The ESA Watch » Special Reports a policy watch site on the Endangered Species Act Fri, 13 Dec 2013 22:24:27 +0000 en-US hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.5.1 The Endangered Species Act has Failed /2013/09/27/the-endangered-species-act-has-failed/ /2013/09/27/the-endangered-species-act-has-failed/#comments Fri, 27 Sep 2013 14:15:00 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=908 Continue reading →]]> By Congressman Rob Bishop (Ut-01)

rep rob bishopThe Endangered Species Act (ESA) was signed into law by President Richard Nixon on December 28, 1973. Since then, 2095 species have been placed on the endangered species list. Over the past forty years only 30 species are considered to be recovered. The law’s lack of success, which falls just under 2%, can be attributed to its misuse. The original purpose of the ESA was to protect threatened species.  However, the law has become a tool by activist groups and the federal government to shut down development and place limitations on land use. The ESA has sadly become a resource to achieve a much broader agenda that goes beyond the recovery of species.

The ESA is one of the most effective roadblocks to limiting land use.  The mere consideration of a plant or animal species as a candidate for an ESA listing has proven capable of shutting down home energy development, agriculture, logging, mining, fire mitigation, ranching, and recreation on both public and private lands. For radical environmental groups, it is one of the most effective arrows in their quiver.  It is also one of the few laws that give the federal government the authority to trample on our most basic property rights.

There is ample evidence of the ESA being used to systematically stop development from occurring. In my home state of Utah, the listing of the Gunnison Sage Grouse has effectively blocked energy development in a section of San Juan County that is known to be rich in oil and gas resources. Despite the abundant opportunities for development, the Gunnison Sage Grouse’s listing has thwarted potential development in this area.

The level of impact that the ESA has on industries and communities in Utah and other states around the country is staggering. It decimated the agriculture community in California’s Central Valley, shifted oil and gas producers away from federally owned lands, and has prevented many other industries from making good use of otherwise fallow federal land.  I recall an account where Geologist Don Fife asked a U.S. Forest Service (USFS) employee about the listing of a prominent weed and was told that “everybody knows they’re not really endangered we just need them to stop mining.” Later, Don Fife successfully secured a signed affidavit that said “[USFS] staff had volunteers collect the seeds for these ESA-listed plants and spread them in the forest to stop mining and recreation on up to 44,575 acres of the mineral-rich forest.”

The fact remains that many species are erroneously listed as endangered or threatened. This is often the result of flawed or manipulated scientific research. Such is the case regarding the Greater Sage Grouse. Recently discovered documents between U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service employees show efforts to reverse engineer data to ensure that, regardless of what the scientific data show, the Greater Sage Grouse would be listed. In the meantime, ranchers, farmers, and other land users are frantically scrambling and spending thousands of their hard earned dollars to protect themselves, their land, and their livelihoods against the repercussions of the listing. This is not what was intended to become of the ESA but thanks to activist judges and an overly litigious society, radical environmentalists have succeeded in corrupting the law as a way to advance their political agendas.

The threat of lawsuit has also proven to effectively incentivize the federal government to seek out of court settlements for pending petitions. Facing onerous legal fees and court battles, settlements have proven to be a less costly route for the federal government and a quicker way for special interest groups to achieve their desired goal. This process is concerning for many reasons, including the fact that it occurs behind closed doors and there is little accountability or transparency required of either party. This is a boon for lawyers and special interest groups, and through the Equal Access to Justice Act, the American people are left holding the bill.

There is no question that the ESA must be reformed. It’s ineffective and costly and allows radical special interest groups to run rough shod over the interests of the American people. Congressman Doc Hastings (WA-04), who serves as Chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, recently established the Endangered Species Act Working Group. The group is actively working to find solutions and reforms that will prevent abuse of the law while also ensuring that deserving species are protected.

The real solution isn’t more federal involvement, but less. State land managers have proven to be far more successful at species recovery and management. The Grey Wolf is a great example. The states worked with stakeholders to develop and implement plans to help this species thrive. Ironically, the greatest hindrance to their efforts was the federal government. If the federal government would relinquish control to the states with regards to management of endangered plant and animal species, we would see enhanced conservation and recovery programs. These days, less federal involvement seems to be the solution to just about all of our problems and endangered species is certainly not an exception.

A public school teacher turned public servant, Congressman Rob Bishop represents Utah’s First Congressional District in the U.S. Congress. Rob is now in his sixth term in the House.  Rep. Bishop serves on the House Armed Services Committee, the powerful House Rules Committee, and the Committee on Natural Resources where he is Chairman of the Public Lands and Environmental Regulation Subcommittee.

]]>
/2013/09/27/the-endangered-species-act-has-failed/feed/ 0
Services Propose Using “Surrogates” to Evaluate Level of Incidental Take of Listed Species /2013/09/13/services-propose-using-surrogates-to-evaluate-level-of-incidental-take-of-listed-species/ /2013/09/13/services-propose-using-surrogates-to-evaluate-level-of-incidental-take-of-listed-species/#comments Fri, 13 Sep 2013 15:57:41 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=858 Continue reading →]]> WPM High Resolution Photo  Moore-W-highresBy W. Parker Moore

Be careful what you ask for.  That old standby bears repeating with the recent proposal of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service (Services) to amend their Endangered Species Act (ESA) regulations to provide greater flexibility when developing Incidental Take Statements (ITSs) for projects.  By formalizing the Services’ use of “surrogates” in ITSs to determine the anticipated level of take of listed species and estimate takes that result, the proposal could streamline project development in some circumstances.  If drafted inartfully, however, the new rule could lead to more problems than solutions.

