Endangered Species Watch – ESAwatch.org Sponsored by the Independent Petroleum Association of America Sun, 28 Oct 2018 01:07:31 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.9.8 Weekly Newsletter – 10/26/18 /weekly-newsletter-10-26-18/ /weekly-newsletter-10-26-18/#respond Fri, 26 Oct 2018 16:32:15 +0000 /?p=7248 Issues Congress chastises Interior over transparency flaw. A confidential seven-page memo from the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) was recently leaked, revealing an internal recommendation that staffers”withhold” certain documents requested by the public on Endangered Species Act (ESA) decisions in cases where the service can “foresee harm” in future litigation challenging those decisions. The memo [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/26/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Congress chastises Interior over transparency flaw. A confidential seven-page memo from the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) was recently leaked, revealing an internal recommendation that staffers”withhold” certain documents requested by the public on Endangered Species Act (ESA) decisions in cases where the service can “foresee harm” in future litigation challenging those decisions.

The memo suggests FWS should consider withholding draft “versions of policies and rules”; internal “summaries, analyses, and comparative materials”; internal “briefing documents that address pre-decisional substantive issues”; and “decision meeting notes and summaries, score sheets, and memos to file reflecting substantive deliberation and especially participant names, position, or individual decision recommendations,” as well as other documents in the “administrative record” produced by the service as part of an ESA decision.

While noting “it is important to be transparent about agency decision-making,” the memo also states that FWS has an “obligation” to redact certain information on ESA decisions in order to “protect deliberations relating to those decisions when analysis allows us to reasonably foresee harm from releasing related documents and information.”

A Fish and Wildlife Service spokesman released a statement via email to E&E News saying the “internal memo” is intended only as “guidance” for the staffers with the Ecological Services Program, which administers ESA protections, in order to “ensure accurate and consistent interpretation and application of existing FOIA law by the program that affects how we compile and produce administrative records.”

Arizona Rep. Raúl Grijalva, the ranking Democrat on the House Natural Resources Committee, is pushing Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke to further explain the revelatory memorandum, sending a two-page letter  calling on Secretary Zinke to “explain the policy objective of this decision to be less transparent.” The Fish and Wildlife Service declined to comment on Grijalva’s letter.

Lease sales in jeopardy around the country. Bureau of Land Management (BLM) officials are delaying oil and gas lease sales on almost 90 square miles in Montana and North Dakota in response to a court ruling that faulted the Trump administration’s attempts to limit public comment on the sales. This move comes as BLM removes roughly 150,000 acres of Greater sage-grouse habitat from a planned December oil and gas lease sale in Colorado.

BLM says it pulled the grouse habitat from the Montana lease sale — and, at least in part, in Colorado — to comply with a preliminary injunction issued last month by Chief Magistrate Judge Ronald Bush in Idaho, temporarily blocking the agency from implementing elements of a January instruction memorandum that, among other things, shortened public review and protest periods for proposed lease sale parcels.

Bush’s preliminary injunction requires BLM to return to previous standards for public participation — such as 30-day public comment and protest periods that had been shortened — specifically when proposed lease sale parcels intersect with sage grouse planning areas or habitat management areas.

In addition to the decisions in Colorado, North Dakota and Montana, BLM is also considering rescinding an additional 578 parcels that are within, or partially within, 778,312 acres of designated grouse habitat from a planned December lease sale in Wyoming and more than 300,000 acres in Utah and Nevada as well.

In total, 1 million acres or more could be removed from planned December lease sales in the six states.

In the News

Landowners Wonder If Prairie Chicken Conservation Can Keep Up in Competitive Grasslands. KGOU. The silhouettes of a few old oil wells and barns flanking Stanley Barby’s ranch house fade quickly after a short drive down a narrow path in prairie grass tall enough to swat a pickup truck’s side mirrors. Today, the Barby Family owns an ocean of grass in Oklahoma’s Panhandle. The scrubby sandhills are the same ones that greeted Barby’s great-grandfather before statehood when he started what would become a 40,000-acre ranch in a region dubbed No Man’s Land. “I’ve heard the old-timers talk about when they came to this country, and there wasn’t any fences, and there wasn’t any trees, and there wasn’t anything how you’d just almost feel lost,” Barby said. No Man’s Land, it turns out, is also a great home for a lesser prairie chicken —  a finicky bird struggling to thrive in increasingly fragile western grasslands. “It’s fun to watch ‘em,” Barby said. “Sometimes they fly, sometimes they don’t. But if they fly they won’t go very far.” Lesser prairie chickens are also considered an indicator species representing the overall health of grasslands, which are increasingly fragmented and slowly vanishing.

Greens sue to protect habitat for Fla. bat. E&E News. Environmentalists want a federal court to force the Trump administration to protect habitat for a rare Florida bat. The Center for Biological Diversity, Tropical Audubon Society and North American Butterfly Association’s Miami Blue Chapter filed a lawsuit today arguing that the Fish and Wildlife Service has violated the Endangered Species Act by failing to designate critical habitat for the Florida bonneted bat. The flying critter, which lives in only about 26 colonies in southern Florida, was listed as endangered in 2013. CBD notes that sea-level rise would exacerbate pressures on the bat, flooding most of its remaining roost sites. “We can’t save Florida bonneted bats without protecting the places where they live and forage,” CBD attorney Rachael Curran said in a statement. “If these bats are to have any chance at surviving sea-level rise, federal wildlife officials need to protect their remaining habitat now.” The lawsuit is in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. FWS does not comment on pending litigation.

Vaquita wins another round in court. E&E News, Sub req’d. Despite objections from the Trump administration, a temporary ban on imports of Mexican seafood caught with gill nets in the Upper Gulf of California will remain in effect. In a ruling yesterday, the U.S. Court of International Trade sided with conservation groups who argued the ban is necessary to prevent the endangered vaquita porpoise from going extinct. The porpoise is the smallest in the world, with only about 15 remaining. The ruling marked another win for the Natural Resources Defense Council, Animal Welfare Institute and Center for Biological Diversity. In March, the environmental groups sued the federal government, arguing that the 1972 Marine Mammal Protection Act applies to both domestic fisheries and foreign fisheries that export products to the United States. In July, Judge Gary Katzmann ordered a preliminary injunction to stop the imports until the case is fully adjudicated. At the same time, the judge denied a motion by the government to dismiss the case. Defendants in the case, including NOAA Fisheries chief Chris Oliver and Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, then went back to court, complaining the federal government had suffered “ongoing serious harm” as a result of the injunction. But Katzmann rejected their claim in his latest ruling, writing that the U.S. government had “failed to meet its burden for a stay.” A stay would have blocked the injunction pending the outcome of an appeal.

