are found in areas of southern Lyon County. Arellano said besides the county submitting comments, it is important that residents submit comments about the listing.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Announces Western Yellow-Billed Cuckoo Proposed for Federal Protections. Sierra Sun Times (Press Release). On October 3, 2013, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) proposed to list the western distinct population segment (DPS) of the yellow-billed cuckoo as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) in the western United States, Canada, and Mexico. In the U.S., the western yellow-billed cuckoo is known to occur in Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Utah, Wyoming, Montana, Oregon, and Washington.

Sage grouse offer positive boost to economy. Craig Daily Press (Column – Sasha Nelson). Sadly, greater sage grouse are on a path to extinction. The population has declined by as much as 99 percent from historical levels. In 2010, they became candidates for protection as an endangered species. Sage grouse are suffering because natural systems are out of balance.

Three Rare Caribbean Plants Proposed for Endangered Species Act Protection. eNews Park Forest (Press Release). Following lawsuits brought by the Center for Biological Diversity, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed Endangered Species Act protection today for three rare plants from the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. Egger’s agave, island brittleleaf and Puerto Rico manjack are imminently threatened by land development and have been on a waiting list for federal protection since 1980.

Bill would change rules protecting endangered species. Williamsport Gazette. The process of how Pennsylvania determines which wildlife species are endangered is the subject of the Endangered Species Coordination Act – House Bill 1576. The bill was proposed by Rep. Jeff Pyle, R-Kittanning. It proposes a new review process for listing and delisting endangered species, along with a new database of where developers might have to watch out for species when they’re building.

]]>
/2013/10/25/ipaa-esa-newsletter-102513/feed/ 0
IPAA ESA Newsletter – 10/11/13 /2013/10/11/ipaa-esa-newsletter-101113/ /2013/10/11/ipaa-esa-newsletter-101113/#comments Fri, 11 Oct 2013 14:10:16 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=961 Continue reading →]]> Issues

Forum Highlights Concerns Surrounding the ESA. Yesterday, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) Congressional Working Group held a forum entitled “Reviewing 40 Years of the Endangered Species Act and Seeking Improvement for People and Species.” The meeting included a diverse group of stakeholders focused on discussing the ESA’s history, its impacts on people and species, and potential improvements to the Act moving forward.

House Natural Resources Committee Chairman and Working Group Co-Chair Doc Hastings (R-WA) presided over the Forum, alongside other members of the Working Group in attendance including Co-Chair Cynthia Lummis (R-WY), Rob Bishop (R-UT), Bill Huizenga (R-MI), James Lankford (R-OK), Blaine Luetkemeyer (R-MO), Randy Neugebauer (R-TX), and David Valadao (R-CA).

Stakeholders present at the meetings included Michigan State Senator Tom Casperson (R), who spoke about the lengthy and complicated process of delisting of the gray wolf in 2012,  Captain William Beacom of Nav-Com Services, who discussed military base limitations that can be directly attributed to the ESA, and  Maria Gutierrez of El Agua Es Asunto de Todos, who noted the ESA’s impacts on the economies and livelihoods of many California Latino communities relying on limited water resources. Roger Marzulla of Marzulla Law LLC and  Mike Wood, a business representative of Carpenters Industrial Council, also spoke of their concerns with the current ESA.

For additional information on the Forum or to watch a webcast of the event click HERE.

“Sue and Settles” Impact on ESA Listings. This week, Stephen Moore, a member of the Wall Street Journal’s editorial board, highlighted the impact of “sue and settle” cases on new federal regulations and Endangered Species Act (ESA) listings. As Mr. Moore explains, the practice of “sue and settle” has increased over recent years with groups like the Center for Biological Diversity and WildEarth Guardians petitioning the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) to list species as endangered – and then quickly filing lawsuits against the FWS to force regulatory action.

According to Mr. Moore:

“Next March, Fish and Wildlife will make a determination about whether to add the lesser prairie chicken, found in Texas, Oklahoma, New Mexico and Kansas to the list. Harold Hamm, president of Continental Resources, says that the habitat for the prairie chicken overlaps ‘some of the most promising land for oil and gas leases in the country.’

“Many Westerners suspect that this environmental activism isn’t only or even mostly about saving species and obscure subspecies. Instead, it is about restricting land use on hundreds of thousands of acres of private and state land. The concern is that if these species are listed as endangered, their habitat could be placed off limits for economic development.”