The ITS program is straightforward in design.  The ESA requires federal agencies to consult with the Services before doing anything (issuing a permit, approving a project, funding an activity) that may result in the take of a listed species.  That consultation produces a biological opinion (BiOp) identifying the expected impact on protected species.  If the BiOp concludes that the proposed action is not likely to jeopardize the species, then the Services may issue an ITS describing the amount or extent of “incidental take” anticipated, imposing conditions on the activity to minimize its impact, and requiring monitoring of that impact so that the Services may reinitiate consultation if the impact is greater than expected.

Unfortunately, despite its uncomplicated design, the ITS program often is complicated to implement.  Over the years, the Services have had trouble developing ITSs for certain types of activities and for certain species when the nature of the activity and/or species at issue makes it difficult to detect or monitor take of individual animals.  The process is further complicated when the expected impact of the activity is indirect or delayed (e.g., impacts from habitat degradation), rather than direct and immediate.

To address these problems, the Services began using “surrogates” in ITSs when they concluded that it would be too difficult to monitor the amount of incidental take from an activity and thus determine when consultation should be reinitiated.  So, for example, instead of requiring a company to quantify the precise number of owls taken during logging, the ITS would require the company to monitor the area of owl habitat impacted.  This helped to expedite the ITS process for those difficult projects.  But it also drew the ire of environmental groups, which began challenging BiOps supported with surrogate-based ITSs.

On September 4, 2013, the Services made a move to sure up their position by proposing to codify the surrogate policy in their ESA regulations.  78 Fed. Reg. 54437 (amending 50 C.F.R. § 402.02).  The proposed rule would establish standards for using surrogates – such as a species’ habitat or similarly affected species in the project area – in ITSs “to express the amount or extent of incidental take” from an action.  Specifically, it would support the use of a surrogate as long as the ITS (1) describes “the causal link between the surrogate and take of the listed species,” (2) describes why it would not be practical to express the amount or extent of anticipated take or to monitor take-related impacts in terms of individuals of a listed species, and (3) sets forth “a clear standard” for determining when the extent of take has been exceeded.

The Services’ proposal presents a good news/bad news situation for industry.  The good news is that formalizing the use of surrogates in appropriate ITSs could eliminate some of the delays associated with the ESA’s consultation process.  That could allow projects to progress more quickly and begin to free up agency time and resources, which the Services could direct towards the next projects in the queue.  And in the abstract, codifying the policy in binding regulations should make it easier for the Services to defend BiOps with surrogate-based ITSs in court.  Thus, the proposed rule could provide some measure of certainty to projects proponents.

But the potential bad news should not be overlooked.  Setting defined standards for using surrogates in ITSs will provide opponents with ready-made lawsuits for challenging Service decisions and the projects they cover.  And because it is reasonable to expect the Services to use surrogates in the ITSs for more projects once the policy is formalized, it also is reasonable to expect that surrogate opponents will file more lawsuits.  Compounding the problem, the Services have not elaborated on the three conditions that would justify using surrogates in an ITS.  If they fail to do so when issuing the final rule, significant additional delays and uncertainty likely would result as courts scramble to answer the myriad questions raised in opponents’ lawsuits:  What constitutes a sufficient “causal link” between the surrogate and the taken species?  What level of impracticality must the Services demonstrate before using surrogates?  What constitutes a “clear standard” for evaluating the level of take?

Moreover, there is a concrete risk that the Service’s rulemaking will cause them to look to surrogates inappropriately when making other ESA decisions.  It is not hard to imagine the Services trying to use surrogates alone to decide whether a proposed action might take a species, and thus whether an ITS is needed in the first place.  Nor is it hard to imagine the Services attempting to repackage information collected from monitoring effects to a surrogate used for evaluating impacts to a particular species from one project as evidence of impacts to that species, or even other species, from an unrelated project.

Outside of the ITS process, the potential pitfalls may be more troubling.  The Services already have attempted to use surrogates (in particular, temporary habitat modification) to presume that a listed species will be taken by a project, to impose substantial mitigation requirements on projects, and to require detailed environmental analyses under NEPA for activities that should qualify for categorical exclusions.

For all of these reasons, it is important for entities that rely on incidental take authorizations for their projects to weigh in on the proposal.  Their input on problems with the proposed rule will help to educate the Services about the potential real world implications and hopefully avoid the misuse of an otherwise promising policy.  And their input on the aspects of the proposal they support will help to counter the criticisms of opponents, who already have begun rattling their sabers while vowing to marginalize the Services’ use of surrogates in ITSs.

Comments on the proposed rule are due November 4, 2013.

W. Parker Moore is a principal with Beveridge & Diamond, P.C., where he co-chairs the firm’s Environmental Practice Group and its NEPA/Wetlands/ESA Section.  His practice focuses on the siting, permitting and defense of projects under NEPA, the Clean Water Act, and the Endangered Species Act.