Court upholds prosecution policy on killing protected wildlife. E&E News, Sub req’d. A federal appeals court yesterday breathed new life into a Justice Department policy that hunters who kill protected wildlife should be prosecuted only if they knew they killed a threatened species. The case concerns DOJ’s “McKittrick Policy,” which says prosecutors must prove that a defendant in a wildlife case knew beyond a reasonable doubt that he or she took an endangered species. Conservation groups challenged the policy, arguing it gave defendants an easy out. Judge David Bury, for the U.S. District Court in Arizona, sided with the groups in June 2017. The George W. Bush appointee held that the policy was “outside the range of prosecutorial authority” granted to DOJ by the Endangered Species Act. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals vacated that decision, remanded the case and instructed Bury to dismiss it. In a six-page order, the San Francisco-based 9th Circuit said the conservation groups, WildEarth Guardians and New Mexico Wilderness Alliance, failed to show a concrete injury caused by the McKittrick Policy — namely that throwing it out would result in few endangered wolves being killed.

Judge orders EPA to manage river temps for salmon. E&E News, Sub req’d. A federal judge yesterday ordered EPA to regulate water temperatures in the Columbia and Snake rivers that have caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands of threatened salmon and steelhead. Judge Ricardo Martinez for the federal district court in Seattle said EPA has unlawfully delayed the temperature regulation for 17 years. “EPA has failed to undertake its mandatory duty to issue a temperature [total maximum daily load (TMDL)] under the [Clean Water Act],” Martinez, a George W. Bush appointee, wrote. The Columbia River is the largest river in the Pacific Northwest, with a basin approximately the size of France. The Snake River is its largest tributary. The river system once held the largest salmon populations in the world, with the Snake River historically sustaining a third of those runs. Dams along the rivers and climate change have imperiled many of those salmon and steelhead species. More than a dozen are listed as endangered or threatened, and many are at “high risk” of extinction. At issue in the lawsuit brought by Columbia Riverkeeper, Snake River Waterkeeper, Idaho Rivers United, the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Associations and the Institute for Fisheries Resources are the rising river temperatures caused by dams and other point-source discharges. The fish require cold water to migrate from the ocean back to the rivers and spawn. When the water is warmer than 68 degrees Fahrenheit, migration becomes difficult. If the temperature exceeds 73 degrees, migration stops altogether.

Plan seeks to protect endangered species in Collier County rural lands. Wink News. Landowners in eastern Collier County want to take thousands of acres of land with the intentions of developing it. The plan also has a conservation element. The Collier County residents want to protect panthers, but the plan has caused considerable controversy. The Conservancy of Southwest Florida hasn’t given its stamp of approval on the development of eastern Collier County. “It’s a mixture of agriculture and natural areas and that really is Collier County’s bread basket,” Nicole Johnson said, who works with the Conservancy of Southwest Florida. “There’s always the concern that the more that we encroach into habitat areas the more potential for human wildlife interactions — negative interactions.” The Golden Gate Estates has had several negative interactions with wildlife and residents. The location is near where landowners want to build next, which is in the rural lands west area that is just east of the Golden Gate Estates and Oil Well Road. The US Fish and Wildlife Service is working with 11 landowners who want to develop up to 45,000 acres of land. It has outlined how they would protect endangered species like the Florida panther. The plan seeks to conserve 107,000 acres of the 152,000 acres it collectively owns. “This is a huge benefit for endangered species and wetlands,” Brad Cornell said, who is on the policy staff for Audubon of the Western Everglades.

Conservationists ask court to step in as red wolf plan looms. E&E News, Sub req’d. Conservationists told a federal judge yesterday that an imminent government plan to shrink the territory of the only red wolves living in the wild would hasten the animal’s extinction in violation of federal law. Lawyers for the Fish and Wildlife Service, however, countered that new rules for the red wolf program, set to be finalized next month, mean that the conservationists’ legal arguments are moot — and that they must file another lawsuit if they want to challenge the new plans. The current lawsuit by the Red Wolf Coalition, Defenders of Wildlife and Animal Welfare Institute argues that the federal government has neglected the wolves in recent years, allowing their population to decline. An estimated 35 wild red wolves remain — all in eastern North Carolina — down from about 120 a decade ago. Another 200 live in captive breeding programs. With the litigation unfolding, FWS announced the new plan in June to limit the wolves’ territory to federal land in just two counties and lift restrictions on killing wolves that stray from that area. The new rules implementing the plan are set to be finalized by Nov. 30. Until then, red wolves are governed by existing rules. One of the lawyers leading the case argued yesterday that the wolf’s decline has been accelerated by federal decisions in recent years to halt releases of captive-born wolves and to abandon efforts to sterilize coyotes that compete for territory.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/26/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-10-26-18/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 10/19/18 /weekly-newsletter-10-19-18/ /weekly-newsletter-10-19-18/#respond Fri, 19 Oct 2018 19:29:14 +0000 /?p=7245 Issues Documents reveals disagreement between Western Governors and Interior over sage grouse. Documents obtained in a public records requests reveal tumult between western governors, including Gov. Matt Mead of Wyoming, and the Trump administration. In a private January 12 letter from a public records request to the Deputy Interior Secretary David Bernhardt, Govs. Matt Mead and [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/19/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Documents reveals disagreement between Western Governors and Interior over sage grouse. Documents obtained in a public records requests reveal tumult between western governors, including Gov. Matt Mead of Wyoming, and the Trump administration.

In a private January 12 letter from a public records request to the Deputy Interior Secretary David Bernhardt, Govs. Matt Mead and John Hickenlooper, then co-chairmen of the Western Governors Association, noted concern over the lack of involvement with state authorities on making some of its Greater sage-grouse changes. According to the documents obtained in the public records request, their concerns were moreso over the lack of collaboration between the gubernatorial administrations and the Interior, rather than the final outcome. However, the letter did note that the sage grouse changes could have impacts on both the bird’s management and states’ economic interests.

Other states shared this stance but didn’t want their names on that letter.

Wyoming rep releases bill on sage grouse habitat. Late last month, U.S. Rep. Liz Cheney, R-Wyoming, sponsored and released a bill that would remove wilderness study area statuses of lands in three counties and remove inventoried lands with wilderness characteristics and recommended wilderness statewide.