Read the full article from the Wall Street Journal’s editorial board member HERE.

In the News

Blue-Throated Macaw Gets Listing Protection. Courthouse News. Twenty-two years after Endangered Species Act protection was first requested, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service listed Bolivia’s blue-throated macaw as endangered throughout its range. Since proposing the change in January, the agency has gathered new information indicating that the population in the wild is “likely between 350 and 400 individuals,” up from the 150 cited in the listing proposal, but still far below healthy population levels.

Feds stall oil, gas drilling projects. Elko Daily Free Press (Guest Column – Thomas Mitchell). Timothy Considine (University of Wyoming) found that development of oil, natural gas, and coal resources on federal lands are often mired in a regulatory bog, while huge tracks of land — that are home to threatened and endangered species and greatly affect the viewshed — are fast-tracked for use for solar panels and wind turbines. In Nevada alone, Considine estimates oil and gas projects on public land could generate tax revenues of as much as $218 million and create as many as 21,797 new jobs — as many as 200,000 jobs in the seven-state region.

Fish & Wildlife Service Proposes Endangered Species Act Protections for Red Knots. NRDC’s Switchboard (Blog). After traveling to Quebec’s Mingan Archipelago to tag these remarkable birds just a few weeks ago, I recently received wonderful news that the Fish and Wildlife Service has proposed to list them as threatened species under the Endangered Species Act.

County receives criticism for its trapping plan. Elko Daily Free Press. The pilot project is a response to a possible 2015 decision to include sage grouse on the endangered species list. The county hopes to demonstrate that sage-grouse populations will increase with predator control and fire prevention through cattle grazing. Commissioner Charlie Myers said he’s concerned the state hasn’t participated in enough “on the ground” conservation projects.

Butterfly and Lark Win and Lose Protections. Courthouse News. A recent U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service action was a mixed bag for the Pacific Northwest’s streaked horned lark and Taylor’s checkerspot butterfly. The lark was granted threatened status and the butterfly was granted endangered status under the Endangered Species Act, but the agency slashed the proposed critical habitat for both species and added special exemptions from prohibitions against harming the lark.

Deal renews controversy over sage grouse protections. Wyoming Public Media. A deal to allow oil and gas development in a sage grouse conservation area near Douglas met considerable resistance when it was announced last month. Environmental groups said it set a dangerous precedent, and showed the state isn’t serious about keeping the bird off the endangered species list. The state said it was a necessary compromise that protects sage grouse while respecting private mineral rights.

]]>
/2013/10/11/ipaa-esa-newsletter-101113/feed/ 0
IPAA ESA Newsletter – 10/7/13 /2013/10/07/ipaa-esa-newsletter-10713/ /2013/10/07/ipaa-esa-newsletter-10713/#comments Mon, 07 Oct 2013 15:52:14 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=942 Continue reading →]]> Issues

NEXT WEEK: On October 10th, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) Congressional Working Group is set to hold a forum entitled “Reviewing 40 Years of the Endangered Species Act and Seeking Improvement for People and Species.” The forum is scheduled to include a diverse group of stakeholders focused on discussing the ESA’s history, its impacts on people and species, and potential improvements to the Act moving forward. The meeting will be held in Washington, DC in the 1300 Hearing Room in the Longworth House Office Building. Additional details, including any possible rescheduling due to the Government Shutdown, is available HERE.

Trades Call for Extension in Coral Listing. On September 30th,  the American Petroleum Institute (API), the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA), and the National Ocean Industries Association (NOIA) submitted a letter to the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS). The letter requests the NMFS extend by 30 days the deadline for its data collection effort in relation to a proposed listing of 66 species of coral in the Caribbean and Indo-Pacific under the Endangered Species Act (ESA).

In September 2012, NMFS announced a 6-month extension of the final rule deadline due to “substantial disagreements” in sufficiency of data and analysis relevant to the proposed listing determinations. The NMFS, however, allowed only 11 days to provide additional information relevant to the six key areas the NMFS noted contained large disagreements.