]]>
/2013/09/13/services-propose-using-surrogates-to-evaluate-level-of-incidental-take-of-listed-species/feed/ 0
IPAA Submits Joint Comments to FWS on Proposed Lesser Prairie Chicken Listing /2013/06/21/ipaa-submits-joint-comments-to-fws-on-proposed-lesser-prairie-chicken-listing/ /2013/06/21/ipaa-submits-joint-comments-to-fws-on-proposed-lesser-prairie-chicken-listing/#comments Fri, 21 Jun 2013 21:16:45 +0000 Julia Bell /?p=628 Continue reading →]]> On June 20, 2013, the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA), alongside oil and gas trade groups from across the country, submitted comments to the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) regarding the Proposed Special Rule under Section 4(d) of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) that would accompany the potential listing of the Lesser prairie-chicken (LPC) as threatened under the ESA.

IPAA, along with the American Petroleum Institute, America’s Natural Gas Alliance, Colorado Oil and Gas Association, International Association of Drilling Contractors, Mid-Continent Oil and Gas Association of Oklahoma, New Mexico Oil and Gas Association, Oklahoma Independent Petroleum Association, Panhandle Producers & Royalty Owners Association, and Western Energy Alliance (collectively “the Associations”), detailed in its comments the Associations’ belief that the FWS’s final determination must be that listing the LPC as “threatened” is not warranted. The Associations’ March 11, 2013 comments echoed this same message. Read more on the March comments on the ESA Watch website.

As detailed in the Associations’ comments this week, the oil and natural gas industry is committed to conservation of the LPC. Companies active in the habitat region including Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas implement LPC avoidance, minimization, and mitigation measures, and provide funding and support for important LPC conservation efforts throughout the region. While the fact that the Service has proposed a 4(d) Special Rule is positive, the rule outlined in the proposal is far too narrow and unnecessarily restrictive to oil and natural gas development activities. As the comments describe:

“The Section 4(d) flexibility to narrowly tailor protections for threatened species and to opt against prohibiting all takes has been fully utilized by the listing agencies. The listing agencies typically refrain from imposing full Section 9 take prohibitions when: (1) take is incidental to a lawfully conducted industrial sector activity; (2) where incidental take potentially attributable to the activity is negligible or not well understood; and, (3) where there are economic and policy reasons to avoid unnecessarily damaging regulations on an industry. The  Associations believe that these principals should inform the Service’s delineation of the 4(d)  Special Rule for the LPC by removing all prohibitions for takes incidental to lawfully conducted  oil and gas operations, because lawfully conducted oil and gas activities already protect the environment, and the LPC habitat therein.”

Furthermore, the FWS’s proposed listing in December 2011 included alleged threats from oil and natural gas activities to the LPC, yet FWS was unable to isolate potential impacts from oil and gas operations from other variables that could pose harm to the species.  As such, supposed threats – be it noise or power lines — that are not specific to oil and gas development may be improperly and unevenly attributed to the industry. It is imperative that the 4(d) special rule proposed by the FWS does not wrongfully target development of our natural resources.

The oil and natural gas industry is already regulated under a host of state, local, and federal regulations that augment the Associations’ and their members’ commitment to the environment and its natural species. After all, America’s oil and natural gas operators are the same men and women who work and live in these operating areas. Increased technology is decreasing land use impacts, allowing multiple wells to be drilled in numerous directions from a single pad. And work with state and local governments is ensuring the continued protection of our environment is ongoing while developing imperative natural resources that provide power and jobs for millions of Americans. An ineffective federal listing of the LPC will only harm this development and the many benefits it brings to the United State.  Read the Associations full comments HERE.

]]>
/2013/06/21/ipaa-submits-joint-comments-to-fws-on-proposed-lesser-prairie-chicken-listing/feed/ 0
Management of the Greater Sage-Grouse – Local Plans for Protection /2013/06/14/management-of-the-greater-sage-grouse-local-plans-for-protection/ /2013/06/14/management-of-the-greater-sage-grouse-local-plans-for-protection/#comments Fri, 14 Jun 2013 16:31:16 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=562 Continue reading →]]> Utah

By Utah Governor Gary R. Herbert

Utah takes its obligations concerning the management of the wildlife resources entrusted to its management very seriously, and has always worked diligently to provide adequate protection for those species that may be adversely affected by development of natural resources. The greater sage-grouse is a species that lives in the vast sagebrush habitat found in eleven states in the West, including Utah. The grouse’s habitat ranges from the flat prairie lands in Wyoming and Montana, to the high-altitude terrain in California, to the naturally fragmented islands of habitat found on the Colorado Plateau. Given this geographical diversity, the protection and management of the greater sage-grouse cries out for solutions specifically tailored to the local situation, and for solutions that are not blind to the character and the needs of local communities. States are in a much better position than the federal government to manage wildlife and habitat.

Utah began finding such solutions 15 years ago for greater sage-grouse by empowering local working groups composed of state and local officials, private landowners, and federal agencies to determine the factors affecting the species locally, and to generate solutions. Utah has invested millions of dollars for habitat restoration and rehabilitation work which has demonstrably improved the status of the bird in Utah.  In addition, Utah, like other western states, has been working hard to formalize a state-specific Conservation Plan for the species. Utah’s planning effort was advised by a Governor’s Working Group composed of many stakeholders, including the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), the U.S. Forest Service, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS).