Wyoming Wilderness Association (WWA) leaders recently spoke out against the bill. According to the WWA, the bill’s introduction threatens more than half of Wyoming’s WSA designations and more than 400,000 acres containing high-desert habitat for species such as elk, deer and sage grouse. “Releasing these areas from WSA status will allow for industrial and motorized uses that will devastate the wilderness of these places,” WWA executive director Khale Century Reno said.

The bill has been referred to the House Committee on Natural Resources by the House of Representatives.

In the News

Wyoming official calls for Endangered Species Act reform. Fox. The deputy director of the Wyoming Game and Fish Department appeared before the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee Thursday. John Kennedy provided testimony on the role of states in wildlife management, conservation and species recovery activities. Kennedy detailed Wyoming’s efforts to successfully manage hundreds of wildlife species. Kennedy said the state played a key part in what he called “the biggest conservation success story in North America,” the Greater Yellowstone grizzly bear. “The Wyoming Game and Fish Department has invested enormous fiscal and personnel resources to monitor and manage the grizzly bears over a period of decades. Since 1980, the Wyoming Game and Fish Commission has invested over $50 million in grizzly bear recovery – more than any other single entity.” Kennedy also pushed for reform of the Endangered Species Act and recent court decisions re-listing the grizzly bear. “The Wyoming Game and Fish Department has invested enormous fiscal and personnel resources to monitor and manage the grizzly bears over a period of decades,” said Kennedy. “Since 1980, the Wyoming Game and Fish Commission has invested over $50 million in grizzly bear recovery – more than any other single entity.”

Colo. gets state director amid more staff shuffling. E&E News, Sub req’d. The latest shuffling of senior management at the Bureau of Land Management involves the Oregon-Washington director moving to lead the Colorado office and the assistant director overseeing the bureau’s National Conservation Lands program in Washington, D.C., moving to the Pacific Northwest. Jamie Connell “in the coming weeks” will begin her new post atop BLM Colorado and will bring with her “a remarkable depth of experience relating to natural resources, particularly with energy development, budget, and communications,” Brian Steed, BLM’s deputy director of policy and programs, said in an email sent yesterday to members of the agency’s executive leadership team. “We’re looking forward to having Jamie Connell come back to Colorado after her time in other states around the West,” said Nada Culver, senior counsel and director of the Wilderness Society’s BLM Action Center in Denver. Culver said that during Connell’s tenure in Oregon-Washington, “BLM was conscientious in managing sage grouse habitat, and it would certainly be nice to see that approach applied to habitat here in Colorado.” Culver added, “She’s taking the proverbial reins at a time when BLM is making critical decisions for our sage grouse, big game and wilderness, and we’d really like a chance to talk to her about the lay of the land here.”

An awkward bird symbolizes the fight over America’s West. National Geographic. The greater sage grouse is “unquestionably the most comical-looking bird I have ever seen,” ornithologist Charles Bendire noted in 1877. Back then there were millions of sage grouse across the American West. Native peoples and Anglo settlers alike hunted them for feathers and food. Camping in one Wyoming valley in the 1880s, naturalist George Bird Grinnell found it so crammed with grouse that it became a “moving mass of gray.” Such scenes are hard to find today. Less than 10 percent of the bird’s original population remains, about half a million birds scattered across 11 western states and two Canadian provinces. Sage grouse need undisturbed sagebrush; the tough, drought-resistant shrub feeds the birds, especially in winter, and shelters them and their nests. But sagebrush is in retreat everywhere. Massive overgrazing a century ago cleared the way for invasive grasses that now fuel devastating fires in the western part of the bird’s range. Roads and subdivisions, transmission lines, farms, gas fields, and wind turbines—all disrupt what was once an unbroken sea of sage. Preserving sagebrush for grouse would help other animals that depend on the same habitat, such as pronghorn, mule deer, pygmy rabbits, and burrowing owls. But it might prove costly to ranchers, miners, oil and gas developers, and real estate brokers. In 2015 then President Barack Obama’s administration brokered what it hailed as a historic collaboration among those competing interests. Now President Donald Trump’s administration is weakening provisions that steered oil and gas drilling away from areas that had been reserved for sage grouse.

House GOP urges Zinke to lift mining, drilling bans. E&E News, Sub req’d. Top House Natural Resources Committee Republicans renewed their demands for the Interior Department to inventory all the administrative bans on oil, gas and mining development on public lands. Chairman Rob Bishop (R-Utah) and Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources Chairman Paul Gosar (R-Ariz.) sent a second letter in as many years to Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke blasting “unwarranted, unilateral” restrictions imposed under President Obama. The committee requested that the Bureau of Land Management produce a list of all the so-called mineral withdrawals currently in effect for both fuel and non-fuel minerals. “Mineral withdrawals, if they are to occur at all, are more properly addressed through an open legislative process rather than by administrative fiat,” the lawmakers wrote, making a common industry argument. A review by E&E News found that the Obama administration banned new mining on 5.2 million acres and proposed taking nearly 16 million acres off the table during eight years in office  The mining industry had high hopes that the Trump administration would lift a slew of those bans, including one prohibiting uranium mining on nearly 1 million acres around the Grand Canyon and another across 101,021 acres of southwestern Oregon. Zinke did scrap the single largest proposed ban — 10 million acres for protecting the greater sage grouse — but he has imposed a 20-year mining ban on 30,000 acres north of Yellowstone National Park (E&E News PM, Sept. 21).

County to appeal Gunnison Sage Grouse Ruling. Crested Butte News. The Gunnison County commissioners have decided to file an appeal of a recent court decision against their position in regard to the Gunnison sage grouse. The board of county commissioners (BOCC) held an executive session Tuesday afternoon to discuss the federal district court ruling to keep the Gunnison sage grouse on the endangered species list as threatened. The BOCC decided after the executive session to move to appeal that ruling. Earlier this month, Gunnison County, the Gunnison Stockgrowers Association, the state of Colorado, the state of Utah and San Juan County (Utah) lost their case in federal district court when a judge ruled to keep the Gunnison sage grouse on the endangered species list. This ruling more severely restricts what can be done on sage grouse habitat and could negatively impact things like local ranching operations. In 2014, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) added the Gunnison sage grouse to the list of endangered and threatened wildlife and designated 1.4 million acres in Colorado and Utah as “critical habitat” for the bird. In 2014, the USFWS said only 4,700 Gunnison sage grouse existed, and put the number at 5,000 in 2017.