According to this week’s letter:

“Eleven days is simply not sufficient time for the Associations to evaluate the existence of, and provide, additional information relevant to the proposed listing. The Service’s proposed rule is unprecedented in its scope and breadth. Not only does the proposal attempt to evaluate extinction risks to 68 different species, it does so largely based on climate models that, as discussed in our previous comments, contain significant limitations, especially at the spatial and temporal scales relevant to the proposed listing. Evaluating the existence of new information on such a large number of species in a listing that is based on multiple scientific disciplines cannot be accomplished in 11 days.”

The associations also note that, while the 30 day extension for data collection is desirable, the initial proposal contains serious flaws that will not be remedied by new data alone.

NESARC Prepares Comments to FWS. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is collecting comments regarding a proposed regulation on the use of surrogates for quantification of take and the treatment of programmatic actions within incidental take statements. The National Endangered Species Act Reform Coalition, of which IPAA is a member, is drafting Coalition comments.

Federal Sage Grouse Plan Faces Criticism in North Dakota. The U.S. Bureau of Land Management released a new proposal aimed at establishing 33,000 acres of priority sage grouse habitat in the southwest of North Dakota. The proposal could limit oil and gas development, road building and off-highway vehicle use in the area. Ron Ness of the North Dakota Petroleum Council commented on the proposed plan in E&E News (sub. req’d):

“Ron Ness, president of the North Dakota Petroleum Council in Bismarck, said most of the area in question has already been drilled and that the industry worked with BLM to restore drilled areas and to protect sage grouse breeding areas, called leks, during production. ‘And all of a sudden, they now come in with what’s in essence a blanket roadless area,’ Ness said.

 

“’That’s why we have zero drilling rigs operating on federal lands in North Dakota,’ he added, despite the state’s booming Bakken Shale oil formation. ‘We’re very fortunate that 90 percent of the Bakken is on private lands.’”

The BLM notes that while the North Dakota sage grouse population is small, it is important to the overall health of the species. This is one of 15 draft environmental impact statements moving forward as a part of the BLM’s “National Greater Sage-Grouse Planning Strategy.” The draft is open for public comment until December 26th with plans for a final decision to be made in September 2014.  Read the full proposal HERE.

In the News

Criticism greets new federal plan for protecting sage grouse in N.D. E&E News (sub req’d). The Obama administration continues to roll out management plans covering thousands of acres that are designed to restore dwindling habitat for the imperiled greater sage grouse. […] The Fish and Wildlife Service has named the greater sage grouse a “candidate species” for listing under the Endangered Species Act, but the service is under a court order to make a final decision whether to list the bird by 2015.

Two Southeast Mussels Listed With Habitat. Courthouse News. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has listed the fluted kidneyshell and the slabside pearlymussel as endangered under the Endangered Species Act, and has designated 1380 river miles of critical habitat for the two mussel species in a separate action.

Enviro groups petition FWS for protection of 2 tortoises. E&E News (sub req’d). Environmentalists yesterday filed petitions asking for federal protection of two tortoise species that are threatened by the exotic pet trade. The spider tortoise and flat-tailed tortoise, both native to Madagascar and known for their patterned shells, are imperiled by deforestation in their homeland.

Protection sought for bats decimated by white-nose syndrome. Associated Press. The Richmond-based Center for Biological Diversity says the service has proposed granting Endangered Species Act protection to the northern long-eared bat, a species that has been devastated by the disease known as white-nose syndrome.

Missouri Fish Gets Listing, No Habitat. Courthouse News. The grotto sculpin, a cave-dwelling fish found in only one county in Missouri, has been listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act, but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service declined to designate critical habitat for it due to community efforts.

Rare Ala. fish that lives near explosive growth gets new protected status. E&E News (sub req’d). The Obama administration today granted protections for a rare Alabama fish that may result in critical habitat designations near the fastest-growing city in the state. The Fish and Wildlife Service finalized a rule that makes the spring pygmy sunfish a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act.

For some, rare birds mean more government. Amarillo Globe News. But as is frequently the case in debates about threatened species, the private landowner has the most at stake — and often seems absent from the negotiating table. That is especially true for Texas and the lesser prairie chicken, whose U.S. population has decreased to 17,000 from 34,000 in the past year

Logic and the endangered species act. Santa Maria Times (Op-Ed by David Pratt, Santa Maria Energy). For those who are intent upon opposing energy projects, the California Endangered Species Act has often proven itself useful for delaying or preventing energy development. And there are a lot of endangered species in Santa Barbara County. One is the California tiger salamander, an amphibian found in a number of areas north of the Gaviota Pass.