Utah’s Conservation Plan for Greater Sage-grouse was finalized in April of 2013, and contains a balanced suite of protections which are designed to encourage a cooperative spirit of conservation, yet allow economic conditions to thrive as well. The state’s Conservation Plan provides protection for 94 percent of the birds in Utah, and contains clear objectives and goals designed to not only stabilize population trends in Utah, but to also seek an increase in the population trends.

Unfortunately, this vast amount of work and progress appears to be of little importance to the FWS and the BLM. The Service’s 2010 decision, set to be reviewed in 2015, did not mention the 15 years of on-the-ground efforts to find solutions. Instead the FWS focused solely upon scientific literature conducted in other parts of the range of the species, and failed to analyze the applicability of the scientific literature upon the local conditions found in Utah, in order to determine if the status of the Utah populations varies from those found elsewhere.  The BLM, meanwhile, is refusing to use more recent habitat information prepared by the state because it is claimed there is no time to stop and review new information and meet the deadline of the Service’s impending review.

In the rush to find a solution, the BLM, the Forest Service, and the FWS have issued reports which purport to evaluate the science, and suggest appropriate conservation measures.  The BLM’s effort, called the National Technical Team report, contains a series of one-size-fits all restrictions on use of the land, many of which constitute a total ban on any use of the land.  These proposed restrictions would be devastating to sensitive rural economies throughout the West and illustrate, once again, how federal rules, procedures, and policies often impede balanced and reasonable state solutions to challenging policy problems.

Despite these challenges, the State of Utah has begun the implementation of its Conservation Plan.  Utah continues to seek a partnership with the BLM, Natural Resources Conservation Service, Forest Service and the FWS in this effort.  However, it is becoming increasingly clear that the drive to finish the BLM plans by an arbitrary date is driving the BLM to use outdated information, among other fundamental flaws, and will not allow for a reasoned review of population trends and other information by the Service in 2015.

Congress should consider legislating an extension of time to allow the states, the FWS, the BLM and the Forest Service, to rationally conclude this conservation planning and species status review process and allow states to demonstrate their ability to manage wildlife resources.

]]>
/2013/06/14/management-of-the-greater-sage-grouse-local-plans-for-protection/feed/ 0
All Witnesses in Agreement that ESA Needs Improvement /2013/06/07/all-witnesses-in-agreement-that-esa-needs-improvement/ /2013/06/07/all-witnesses-in-agreement-that-esa-needs-improvement/#comments Fri, 07 Jun 2013 15:40:52 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=522 Continue reading →]]>  

nat resourcesFrom the House Natural Resources Committee

On Tuesday, the House Natural Resources Committee held an oversight hearing entitled “Defining Species Conservation Success: Tribal, State, and Local Stewardship Vs. Federal Courtroom Battles and Sue-and-Settle Practices.”  At the hearing, Members and witnesses compared the effective conservation efforts happening on state, local, and tribal levels with the seemingly never-ending cycle of Endangered Species Act (ESA) litigation that often stands in the way of recovery efforts.

This hearing was the first in a series of hearings this Committee will hold to examine ways to ensure that the ESA is working efficiently and effectively for both people and species affected by this law.

“During the last Congress, this Committee held several hearings that demonstrated how the ESA has been used as a tool for litigation and how skillful lawyers are benefitting much more than species.  Ironically, the same litigious groups that routinely criticize the federal government’s failure to meet ESA listing or critical habitat deadlines are the same groups that are quick to claim that the status quo ESA successfully protects species by keeping the vast majority (over 98 percent) from ever getting off the list,” said Chairman Doc Hastings (WA-04).  “Fortunately, state, local, and tribal governments, and many private landowners not only care about species conservation, they’re doing it now, and in a manner that responsibly respects local economic activities, private property, and other uses.  This is occurring despite the ever-growing litigation industry involving federal implementation of the Endangered Species Act.” Read Chairman Hasting’s full testimony HERE.

Witnesses who testified before the Committee touted the success of state, local, and tribal conservation efforts and underscored the need for meaningful ESA reform.

Tyler Powell, Oklahoma’s Deputy Secretary of Environment, highlighted the successes of Oklahoma’s Lesser Prairie Chicken conservation efforts saying, “As it stands today the Endangered Species Act does not adequately assess the work that states are undertaking and provides little or no role for the states after listing of a species.  State wildlife agencies have built trust with landowners and a stakeholder that continues to benefit the Lesser Prairie Chicken and other species.  We believe, and have seen in past listings, that this trust is lost when the Service takes over all management of a species.  As also seen in other areas, states are best equipped to manage resources within their boundaries.  Our goal remains to have Oklahoma’s work on the Lesser Prairie Chicken be an example of how species of greatest conservation need should be managed.”

Tom Jankovsky, Garfield Colorado County Commissioner, accentuated the importance of local species conservation management and how top-down federal policies are doing more harm than good.  “Our primary concern is that the policies the Bureau of Land Management is attempting to put in place do not fit our unique topography and will fail, destroy our local economy and create the need for litigation.  It is critical that agency plans be consistent with local plans.”