Trump updates rule-busting agenda. E&E News, Sub req’d. Federal agencies have “greatly exceeded” initial targets for slashing regulatory costs, cutting four significant rules for every new one put in place, a senior administration official told reporters yesterday. The deregulatory push resulted in $23 billion in net regulatory cost savings in fiscal 2018, according to the White House. The federal government expects the trend to continue this coming fiscal year, leading to a projected $18 billion in net regulatory savings, excluding the proposed corporate average fuel economy standards. The White House announced its rule-busting progress in a 2018 regulatory reform report and by releasing the “Fall 2018 Unified Agenda of Regulatory and Deregulatory Actions.” BLM, which routinely holds timber sales in western Oregon, as well as Idaho and Wyoming, plans next month to formally propose a rule aimed at allowing it “to resolve protests of forest management decisions, specifically decisions to implement timber sales.” A formal notice will be published in the Federal Register next month, and it will be open for public comment into January. The Fish and Wildlife Service will continue considering protecting numerous species including the lesser prairie chicken and the Sierra Nevada red fox under the Endangered Species Act.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/19/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-10-19-18/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 10/12/18 /weekly-newsletter-10-12-18/ /weekly-newsletter-10-12-18/#respond Fri, 12 Oct 2018 17:16:17 +0000 /?p=7241 Issues USFS opens comment period for draft sage-grouse protection plan. Late last week, the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) unveiled proposed changes to Obama-era greater sage-grouse conservation plans in five Western states. On Friday, the agency released draft plans altering rules put in place in 2015 by the Obama administration, generally viewed as keeping the bird [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/12/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

USFS opens comment period for draft sage-grouse protection plan. Late last week, the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) unveiled proposed changes to Obama-era greater sage-grouse conservation plans in five Western states.

On Friday, the agency released draft plans altering rules put in place in 2015 by the Obama administration, generally viewed as keeping the bird from being listed for federal protections under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The new plans cover 8,000 square miles of greater sage-grouse habitat in Idaho, Colorado, Nevada, Wyoming and Utah. The draft environmental impact statement (EIS), which proposes amending land-use management plans governing national forests and grasslands, keeps sage grouse protection measures in place in most of the areas covered by the original federal blueprint.

Overall, the Forest Service’s draft EIS proposes changes in how the agency looks at a “desired condition” to describe “specific social, economic and/or ecological characteristics of the plan area or a portion of the plan area toward which management of the land and resources should be directed,” states the draft EIS’s executive summary.

According to Bridger-Teton National Forest spokeswoman Mary Cernicek, “The purpose of the proposed changes is to improve the clarity, efficiency and implementation of the current greater sage-grouse plans, including promoting landscape-scale alignment with state efforts.”

The draft EIS was published in the Federal Register on Oct. 4, opening a 90-day public comment period will end near Jan 3. In the meantime, the Forest Service has scheduled public comment open houses for each state.

Limbo of lizard’s legal status threatens industry. In August, Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar proposed a complete overhaul of sagebrush lizard conservation, in an effort to strike a balance between protecting the tiny reptile and maintaining economic prosperity in the state.

Hegar’s proposal is the latest attempt in this ongoing battle to protect the dunes sagebrush lizard amid a threat of federal action. It eliminates scientifically unsupported conservation options and defines ways for companies to avoid lizard habitat, enacts fees from some companies operating in the lizard habitat to support conservation efforts to offset habitat disturbances and includes incentives to focus industrial activities in degraded or nonhabitat areas.

Recently, former Texas Commission on Environmental Quality Chairman Kathleen Hartnett White spoke out in support of the proposal in hopes that it moves forward, citing the prior ineffectiveness of the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) when enforcing the Endangered Species Act (ESA).

“The Endangered Species Act was written so as to grant government near-absolute power to dictate how landowners can use property (…) FWS has not had a stellar history as far as accuracy in defining habitat or even in determining whether a particular species is actually threatened or endangered,” said Hartnett White.

According to Robert Gulley, Director of Economic Growth and Endangered Species in Texas, the federal government could make a decision on the revamped plan by spring of next year.

In the News

‘Cryptic’ little mussel needs ESA listing, feds say. E&E News, Sub req’d. The vulnerable Atlantic pigtoe freshwater mussel requires protection as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Wildlife Service said today. Capping years of litigation and study, the federal agency agreed with environmentalists that the mussel faces serious risks stemming from the loss and degradation of habitat. Land-use changes and a warming climate contribute to the underlying problem. “The Atlantic pigtoe faces a variety of threats from declines in water quality, loss of stream flow, riparian and instream fragmentation and deterioration of instream habitats,” the agency noted, adding that “these threats … are expected to be exacerbated by continued urbanization and the effects of climate change.” As part of the ESA proposal, the agency identified 542 river miles in Virginia and North Carolina as critical habitat. Some of the designated habitat is also home to other species listed under the ESA, which effectively reduces the impact of the new designation. “The incremental costs of designating critical habitat for the Atlantic pigtoe are likely to be relatively low, less than $230,000 per year, given the estimated number of future consultations,” the 16-page economic analysis states. And while private property owners often fear critical habitat designations, the economic analysis notes that there do not appear to be significant development pressures in the area. “In fact, more than half of the river miles proposed for critical habitat are located in counties that experienced population declines between 2012 and 2016,” the analysis reports.

Bill sparked by Calif. blaze would curtail some enviro reviews. E&E News, Sub req’d. Some timber thinning and other efforts to cut wildfire risk near roads would be exempt from standard environmental rules under a new message-sending bill introduced by a Northern California lawmaker. Planted in the final weeks of the 115th Congress, the measure authored by Rep. Doug LaMalfa (R-Calif.) essentially stakes out a position for future debate purposes. Its long-term prospects likely depend on whether LaMalfa’s fellow Republicans retain control of the House. “While we certainly recognize it’s far from a finished product, Congressman LaMalfa knows something must be done to address recent wildfires and believes this bill is a good way to get that conversation seriously started,” LaMalfa’s spokesman Parker Williams said yesterday. The legislation introduced Friday, H.R. 7042, would cover wildfire mitigation efforts undertaken within 500 feet of any permanent or temporary road. The activities, including forest thinning, hazardous fuel reduction, prescribed burning and vegetation management, would be exempt from National Environmental Policy Act and Endangered Species Act requirements. Dubbed the “Combustion Avoidance along Rural Roads (CARR) Act,” the far-reaching, three-page bill is a response to the Carr Fire, which burned more than 299,000 acres and destroyed more than 1,000 residences in Northern California before it was contained Aug. 31.