Two Rare Arizona Cactuses Gain Endangered Species Act Protection. eNews Park Forest (Press Release). The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service granted Endangered Species Act protection today to two highly imperiled cactuses found in northern and southern Arizona. Protection for the Acuña cactus and Fickeisen plains cactus results from a 2011 settlement with the Center for Biological Diversity requiring the agency to speed protection decisions for 757 species across the country.

]]>
/2013/10/07/ipaa-esa-newsletter-10713/feed/ 0
The Endangered Species Act has Failed /2013/09/27/the-endangered-species-act-has-failed/ /2013/09/27/the-endangered-species-act-has-failed/#comments Fri, 27 Sep 2013 14:15:00 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=908 Continue reading →]]> By Congressman Rob Bishop (Ut-01)

rep rob bishopThe Endangered Species Act (ESA) was signed into law by President Richard Nixon on December 28, 1973. Since then, 2095 species have been placed on the endangered species list. Over the past forty years only 30 species are considered to be recovered. The law’s lack of success, which falls just under 2%, can be attributed to its misuse. The original purpose of the ESA was to protect threatened species.  However, the law has become a tool by activist groups and the federal government to shut down development and place limitations on land use. The ESA has sadly become a resource to achieve a much broader agenda that goes beyond the recovery of species.

The ESA is one of the most effective roadblocks to limiting land use.  The mere consideration of a plant or animal species as a candidate for an ESA listing has proven capable of shutting down home energy development, agriculture, logging, mining, fire mitigation, ranching, and recreation on both public and private lands. For radical environmental groups, it is one of the most effective arrows in their quiver.  It is also one of the few laws that give the federal government the authority to trample on our most basic property rights.

There is ample evidence of the ESA being used to systematically stop development from occurring. In my home state of Utah, the listing of the Gunnison Sage Grouse has effectively blocked energy development in a section of San Juan County that is known to be rich in oil and gas resources. Despite the abundant opportunities for development, the Gunnison Sage Grouse’s listing has thwarted potential development in this area.

The level of impact that the ESA has on industries and communities in Utah and other states around the country is staggering. It decimated the agriculture community in California’s Central Valley, shifted oil and gas producers away from federally owned lands, and has prevented many other industries from making good use of otherwise fallow federal land.  I recall an account where Geologist Don Fife asked a U.S. Forest Service (USFS) employee about the listing of a prominent weed and was told that “everybody knows they’re not really endangered we just need them to stop mining.” Later, Don Fife successfully secured a signed affidavit that said “[USFS] staff had volunteers collect the seeds for these ESA-listed plants and spread them in the forest to stop mining and recreation on up to 44,575 acres of the mineral-rich forest.”

The fact remains that many species are erroneously listed as endangered or threatened. This is often the result of flawed or manipulated scientific research. Such is the case regarding the Greater Sage Grouse. Recently discovered documents between U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service employees show efforts to reverse engineer data to ensure that, regardless of what the scientific data show, the Greater Sage Grouse would be listed. In the meantime, ranchers, farmers, and other land users are frantically scrambling and spending thousands of their hard earned dollars to protect themselves, their land, and their livelihoods against the repercussions of the listing. This is not what was intended to become of the ESA but thanks to activist judges and an overly litigious society, radical environmentalists have succeeded in corrupting the law as a way to advance their political agendas.

The threat of lawsuit has also proven to effectively incentivize the federal government to seek out of court settlements for pending petitions. Facing onerous legal fees and court battles, settlements have proven to be a less costly route for the federal government and a quicker way for special interest groups to achieve their desired goal. This process is concerning for many reasons, including the fact that it occurs behind closed doors and there is little accountability or transparency required of either party. This is a boon for lawyers and special interest groups, and through the Equal Access to Justice Act, the American people are left holding the bill.

There is no question that the ESA must be reformed. It’s ineffective and costly and allows radical special interest groups to run rough shod over the interests of the American people. Congressman Doc Hastings (WA-04), who serves as Chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, recently established the Endangered Species Act Working Group. The group is actively working to find solutions and reforms that will prevent abuse of the law while also ensuring that deserving species are protected.