Kathryn Brigham, Chairwoman of the Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission (CRITFC), showcased the many successes that CRITFC has achieved in species recovery and re-introduction.  Brigham also pointed out how important CRITFC is to fulfilling local species conservation needs. “We are proven natural resource managers.  Our activities benefit the region while also essential to the U.S. obligation under treaties, federal trust responsibility, federal statutes, and court orders.  The Endangered Species Act is at its best when it provides beneficial coordination and resources.  It is at its worst when it creates delay, bureaucracy and limits the tools co-managers need to restore abundance.”

During the hearing, Steve Ferrell, Wildlife and Endangered Species Policy Advisor to Wyoming Governor Meade, defended the states’ ability to effectively implement ESA requirements. “States are unquestionably qualified to be effective partners in the implementation of the ESA.  States have extensive experience and expertise in science based wildlife management principles and the application of public policy in managing wildlife as a public asset.  States are significantly affected by the ESA including their ability to develop and maintain their economies and natural resources. States should be afforded every opportunity to provide input to laws, regulations and policies in implementing the ESA.”

Ferrell also testified that those closest to the species know firsthand how to protect species better than distant bureaucrats and litigious groups who often hinder ESA through lawsuits and closed-door settlements.  “Litigation appears to be a business model for some organizations today.  Changing these laws to reduce the financial incentive to litigate would make the implementation of the ESA more efficient, and more transparent.  States and other interested stakeholders need and deserve a seat at the table when it comes to ESA management.”

]]>
/2013/06/07/all-witnesses-in-agreement-that-esa-needs-improvement/feed/ 0
Petition to List Sperm Whales in the Gulf of Mexico As a Distinct Population Segment /2013/05/17/petition-to-list-sperm-whales-in-the-gulf-of-mexico-as-a-distinct-population-segment/ /2013/05/17/petition-to-list-sperm-whales-in-the-gulf-of-mexico-as-a-distinct-population-segment/#comments Fri, 17 May 2013 16:01:02 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=450 Continue reading →]]> Kelley Drye Portrait - Wayne -- by Len Spoden PhotographyBy Wayne D’Angelo, Kelley Drye & Warren, LLP.

Industries that are most often impacted by Endangered Species Act (ESA) listings, and those of us that represent them, are familiar with environmental organizations using ESA’s petition process -  and their own formidable litigation budgets -  to drive listing activity at the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), often beyond the resource capabilities of those agencies.  Perhaps the best known example is the 2011 Center for Biological Diversity/Wildearth Guardians settlement with FWS which resulted in listing deadlines for hundreds of species.  A growing and lesser known tactic is for environmental organizations to petition the listing agencies to divide species into “distinct population segments,” each of which might then be listed under the ESA.

Authority to designate Distinct Population Segments (DPS) comes from the ESA itself.  The ESA applies to distinct taxonomic species, “any subspecies of fish or wildlife or plants, and any distinct population segment of any species of vertebrate fish or wildlife that interbreeds when mature.”

In 1978, when the phrase “DPS” was added to the ESA via the ESA Reauthorization Act, Congress wisely expressed concern that the language could be used to improperly disaggregate species to the extent that even healthy and abundant species could be shown to be endangered or threatened.  As such, in the conference report that accompanied the reauthorization, Congress admonished that DPS designation be used “sparingly and only when the biological evidence indicates that such action is warranted.”

Based on this admonition, NMFS and FWS crafted a DPS Policy that set a high bar for designating a DPS.  Under that policy, populations are not considered distinct unless they are both discrete and significant to the taxon as a whole.  When properly applied, the DPS Policy has resulted in “sparing” use, however petitioning groups are showing decidedly less restraint.  An interesting example of a DPS petition that would expand the designation far beyond what Congress intended, and the DPS policy allows, involves the sperm whale.

On December 9, 2011, Wildearth Guardians petitioned the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) to list sperm whales in the Gulf of Mexico (GoM) as a DPS.  In most DPS petitions, the petitioner attempts to sub-divide a non-endangered species into narrowed segments that may qualify as “threatened” or “endangered” under the ESA.   The sperm whale, however, has been listed as endangered throughout its global range (including the GoM) since 1970.  It begs the question; Why petition to further delineate a species that is already endangered? It is not because there is particularly good evidence that sperm whale in the GoM are a DPS.  To the contrary, Wildearth Guardians’ petition falls far short of the DPS Policy standards.

Perhaps Wildearth Guardians is concerned that there is mounting evidence of global sperm whale abundance that may justify delisting or down-listing the species.  Indeed, the International Whaling Commission Moratorium effectively eliminated the largest supposed threat to the sperm whale in 1988.   Perhaps also, Wildearth Guardians’ stated organizational goal of eliminating all fossil fuel development and use has informed its focus on the Gulf of Mexico.

The Gulf of Mexico is important to the domestic energy industry as it accounts for over a quarter of all domestic oil production. The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has determined that its new five-year drilling program will result in an annual “addition of between 20,025 and 51,825 jobs” and  that “[b]etween $1,050 million and $2,180 million in income would be produced.”

The Wildearth Guardians Petition may be less about protecting the sperm whale, and more about using the species to try to constrain offshore leasing activity, increase costs and uncertainty, and mire the offshore energy industry in more permitting delay.

What next?