Conservatives stake claim on new Supreme Court. E&E News, Sub req’d. Conservative lawyers are mapping out the next environmental battles they want to wage before the newly constituted Supreme Court. With Brett Kavanaugh sworn in Saturday for a lifetime appointment, many groups are eager to cash in on the court’s distinct swing to the right. On environmental issues, that means a potential uptick in cases involving property rights, agency power and cornerstone environmental laws including the Endangered Species Act and the Clean Water Act. Myron Ebell of the Competitive Enterprise Institute said the first order of business will be defending the Trump administration’s deregulatory actions before the high court. “I was confident that most of them would be eventually upheld, but I’m more confident today with Kavanaugh joining the court,” he said. Jonathan Wood, an attorney with the conservative Pacific Legal Foundation, said the fight over the Obama-era Waters of the U.S. rule, or WOTUS, is likely to find its way back to the Supreme Court, too. Now-retired Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote the 2006 Supreme Court opinion relied upon for years to guide the federal government’s jurisdiction over various wetlands and waterways. A firmly conservative court may prefer the more limited approach favored by the Trump administration. Another big issue: judicial deference to agencies. Conservatives and libertarians have been gunning for the Chevron doctrine, a long-standing Supreme Court precedent that directs judges to defer to agency judgments in many cases.

FWS floats protections for eastern black rail on rising seas. E&E News, Sub req’d. The Fish and Wildlife Service today proposed protecting the eastern black rail under the Endangered Species Act. Citing dangers that include rising oceans, warmer temperatures and “severe weather events,” the federal agency said the bird deserves ESA listing as a threatened species. Some populations have dropped by as much as 90 percent, officials say. “We have determined that habitat loss and destruction, sea level rise and tidal flooding, incompatible land management, and increasing storm intensity and frequency are the primary threats to this subspecies,” FWS stated. As part of the listing, FWS is also proposing a specially tailored protection plan that would exempt mowing and mechanical treatment of rights of way, fire breaks and utility transmission corridors from the ESA’s usual “take” prohibitions. Described as “shy and reclusive,” the eastern black rail has popped up in as many as three dozen states. One of four subspecies of black rail, the eastern black rail, though rare, is broadly distributed and favors salt, brackish and freshwater marshes. Population estimates vary across different regions, but along the Atlantic Coast from New Jersey to Florida there are thought to be somewhere between 355 and 815 breeding pairs. As a result of climate change, FWS noted that the “Northeast Atlantic and western Gulf of Mexico coasts are projected to have amplified relative sea level rise greater than the global average under almost all future sea level rise scenarios.” Such a scenario bodes ill for the eastern black rail’s habitat.

States want lawmakers to watch and learn. E&E News, Sub req’d. State efforts to conserve wildlife earned plaudits on a federal stage yesterday, in a Senate committee hearing largely marked by amicable talk of teamwork and cooperation. But all the while, the edgier and endless Endangered Species Act debate hovered about as the ghost at the banquet. Billed as a session dedicated to considering “Successful State Conservation, Recovery and Management of Wildlife,” the 90-minute Senate Environment and Public Works Committee hearing put its primary spotlight on state-level expertise. “State fish and wildlife agencies have a long history of success in restoring many species,” John Kennedy, deputy director of the Wyoming Game and Fish Department, told the Senate panel. Kennedy pointed to the example of the greater sage grouse, whose range spans 43 million acres in Wyoming. The state has focused on habitat areas considered vital to the species and allowed normal use and development elsewhere, Kennedy recounted. The results have helped keep the sage grouse off the ESA list. Mike McCormick, president of the Mississippi Farm Bureau Federation, likewise cited the “successful examples of conservation and wildlife recovery achieved through partnerships with private landowners and state and federal agencies.” For instance, McCormick described the Mississippi Honeybee Stewardship Program as a productive result of collaboration among beekeepers, row crop farmers, and the Mississippi Department of Agriculture and Commerce, among others. Federal officials lent support but gave locals the lead.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/12/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-10-12-18/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 10/5/18 /weekly-newsletter-10-5-18/ Fri, 05 Oct 2018 18:37:22 +0000 /?p=7238 Issues Gunnison sage-grouse to remain on ESA list, judge rules. Gunnison County, the Gunnison Stockgrowers Association, Colorado, Utah and San Juan County lost their case in federal district court last week when a judge ruled that the Gunnison sage-grouse should stay on the endangered species list as “threatened.” Being listed as “threatened” more severely restricts [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/5/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Gunnison sage-grouse to remain on ESA list, judge rules. Gunnison County, the Gunnison Stockgrowers Association, Colorado, Utah and San Juan County lost their case in federal district court last week when a judge ruled that the Gunnison sage-grouse should stay on the endangered species list as “threatened.” Being listed as “threatened” more severely restricts what can be done on grouse habitat and could negatively impact things like local economic development.

The ruling by U.S. District Court Judge Christine Arguello in Colorado also upheld Fish and Wildlife’s concurrent decision to establish 1.4 million acres of designated critical habitat for the bird. In doing so, Arguello rejected legal challenges that argued the service had violated the Administrative Procedure Act, in part by not allowing for public comment on a critical population analysis that was key to the service’s 2014 listing decision.

When FWS listed the bird as threatened under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), the decision was sharply criticized by elected officials, including Hickenlooper and Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.), who argued the listing was unnecessary. John Swartout, a senior adviser for Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper (D), said the state is reviewing the ruling but added, “Obviously, we’re disappointed the court did not recognize the efforts of Gunnison County, the landowners and the state to protect the Gunnison sage grouse.”

This week, the U.S. Supreme Court began hearing arguments on an ESA case in Louisiana with similarities to the Gunnison grouse case, said David Halverson, a lawyer for the state’s Public Lands Policy Coordinating Office. The Fish and Wildlife Service designated timberland in Louisiana as critical habitat for an endangered frog, but opponents say the frog has not lived in that state since 1965. Similarly, Utah argues that some of the land designated as critical habitat for the Gunnison grouse is not suitable for the bird.  Halverson said Utah wants to save the bird but believes it can be done better outside the framework of the ESA.

Sage Grouse preserved by industry, study says. A study led by UC Santa Barbara’s National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis (NCEAS) shows that grazing restrictions on public lands may have unintended consequences for Greater sage-grouse. The species depends on habitat on both public and private lands, and much of that habitat can be lost when ranching operations go under. Policies to restrict grazing access on public lands are likely to harm ranch profitability, which in turn could spur ranchers to sell their private lands for other uses—namely, crop cultivation or housing developments—that would ultimately destroy critical grouse habitat.