The real solution isn’t more federal involvement, but less. State land managers have proven to be far more successful at species recovery and management. The Grey Wolf is a great example. The states worked with stakeholders to develop and implement plans to help this species thrive. Ironically, the greatest hindrance to their efforts was the federal government. If the federal government would relinquish control to the states with regards to management of endangered plant and animal species, we would see enhanced conservation and recovery programs. These days, less federal involvement seems to be the solution to just about all of our problems and endangered species is certainly not an exception.

A public school teacher turned public servant, Congressman Rob Bishop represents Utah’s First Congressional District in the U.S. Congress. Rob is now in his sixth term in the House.  Rep. Bishop serves on the House Armed Services Committee, the powerful House Rules Committee, and the Committee on Natural Resources where he is Chairman of the Public Lands and Environmental Regulation Subcommittee.

]]>
/2013/09/27/the-endangered-species-act-has-failed/feed/ 0
IPAA ESA Newsletter – 9/27/13 /2013/09/27/910/ /2013/09/27/910/#comments Fri, 27 Sep 2013 14:13:50 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=910 Continue reading →]]> Issues

Trade Associations Active on ESA Issues This Week. On Friday, September 20th, the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA), American Petroleum Institute (API), Permian Basin Petroleum Association (PBPA), and New Mexico Oil & Gas Association (NMOGA) filed their petition to intervene in the case where the Center for Biological Diversity is challenging the Department of Interior’s decision to not list the dunes sagebrush lizard. Read the full petition on the ESA Watch website HERE.

The National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) has also announced it is extending the deadline for a final determination on the listing of sixty six species of reef-building corals under the Endangered Species Act. API, IPAA, and the National Ocean Industries Association (NOIA) commented on the proposed listings in April 2013. The areas of uncertainty noted by the NMFS closely mirror comments API, IPAA, and NOIA jointly submitted including:

  • Interpretation of the data relating to extinction risk and proposed species’ listing statuses;
  • The sufficiency and quality, or lack thereof, of the species-specific information used for each species’ proposed listing determination;
  • The accuracy of the methods used to analyze the available information to assess extinction risk (including NMFS’s ‘‘Determination Tool’’) and derive listing statuses for each of the proposed species;
  • The ability of corals to adapt or acclimatize to ocean warming and acidification;
  • The reliability, certainty, scale, and variability of future modeling and predictions of climate change;
  • The effect local management efforts have on coral resilience.

NMFS stated the agency, based on comments received during the public comment period, needs an additional six months to collect additional information and reconcile data conflicts. A link to the federal register notice can be found HERE.

ESA and the Keystone XL Debate. This week, the Center for Biological Diversity released a new analysis regarding the Keystone XL pipeline’s impact on endangered species. The analysis claims the State Department’s review of the proposed pipeline route underestimates the project’s impact on endangered species.  The State Department’s draft environmental impact statement, however, found the pipeline – following certain safeguards — would cause “no significant impacts to most resources along the proposed project route.” The ESA Watch team will be keeping an eye on this debate as it moves forward.

LPC Debate Continues to Impact Texas Landowners. An article in the Texas Tribune this week highlighted the Lesser prairie chicken (LPC) debate in Texas. The article, which was also featured in the New York Times, discussed the impact such a listing would have on ranchers in the habitat region, noting a federal listing could mean fines or large penalties for landowners who have birds injured on their property. According to the article:

“’This is very serious, and it very well could put our 100-year operation out of business,’ said Evertt Harrel, whose West Texas family cattle ranch has long been a home to lesser prairie chickens. A chunk of it, like many in Texas, is leased for oil and gas activities.

 

“…’Everybody’s just too busy trying to make a living to survive the drought, pay their taxes and put food on the table,’ said Jeff Haley, who also raises cattle on chicken habitat near the Oklahoma border in the Texas Panhandle. ‘They’re resentful of the fact that outside forces would be trying to tell them what they can and can’t do on their own place.’”

The Texas Parks and Wildlife Department and others are working to promote Range-wide Plans where oil and natural gas companies would pay landowners a fee to maintain and offset disturbances to the LPC’s habitat while avoiding a federal listing. Other plans promoted by the Environmental Defense Fund and operators in the region would utilize wildlife habitat exchanges to protect the bird.  The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is set to make a final listing determination for the LPC by March 30, 2014.