On March 29, 2013, NMFS announced a 90-day finding that the Wildearth Guardians’ petition presented “substantial or commercial information” that the petitioned action may be warranted.  90-day findings are not based on substantive reviews and should not be read as an indicator of the agency’s endorsement of the petition.  The more rigorous analysis takes place pursuant to the 12-month, which the 90-day finding initiated.  Comments to inform that 12-month finding are due May 28, 2013.

Wayne D’Angelo, special counsel with Kelley Drye & Warren LLP, counsels on environment and energy matters, focusing on hydraulic fracturing, conventional and non-conventional fuels, resource extraction, greenhouse gas regulation and stationary and mobile sources issues under the Clean Air Act.

]]>
/2013/05/17/petition-to-list-sperm-whales-in-the-gulf-of-mexico-as-a-distinct-population-segment/feed/ 0
Improve the ESA to Ensure Conservation and Development Are Not Mutually Exclusive /2013/05/10/improve-the-esa-to-ensure-conservation-and-development-are-not-mutually-exclusive/ /2013/05/10/improve-the-esa-to-ensure-conservation-and-development-are-not-mutually-exclusive/#comments Fri, 10 May 2013 17:24:50 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=428 Continue reading →]]> LummisBy Congressman Cynthia Lummis (WY)

It is no secret that the Endangered Species Act (ESA) has become the third rail of natural resources policy.  It is so thoroughly embedded into our national dialogue regarding wildlife conservation that it has become an institution unto itself.  It appears the ESA is on par with our most untouchable social safety net entitlement programs.  Its untouchable status, however, does no favors to the species it was designed to protect.

The ESA was created in 1973 in response to concerns regarding the decline in population of the American Bald Eagle.  Since then the ESA has been a source of both pride and angst.  Pride in fulfilling the original goal to ensure that species escape extinction and come off the list, as has occurred for a few iconic species like the eagle and peregrine falcon.  Angst in the Act’s inability to recover more than 1% of species ever listed.  Pride that we possess a national desire to do what is right by the land and wildlife we have been given to steward; angst that the means established to accomplish that goal seems more beneficial to lawyers than to the lesser prairie chicken and other species.

Funding authorization for the ESA lapsed 25 years ago, yet the prohibitions and penalties associated with the law remain in force regardless of funding.  This fact has removed any incentives for careful study of the ESA by policy makers.  Worse, it has thrust the courts and lawyers into the de facto role of ESA policy makers.

Most laws cannot withstand the passage of time and changes in technology and scientific development.  The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service acknowledges that only 5 percent of the over 1,000 species under review are actually improving.  We can do better for species; we must do better for people.  That does not necessarily require comprehensive reform, but it does require an honest discussion about the ESA that does not immediately devolve into finger pointing and anger.  That is why I joined Natural Resources Committee Chairman, Doc Hastings, in announcing the formation of an ESA working group that will restart the discussion in a thoughtful and transparent way.

The working group will consist of Members from across the country and will analyze the ESA from all angles. We will hear from every interested stakeholder to unearth new ideas to improve the ESA for everyone.  There are many ideas out there, most of them from people outside the beltway, and I am eager for the working group to assess each of them on their merits.  My hope is that the ESA working group will help build a more sophisticated level of awareness about the law, and identify areas of improvement that can attract broad support in Congress and beyond.

We must improve the ESA to ensure that conservation and development are not mutually exclusive.  Doing so starts with an open discussion that is free of rancor.  I urge you to let me know your ideas, and I look forward to the task at hand.

Congressman Cynthia Lummis was first elected to represent the people of Wyoming in the U.S. House of Representatives in 2008.  She is a member of the House Natural Resources, Oversight and Government Reform and Science, Space and Technology Committees.

]]>
/2013/05/10/improve-the-esa-to-ensure-conservation-and-development-are-not-mutually-exclusive/feed/ 0
“Adverse Modification” Rulemaking on the Horizon for the Endangered Species Act? /2013/05/03/adverse-modification-rulemaking-on-the-horizon-for-the-endangered-species-act/ /2013/05/03/adverse-modification-rulemaking-on-the-horizon-for-the-endangered-species-act/#comments Fri, 03 May 2013 17:23:18 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=426 Continue reading →]]> By Joe Nelson, Van Ness Feldman, LLP

Do not mistake the mundane for the unimportant.  With two routine notices, one published in January and the second posted on an Office of Management and Budget (OMB) website at the end of April, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) gave notice of its intent to redefine what constitutes “adverse modification” for purposes of a Section 7 consultation under the Endangered Species Act (ESA).  FWS has indicated that it would take this action as part of a joint rulemaking with the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), which has jurisdiction over anadromous and marine species under the ESA.

Federal actions, including permitting and leasing decisions relating to oil and gas development, are subject to a requirement to “consult” with FWS or NMFS on the effects of the proposed federal action on threatened and endangered species as well as designated critical habitat.  A key element of this consultation is whether the proposed action will result in the destruction or “adverse modification” of designated critical habitat.

In 2001 and 2004, separate federal circuit court decisions overturned the regulatory definition of “adverse modification.”  The challenged definition considered adverse modification to occur only when there was an appreciable diminishment in the value of the critical habitat to contribute to the survival and recovery of the species.  The courts faulted this definition as “setting the bar too high” and inconsistent with the purpose and scope of the critical habitat designation.  After the second negative decision in 2004, FWS and NMFS issued guidance to field offices that the adverse modification inquiry should simply “rely on the statutory provisions of the ESA.”