“We found that as the restrictions to public lands increased, (private) landowners have historically made decisions to alter their land use. Then there’s trigger points where they may sell those lands to higher intensity uses that would be bad for sage grouse,” said David Naugle, study co-author and professor at the University of Montana.

The study, published in the Journal of Applied Ecology, found that curbing public land grazing by 50 percent could lead to more than 429,000 acres of lost habitat for sage grouse. According to co-author Joe Fargione, science director for The Nature Conservancy’s North American region, their findings validate the increasing recognition that ranchers and conservationists must partner to support healthy sagebrush ecosystems for industry and sage grouse and open the door to creative solutions that take a more balanced approach.

In the News

States want greater oversight of endangered species. E&E News, (Sub req’d). States would get more authority to carry out the Endangered Species Act under a regulatory proposal that could be filed soon. The rulemaking proposal would ask the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to change how it works with state agencies under Section 6 of the act, Matthias Sayer, New Mexico’s deputy secretary for energy, minerals and natural resources, said yesterday at a meeting of the Interstate Oil and Gas Compact Commission. If it’s adopted, states would be able to apply for authority to issue and administer the recovery plans that govern how endangered animals and plants are protected. State rules on “taking” animals would gain pre-eminence over federal rules. New Mexico and other Western states have been pressing for decades to get more control over both energy production and federal regulations like the Endangered Species Act. The IOGCC, a trade group for state oil and gas regulators, has served as a clearinghouse for those ideas. Wildlife conservation groups criticized the idea, but Sayer said New Mexico and other states are better positioned than FWS because they have more boots on the ground and have better relations with landowners than federal agencies.

Short-Handed Supreme Court Hears Endangered-Species Case. Wall Street Journal. An eight-member Supreme Court returned from its summer break Monday with a case pitting an endangered species against a logging company, immediately demonstrating the pivotal role that Judge Brett Kavanaugh would play if confirmed. Liberal justices said Congress had intended broad efforts to save endangered species. Conservatives said government shouldn’t impose costs on private landowners. With the court divided, a tiebreaking vote—probably for the property owner, should Judge Kavanaugh cast it—could be necessary to decide the case and others like it. Nevertheless, the marble chamber’s atmosphere seemed in many ways a world apart from the caustic partisan battle over the court unfolding in the Senate buildings across the street. When Justice Stephen Breyer matter-of-factly said “drain the swamp,” he was referring to actual Louisiana wetlands, seemingly unaware that the phrase plays double duty in President Trump’s rhetorical arsenal. Chief Justice John Roberts set the tone at the outset, noting the 25th anniversary of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s investiture at court. “We all look forward to sharing many more years with you in our common calling,” he said to his 85-year-old colleague. And after the fight over an endangered frog, a second case Monday showed the court largely in alignment behind Arizona firefighters raising an age-discrimination claim, highlighting that only a minority of cases, albeit often highly-charged ones, divide the justices along strict ideological lines. The first case involves, the government says, “one of the most imperiled species” in the U.S., the dusky gopher frog, which once ranged across Alabama, Louisiana and Mississippi. As its habitat was destroyed by development, the species had dwindled by 2001 to a known population of about 100 in a single pond in the De Soto National Forest.

Zinke announces $50M in state conservation grants. E&E News, (Sub req’d). The Interior Department will distribute $50 million in conservation grants designed to help keep sensitive wildlife species from being listed for federal protection in all 50 states and major U.S. territories. The State Wildlife Grant Program specifically targets projects that help conserve sensitive species and habitat that are listed in each state’s Wildlife Action Plan. The plans in all 50 states and major territories include detailed strategies to protect species that have been determined to be in greatest need of conservation, Interior said today. The goal is to keep them from being listed for protection under the Endangered Species Act. Alaska, California, Florida, New York and Texas are the states receiving the biggest share, with each getting at least $2.3 million. American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands and the Virgin Islands are each receiving $126,551. U.S. territories in years past have received less grant money than states. “When the federal and state governments work together, we can achieve the best outcomes,” Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke said in a statement. “This funding is an investment in the future of our wildlife. When we can recover species before they are listed under the Endangered Species Act, that means more federal resources for the other species that need it most.”

New science policy: ‘It’s all kind of vague right now’. E&E News, (Sub req’d). Fans and critics of the Interior Department’s new science policy are still holding their breath over what it will actually change. The arguments over the new order, titled “Promoting Open Science,” echo the fight at EPA to curtail research that doesn’t publish its raw data. The political left says Interior’s new policy threatens to politicize and complicate even routine science, such as counting animal populations, while the right says it will restore trust to processes that have historically tilted against industry — namely, endangered species listings. At stake is how all the arms of the Interior Department behave, experts said, because science underlies just about everything it does. But here’s where things get foggy: Unlike the EPA proposal, which outlines criteria to accept research into rulemaking, the new Interior policy seeks to “prioritize” reproducible studies with public data “to the extent possible.” The department may still use research with non-public data if staff explain why it’s the best available science. “We’ll have to see how they implement it, whether there are any changes in things or if this is just — it’s all kind of vague right now,” said Myron Ebell of the Competitive Enterprise Institute. “There aren’t bright lines in the order.” At least one expert suggested the order amounts to a victory for scientific integrity. Bernard Goldstein, who was assistant EPA administrator for research and development under President Reagan, has criticized the current EPA’s attempt to restrict the science it will use. But the Interior order seems to sidestep those problems, he said.

Green groups sue Zinke, BLM to cancel drilling leases. E&E News, (Sub req’d). A coalition of environmental groups today filed a federal lawsuit challenging three already-held Bureau of Land Management lease sales in Utah and Colorado, including some parcels less than 3 miles from Dinosaur National Monument. The lawsuit, filed today in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado in Denver, seeks to invalidate the 121 leases covering more than 117,000 acres because the coalition claims BLM did not properly analyze the risks of potential oil and gas drilling on public health and the surrounding environment before offering them. The 45-page legal complaint — filed by the National Parks Conservation Association, Rocky Mountain Wild, the Center for Biological Diversity and WildEarth Guardians — says BLM’s lack of evaluation violates the National Environmental Policy Act and the Federal Land Policy and Management Act. The coalition, which is being represented by attorneys with Earthjustice, wants the court to issue an order vacating the leases sold during the three sales — two in Utah, one in Colorado. “Prioritizing economic benefits over public health and the environment is wrong,” Matt Sandler, a staff attorney for Rocky Mountain Wild, said in a statement. “This is especially so when the BLM has failed to comply with the laws that would have ensured the public knew the full impacts of these leasing decisions. Representatives with the Interior Department did not respond to requests to comment on this story before publication. Interior usually does not publicly comment on matters pertaining to pending or ongoing litigation. A Department of Justice spokesman said the department is reviewing the complaint.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/5/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Weekly Newsletter – 9/28/18 /weekly-newsletter-9-28-18/ Fri, 28 Sep 2018 18:46:07 +0000 /?p=7235 Issues IPAA publishes comments on ESA open dockets.  Together with the Petroleum Association of Wyoming (PAW), the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) has submitted comments to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries Services on their jointly-proposed Revision of the Regulations for Interagency Cooperation, and Revision of the Regulations for Listing [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/28/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