In the News

Energy companies seek compromise in prairie chicken listing. KFDA. Five states, including Texas, have submitted the fourth draft of a conservation plan for the lesser prairie chicken. This comes after the bird was proposed to be listed as “threatened” under the endangered species act. If the species is classified as endangered, stricter federal regulations for land use will be put in place.

ESA listing could undercut Washington’s economy. Bonney Lake Courher-Herald (Column by Don Brunell). Last December, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) proposed to list several subspecies of the Mazama pocket gopher in Washington as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Why should we care? Because this listing will come at a very high price — a price we will all pay.

U.S. Agency Lists Nevada Butterfly as Endangered. Courthouse News. A rare Nevada butterfly has been listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act, but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service declined to list five others that were proposed for listing at the same time. The Mount Charleston blue butterfly lives only in the high elevations of the Spring Mountains National Recreation Area about 25 miles west of Las Vegas, Nev.

Timber industry suffers as loggers blame federal regs for lost jobs. Fox News. While Rough and Ready sits in the middle of America’s richest timber country, the federal government owns 80 percent of the land. Many in these decimated small towns blame The Endangered Species Act, which paved the way for a flood of lawsuits blocking federal timber sales, because of an endangered species in the region.

Draft Sage Grouse Plan Gets Pushback from Feds. Montana Energy Review. A document that is purportedly a preliminary draft of a Montana sage grouse conservation strategy has received initial pushback from the federal Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) as lacking sufficient surface occupancy restrictions and not doing enough to discourage land conversion for agricultural purposes.

New Study Shows Steep Decline of Lesser Prairie Chicken Populations. Center for Biological Diversity (Press Release). Lesser prairie chicken population numbers dropped by more than 50 percent over the past year, according to a study released today. The finding raises questions about the adequacy of voluntary conservation measures proposed today for the rare grouse in a final rangewide conservation plan intended to preclude the need for Endangered Species Act protections.

Sage grouse under Endangered Species Act review. Boulder Weekly. The sage grouse, with pointed back feathers like a crown and yellow eyes, is under review for endangered species status by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Sage grouse, as their name suggests, occupy the sagebrush country of the northwest U.S. and some of southern Canada, an area highly contested among the sage grouse, ranchers and the oil and gas industry.

BLM Wyo. plan won’t prevent sage grouse listing — conservation group. E&E News (sub req’d). The American Bird Conservancy is concerned that BLM’s “preferred alternative” would open up too much known sage grouse habitat to development, resulting in a greater likelihood that the bird will soon be listed under the Endangered Species Act, said Steve Holmer, ABC’s senior policy adviser.

Sagebrush study to improve native grasses, sage grouse habitat. CDA Press. Thinning old sagebrush stands may give sage grouse more high-quality habitat to spread their wings and prosper. University of Idaho Extension faculty members plan to test that idea, and whether younger, sparser sagebrush stands can help restore populations of the iconic Western bird.

]]>
/2013/09/27/910/feed/ 0
IPAA ESA Newsletter – 9/20/13 /2013/09/20/ipaa-esa-newsletter-92013/ /2013/09/20/ipaa-esa-newsletter-92013/#comments Fri, 20 Sep 2013 17:56:32 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=884 Continue reading →]]> Issues

FWS Announces Assessment for the Gunnison Sage-Grouse. This week, the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) released a draft economic analysis and draft environmental assessment regarding a proposal to designate 1.7 million acres of critical habitat for the Gunnison sage-grouse in southeastern Utah and southwestern Colorado. According to the FWS:

“The economic analysis estimates the economic impacts of Gunnison sage-grouse conservation efforts associated with livestock grazing, agriculture and water management, mineral and fossil fuel extraction, residential and related development, renewable energy development, recreation, and transportation activities. Only areas that contain habitat essential to the conservation of the species and where the benefits of this habitat outweigh potential economic impacts will be included in the final designation. The Service will use the draft environmental assessment to help decide whether critical habitat will be designated as proposed, if the proposed action requires refinement, or if further analysis is needed through preparation of an environmental impact statement.”

The FWS is reopening the public comment period on the proposal to list the species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and designate critical habitat until October 19, 2013. The FWS draft economic analysis is available HERE. The draft environmental assessment is available HERE.