For almost a decade, FWS and NMFS have routinely promised, but have not issued, a new definition.  The wait may be over.   In January, the annual Regulatory Plan for FWS stated:

In regard to the designation of critical habitat for listed species, we will issue rules to revise the timeframe for our issuance of economic analyses pertaining to critical habitat designations, to clarify definitions of “critical habitat” and “destruction or adverse modification,” to improve our consultation process in regard to issuing incidental take statements, and otherwise make improvements to the process of critical habitat designation.

Moving forward, at the end of April, the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs for OMB published a notice of its receipt of a proposed rule from FWS for “Definition of ‘Destruction or Adverse Modification’ of Critical Habitat.”  At this time, FWS has three other ESA rulemakings under review at OMB.

The implication of any new definition of “adverse modification” extends beyond its potential scope, to the changed landscape in which it will be applied.   Since 2004, the number of species with designated critical habitat and the overall acreage covered by such designations has grown significantly.   Moreover, as part of the 2011 “listing settlement” that is likely to result in an increase of more than 20% in the number of listed species by 2016, FWS committed to propose critical habitat for such species concurrent with listing, where prudent and determinable.  With these events, the likelihood of having activities within designated critical habitat has significantly increased.   Further, a new definition of “adverse modification” is likely to raise the bar with respect to the habitat protections and mitigation imposed upon federal permittees, leaseholders and licensees.

Preparation is often the key to success.   Having been given notice, the regulated community should mobilize and consider strategies for engagement in this rulemaking.  To effectively engage, stakeholders need to consider a host of questions.  What is the appropriate role of critical habitat designations under the ESA and how does that role inform the “adverse modification” inquiry under ESA, Section 7?  Since 2004, the overall understanding of the constituent elements of habitat, their relationship to species health and interaction with resource use activities has significantly advanced.  How are those advances in knowledge and science integrated into what constitutes “adverse modification” of critical habitat?  Should adverse modification be measured through both qualitative and/or quantitative means?  Can only temporary impacts constitute an adverse modification?  If so, how and when?

Most importantly, individuals and businesses must recognize and plan for the implications of a proposed and final rule re-defining “adverse modification”—particularly with respect to planned or ongoing projects that may be subject to an ESA Section 7 consultation.   Any new definition could have significant impact on the timing and scope of the consultation inquiry to a project and materially change the nature and amount of mitigation measures that may be required to avoid an adverse modification finding.   As mundane as the notice of this proposed rule may have been, its implications should not be underestimated.

Joe Nelson is a Partner at Van Ness Feldman, LLP, where he counsels clients on project compliance and permitting matters arising under the Endangered Species Act, Clean Water Act, National Environmental Policy Act and other environmental statutes.

]]>
/2013/05/03/adverse-modification-rulemaking-on-the-horizon-for-the-endangered-species-act/feed/ 0
In Montana the ESA fuels Litigation in Resource Development, Risks Bakken Job Boom /2013/04/12/in-montana-the-esa-fuels-litigation-in-resource-development-risks-bakken-job-boom/ /2013/04/12/in-montana-the-esa-fuels-litigation-in-resource-development-risks-bakken-job-boom/#comments Fri, 12 Apr 2013 17:18:22 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=418 Continue reading →]]> DainesRep. Steve Daines of Montana

Earlier this month, I had the opportunity to spend a day in Sidney, Montana.  From standing near the base of a recently constructed oil rig to having candid conversations with local business owners who have seen their operations grow and change substantially to meet the demands of the oil field, it’s clear that recent growth in Bakken energy production has had a tremendous impact on our eastern Montana communities.

Production in the Bakken has accounted for thousands of new jobs and injected millions of dollars into eastern Montana and western North Dakota.  Recent reports show that Bakken oil production currently accounts for 11 percent of total U.S. oil production and represents 40 percent of increased oil production nationwide.

I quickly realized that business and community leaders were searching for a level of regulatory certainty that will allow them to make the kind of long term investments necessary to foster sustainable economic growth. The almost whimsical nature of regulatory order and enforcement from Washington may look good to bureaucrats 2,000 miles away but fundamentally imperils the kind of economic opportunity that has finally arrived in my home state. As a small businessman I helped grow a Montana company from 100 employees to over 1000. It was later acquired by Oracle for 1.5 billion. I understand the need for regulatory certainty and I want businesses to have the same avenues that lead to success.

Some of the major barriers facing our state are environmental laws, like the Endangered Species Act (ESA). This law was intended to foster the kind of well-balanced development we care about in Montana—responsible resource exploration and extraction, coupled with conservation of our environment. We must ensure our laws work with us to achieve this end, to strengthen our nation, and not inhibit economic growth.

The ESA’s fundamental purpose is to preserve, protect, and recover valuable species in our country. However, too many operators in the oilfield and other job creators are constantly battling threats of legal suits. All the while, the ESA is not accomplishing its goal—only 28 species have been recovered out of well over 1,000 that have been listed in our country. That is a recovery rate that is unacceptable to any logical businessman.