IPAA publishes comments on ESA open dockets.  Together with the Petroleum Association of Wyoming (PAW), the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) has submitted comments to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries Services on their jointly-proposed Revision of the Regulations for Interagency Cooperation, and Revision of the Regulations for Listing Species and Designating Critical Habitat, as well as the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s proposed Revision of the Regulations for Prohibitions. Select comments include:

  • The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service should finalize its proposed revisions to the Blanket 4(d) Rule so that newly-listed threatened species’ needs are addressed only on a species-specific basis and enhance the rule.
  • The Services must correct their incorrect description of the scope of intra-Service consultations on Section 10 take permits to make clear that the consultation is limited to the effects of the agency action (i.e., the take permit itself), not any underlying projects or activities for which that take permit may be used and streamline the consultation process.
  • The Services should revise their regulations, as proposed, to codify the understanding that 1) they may not designate any unoccupied areas as critical habitat for a species unless designation of all occupied areas would be insufficient to provide for the conservation of the species and 2) that any unoccupied areas that they designate as critical habitat for a species must be “essential to the conservation of” that species.

Read IPAA’s full comments on ESA Watch.

ESA reform under review. Earlier this week, lawmakers assembled a House panel hearing on nine ESA-related bills. The House Natural Resource Committee examined a package of bills sponsored by the House Western Caucus that are designed to make incremental changes to the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Changes include increased consultation on ESA petitions from state and county governments, expedited petition discharges, streamlining the listing process, and increased transparency by publishing the reasoning for listings of endangered or threatened species.

Lasting two hours, the hearing involved familiar arguments from both sides of the aisle. One in particular that stood out came from a top Interior Department official who appreciated the concerns of lawmakers who brought the bill forward but also underscored his hesitant support by pointing out potential real-world complications from the nine bills in question.

“In general, the administration supports the goals of these bills to improve coordination with, and expand the role of, states in implementing the ESA, to improve transparency in decision-making … and to improve the processes for listing, downlisting, delisting and recovery of species,” said Gregg Renkes, the Interior Department’s Office of Policy Analysis director.

At the same time, Renkes cautioned against the particulars in one bill, H.R. 6345, involving ESA petitions that “may increase workload for agency staff and may expose the department to additional litigation risk.” In the case of another bill, H.R. 6355, intended to restrict ESA actions during designated petition “backlog” periods decisions, Renkes advised lawmakers to consider “more appropriate deadlines that would not place additional constraints on the work of the agency.” Despite this lukewarm reception, Renkes repeatedly declared, “We welcome the opportunity to work with the committee.”

The hearing occurred only one day after the expiration of a public comment period on a Trump administration package of proposed regulatory revisions. The Committee passed H.R. 5636, H.R. 5706, H.R. 6064, H.R. 6118, H.R. 6255, and H.R. 6666 by unanimous consent while also adopting H.R. 6682 and H.R. 5727 by voice vote.

Judge orders revival of sage-grouse leasing reforms. A federal judge has halted the Trump administration’s updated policy on public participation in the process by which the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) decides whether to grant oil and gas leases in a habitat of the greater sage-grouse.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Ronald Bush in a Friday ruling sided with environmentalists who sued in April out of concerns that upcoming sales could harm the flamboyant bird species.

Bush’s preliminary injunction applies only to lease sales that intersect with sage grouse planning areas or habitat management areas. The order requires BLM to return to standards for public participation in the onshore oil and gas leasing process established in a 2010 staff memo under the Obama administration.

“The record contains significant evidence indicating that BLM made an intentional decision to limit the opportunity for (and even in some circumstances to preclude entirely) any contemporaneous public involvement in decisions concerning whether to grant oil and gas leases on federal lands,” noted Bush, an Obama appointee.

Environmental groups that brought the litigation against BLM welcomed the court’s temporary stay of the Trump-era changes to the leasing process. However, Bush’s order does not grant the groups’ request to end BLM’s quarterly lease sale schedule and revert to an Obama-era system of rotating parcel reviews between field offices. The requirements take effect starting with the next round of onshore lease sales, which will take place in December.

In the News

Judge tosses critical habitat for fairy shrimp. E&E News, Sub req’d. A federal judge has rejected a Fish and Wildlife Service map meant to protect a tiny Southern California crustacean that has cast a long legal shadow. U.S. District Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson sided with property owners in rejecting the government’s designation of a 56-acre parcel as critical habitat for the endangered Riverside fairy shrimp. “The manner in which the [Fish and Wildlife Service] determined the scope of the area that the Riverside fairy shrimp occupies is inconsistent with the [Endangered Species Act’s] prescriptions for making that determination,” Brown Jackson wrote The 43-page decision issued yesterday is another victory for Otay Mesa Property LP, which previously prevailed in a 2011 fairy shrimp-related appellate decision authored by Judge Brett Kavanaugh. Kavanaugh, currently on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, is now fighting for confirmation to the Supreme Court. The high court starts its new term next week with a case challenging the critical habitat designation for another species, the dusky gopher frog.

Judge to U.S. Fish and Wildlife: Don’t ‘cherry pick’ science. High Country News. In September, U.S. District Judge William Alsup ordered the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to reconsider its decision not to federally protect Pacific fishers, ruling that the agency had ignored and mischaracterized research about the species. At a time when the Endangered Species Act faces increasing politicization, the decision re-affirms the role of science in deciding when and how to protect the West’s disappearing species. Rodenticides from illegal marijuana operations have threatened the Pacific fisher in recent years. The Fish and Wildlife Service decided not to grant fishers federal protections in 2016; now, a judge has ordered the agency to reconsider. About the size of large house cats, Pacific fishers hunt birds, rodents, hares and even porcupines. Once found throughout the Pacific Coast mountains, fishers have been dwindling for generations, first because of widespread logging in their range, and more recently because of illegal marijuana operations in remote forests. Since 2004, Fish and Wildlife has stalled over whether to protect Pacific fishers, but in 2014, it finally proposed protecting fishers as federally threatened. Two years later, the agency changed course, deciding that fishers did not need protection after all. Conservation organizations including the Center for Biological Diversity sued, saying that Fish and Wildlife had caved to pressure from the timber industry. Indeed, multiple industry organizations joined the suit as defendants alongside the federal agency. Now, Judge Alsup has ordered Fish and Wildlife to reexamine the issue.