Rep. Bishop Flags Mismanagement of the Hookless Cactus. Today, Representative Rob Bishop of Utah’s 1st District submitted a letter to Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell regarding the US Fish and Wildlife Service’s (FWS) management of the Hookless Cactus, a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). In his letter, Rep. Bishop highlights concerns regarding how the FWS’s management of the cactus is hindering energy development in the Uintah Basin. Both the state and the Tribe’s Reservation rely on the development of the Uintah Basin’s extensive energy resources for employment, funding, and investment. Read the full letter to the Secretary HERE.

WAFWA Announces Further Efforts to Conserve the Lesser Prairie Chicken. This week the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (WAFWA) released the 4th Version of its Lesser Prairie-Chicken (LPC) Range-wide Conservation Plan (RWP). According to WAFWA, the document reflects input gathered over 70 meetings with industry and agricultural stakeholders across the LPC’s five state range. It also includes over 300 comments received in response to earlier drafts. Read the full plan HERE.

Wyoming Opens Land for Energy Development While Protecting Sage Grouse. The state of Wyoming and Chesapeake Energy have worked out a plan to enable oil production while maintaining and protecting the state’s sage grouse population. The agreement modifies existing sage grouse habitat protections to enable energy development in Douglas County where the company holds oil and gas leases. In 2011, Wyoming established these areas as part of the state’s plan to conserve sage grouse habitat and avoid a federal listing of the bird under the Endangered Species Act (ESA).  The area is divided into three areas with differing levels of conservation protection.  As NPR explains:

“Ten percent of the area is classified as prime sage grouse habitat and is excluded from drilling activity for the next three years. Another 20 percent is subject to some restrictions on when and where drilling can happen. The rest of the area is categorized as low-quality habitat, and is mostly open to development.”

Chesapeake has also committed $2.8 million to restore sage grouse habitat in the Douglas Core Area, emphasizing its role as both an energy developer and environmental steward of the habitat region.

In the News

County launches own study to check sage-grouse habitat. Sky-Hi News. To avoid listing the bird as an endangered species, the U.S. Bureau of Land Management, which manages 52 percent of the greater sage-grouse national lands, has partnered with the U.S. Forest Service, Colorado Parks and Wildlife and other agencies on environmental impact statements recommending ways to protect the birds.

Nev.’s blue butterfly listed as endangered species. Associated Press. Nevada’s iridescent Mount Charleston Blue Butterfly will get extra protection under the Endangered Species Act. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service this week officially classified the delicate gray and baby blue insect as endangered.

Apache Donates 1 Millionth Tree For Black Bear Habitat. Wall Street Journal (Press Release). The Louisiana black bear was listed as “threatened” in 1992 under the guidelines of the Endangered Species Act. The decline of the black bear species was attributed to habitat loss, significant habitat alteration, reduction of the bears’ range and unregulated harvesting. Primarily due to the development of row-crop agriculture, 80 percent of the forestland in the Lower Mississippi River Valley was cleared.

Gunnison sage grouse listing, protection will cost millions to Utah, Colorado. Deseret News. A newly-released economic analysis predicts that federal protection of Gunnison sage grouse habitat in Utah and Colorado will cost as much as $12 million over the next 20 years.

WVa wind farm could kill dozens of endangered bats. Associated Press. The estimated death toll comes as Beech Ridge Energy requests a permit under the federal Endangered Species Act that would allow the “incidental take,” or killing, of endangered bats that collide with the turbines. The law, however, requires permit applicants to meet a certain threshold for minimizing damage to endangered wildlife.

Colo. habitat expansion gets oil and gas industry support. E&E News (sub req’d). Colorado’s oil and gas regulatory agency agreed yesterday to expand the acreage in formally designated sensitive wildlife habitat areas that require the industry to consult with state wildlife officials and avoid impacts before drilling wells.

Mono Supervisors: access road, new facility and Sage Grouse. Sierra Wave. In other matters, the [Mono County] Board may send a letter U.S. Fish and Wildlife to oppose the listing of the Bi-State Sage Grouse as endangered. A proposed letter from the Board says a special working group is taking steps to protect the Sage Grouse and more is not needed.

Critter under controversy: should lesser prairie chicken be “threatened”? Lubbock Avalanche-Journal. Listing the lesser prairie chicken as a threatened species could protect its habitat and save the bird from extinction, say supporters.

]]>
/2013/09/20/ipaa-esa-newsletter-92013/feed/ 0