Currently, there is a culture of “sue & settle” instead of effective species recovery. This stops business development and fuels fringe environmentalists’ agendas.  In Montana alone, at least 29 ESA cases were open between 2009 and 2011. There are more than a dozen cases against the Forest Service in Montana; and there are new cases filed each month.  In March, The Friends of the Wild Swan, Alliance for the Wild Rockies, and others halted a much-need timber sale, the Colt Summit project near Seeley Lake in Montana, due to a minor technical error by the Forest Service involving the impact on the habitat of a listed species, the Canadian Lynx.

Finally, resources spent litigating in the courtroom means less time spent on developing our natural resources while the American taxpayer fits the bill for the legal costs. Taxpayers have paid more than $1.2 million in attorney fees for just 12 of 29 Montana cases. Communities may never achieve the growth like Sidney, Montana if valuable resources remain undeveloped due to excessive litigation.

As a member of the House Natural Resources Committee and the House Energy Action Team, I am committed to working toward common sense solutions that help alleviate these roadblocks. Resource development and effective protection and recovery of our rare species must coexist. In Montana, we know that the responsible development of our resources, while also protecting the lands and wildlife we value, isn’t only possible—it’s the best solution.  I’ll work to bring these Montana principles to Congress.

Congressman Steve Daines is an American politician and businessman and the United States Representative for Montana’s At-large congressional district.

]]>
/2013/04/12/in-montana-the-esa-fuels-litigation-in-resource-development-risks-bakken-job-boom/feed/ 0
Fifth Circuit to Hear ESA Case Involving Texas Water Rights & Take of Whooping Cranes /2013/04/05/fifth-circuit-to-hear-esa-case-involving-texas-water-rights-take-of-whooping-cranes/ /2013/04/05/fifth-circuit-to-hear-esa-case-involving-texas-water-rights-take-of-whooping-cranes/#comments Fri, 05 Apr 2013 17:14:13 +0000 Kristen Lingley /?p=413 Continue reading →]]> Molly CarlosBy Molly Cagle & Carlos Romo, Baker Botts L.L.P.

On March 26, 2013, a panel of three judges from the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit stayed the U.S. District Court ruling in The Aransas Project (TAP) v. Shaw. The lower court ruling had enjoined the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) from issuing any water rights permits on the Guadalupe or San Antonio Rivers (except as required for public health and safety), which would seriously disrupt economic development in a growing part of Texas (including parts of the Eagle Ford Shale). The district court also required the TCEQ to seek an Incidental Take Permit under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) within 30 days.

The district court’s opinion and pending appeal involve several novel ESA theories with important implications for IPAA member companies.

First, the district court concluded that the Texas water-rights permitting scheme was preempted by the ESA and the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. constitution. This is a potentially far-reaching conclusion to the extent it suggests various state permitting programs, including oil and gas permitting by state agencies, must consider and enforce the ESA in policy areas traditionally reserved for state and local decision-making. The effect of the decision is a Section 7-type consultation process for TCEQ.

Second, the district court concluded that proximate causation can exist under the ESA when a defendant government agency indirectly authorizes an activity that does not inherently cause take. The court’s finding that TCEQ proximately caused take is significant precedent for groups challenging permitting schemes indirectly leading to take of endangered species, including state and federal agency programs that permit oil and gas projects.

Third, the district court’s 125-page opinion stretched statistical evidence to its limit to support its conclusion that TCEQ’s regulatory scheme for issuing water-rights permits caused the deaths of 23 whooping cranes. The court’s ultimate conclusion on causation involved several faulty scientific findings for each part of a multi-link causal chain leading from TCEQ’s water permitting scheme to the purported death of the birds. For example, there was significant doubt whether 23 birds had even died, let alone that they did not die from other natural causes such as drought. In this case, correlations were used to imply causation (despite the admonition in every statistics class to the contrary). And the district court’s findings on causation suggest even the most attenuated state regulatory decisions could be challenged for effects on endangered species.

Finally, by enjoining all new water rights permits (unless they meet certain court-supervised conditions) and ordering the TCEQ to seek out an Incidental Take Permit and associated Habitat Conservation Plan, the court ordered an extraordinary and expensive remedy for the alleged death of 23 cranes. Similar court-supervised injunctions and costly remedial actions could be ordered for other agencies regulating IPAA members implicated in a take suit.

Both the TCEQ and the Guadalupe-Blanco River Authority (GBRA) filed notices of appeal and requests to stay the district court order. GBRA’s motion specifically noted that the district court’s order would have irreparable harm on hydraulic fracturing operators in the Eagle Ford Shale needing new water rights permits.  Plaintiff filed a response, but the Fifth Circuit granted the stay barely 24 hours later.

Appellants are pleased that the 5th Circuit agreed that appellants were likely to succeed on the appeal and they are confident that the Court will conclude both that the district court’s decision overstepped the bounds of the ESA and federal court jurisdiction.  But IPAA members should closely follow the appeal because of its far-reaching implications.

Molly Cagle has been practicing environmental law in Texas for more than 30 years and is a Partner in the Austin office of Baker Botts L.L.P. Carlos Romo is an Associate in the Austin office and co-chairs client groups focused on ESA and upstream issues. They are part of a Baker Botts team enlisted to represent GBRA in the Fifth Circuit. 

]]>
/2013/04/05/fifth-circuit-to-hear-esa-case-involving-texas-water-rights-take-of-whooping-cranes/feed/ 0