Kavanaugh’s absence could affect rare frog’s fate. E&E News, Sub req’d. On Monday morning, the high court will open its new term with arguments over habitat protections for the dusky gopher frog, an endangered amphibian in the South. It’s unlikely Kavanaugh will be there. The nominee appeared to be cruising toward Senate confirmation two weeks ago before sexual assault allegations surfaced. Now Kavanaugh and his first accuser, Christine Blasey Ford, are set to testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday. Republicans have blazoned confidence they’ll ultimately confirm Kavanaugh to the bench, but the vote count remains uncertain. And even with enough support, it would be nearly impossible to have him seated in time for Monday’s Supreme Court arguments. A fastest-case scenario would likely look like this: The panel could act on the nominee immediately after Thursday’s hearing. After moving the nomination out of committee, lawmakers are required by chamber rules to invoke cloture and allow for 30 hours of post-cloture debate before a final vote. The Senate would have to stay in session through the weekend for a full Senate vote on Kavanaugh to occur before Tuesday. That means the ESA case and the rest of next week’s arguments — including disputes over property rights and executive power — will likely be heard by an eight-justice court.

Proposed changes will help recover endangered species. The Hill. For the past 45 years, the Endangered Species Act has been America’s most popular environmental law. In at least one critical respect, that popularity is well deserved: less than 1 percent of species protected by the Endangered Species Act have gone extinct. However, it also has fallen short in an equally important respect: less than 3 percent of protected species have recovered. Recently, the U.S. Department of the Interior proposed a modest reform that finally could enable the Endangered Species Act to achieve both of its noble goals. That reform would adjust the regulatory burdens felt by private landowners based on the degree of threats a species faces, aligning the incentives of property owners with the interests of vulnerable species. As a species recovers, relaxed regulations will reward property owners for their role in that recovery, creating a necessary incentive for landowners to restore and improve endangered species habitat. Equally important, regulations will become more restrictive if a species declines, encouraging property owners to proactively protect less-vulnerable species to avoid this consequence. Importantly, the strict regulations for the most at-risk species will be unchanged, ensuring that the Endangered Species Act will continue to effectively prevent extinction.

Court reinstates protections for Yellowstone grizzlies. E&E News, Sub req’d. A federal court last night halted a planned hunt for grizzly bears near Yellowstone National Park and restored Endangered Species Act protections for them. Environmental groups cheered the move by the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana, saying grizzly bears now “have a fighting chance.” The court ruled that the Fish and Wildlife Service erred when it lifted Endangered Species Act protections for a population of grizzlies in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem in Wyoming, Montana and Idaho. The decision is a huge win for several tribes and environmental groups, which announced victory last night. “This is a victory for the bears and for people from all walks of life who come to this region to see the grizzly in its natural place in the world,” Earthjustice attorney Tim Preso, who argued the case, said in a statement. Bethany Cotton, director of WildEarth Guardians’ wildlife program, said the ruling will help grizzlies throughout their range.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/28/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Weekly Newsletter – 9/21/18 /weekly-newsletter-9-21-18/ Fri, 21 Sep 2018 17:27:45 +0000 /?p=7229 Issues Nevada Governor pushes back on compensatory mitigation rollback. At a recent Western Governors Association workshop on invasive species in Lake Tahoe, Governor Brian Sandoval of Nevada told reporters that he has concerns about the impact that rolling back compensatory mitigation will have on the state’s Greater sage-grouse plan. The state’s program, known as the [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/21/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Nevada Governor pushes back on compensatory mitigation rollback. At a recent Western Governors Association workshop on invasive species in Lake Tahoe, Governor Brian Sandoval of Nevada told reporters that he has concerns about the impact that rolling back compensatory mitigation will have on the state’s Greater sage-grouse plan. The state’s program, known as the Conservation Credit System, allows mining companies like Barrick and Newmont to offset their impact of development by restoring sagebrush habitat elsewhere.

“A big piece of [the state’s plan] was working with the private sector, working with the mining industry, to allow for that compensatory program. So, to see that go away, would be very troublesome for me,” said Sandoval at the workshop earlier this week.

Back in August, Governors from Nevada, Oregon and Utah expressed concern with a Trump administration directive that no longer requires off-site compensatory mitigation on most federal land as part of the Sage Grouse Initiative. Gov. Sandoval has written his expressed support for other changes the Trump administration has moved forward for the Endangered Species Act, but Sandoval’s office sent a letter to the Department of Interior asking it to allow the state to keep the mitigation program intact.

“Nevada has worked toward conservation of sage-grouse habitat, in part to prevent its listing under the Endangered Species Act,” said the Governor’s Policy Director Pam Robinson. “Better management, protection and restoration of sagebrush ecosystems are crucial to preventing the listing of greater sage-grouse in the future. Those goals are accomplished through compensatory mitigation and are often comprised of projects that include protection of valuable resources such as mesic meadows and natural springs, removal of pinion and juniper and the restoration of degraded habitat.”

According to Gov. Sandoval, state officials are still having conversations with the Trump administration about the plan’s future and what the curtailment of “compensatory mitigation” means.

County in New Mexico says residents have suffered because of the ESA. The Otero County Commission of New Mexico is sending letters to the Fish and Wildlife Service, the National Marine Fisheries Service and the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration to share their support of proposed changes to the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Changes that will affect the county include revising the definition of destruction or adverse modification, making determinations on a case-by-case basis and identifying the economic effects of listing an animal as endangered.

The southwestern county is made up of mostly government-owned lands and, according to one of the letters, “In the Lincoln National Forest, administered by the Forest Service, that agency keeps moving the goal posts on what it is trying to protect,” the letter states. “The Forest Service regulations killed the timber industry in this county. And now they are trying to kill the livestock industry, too.”

While U.S. Forest Service District Ranger Beth Humphrey does not agree with the county’s assessment in regard to the ESA’s impact on the timber and livestock industry, she is in support of the changes as well, saying, “I think it’s going to be easier for us to action [sic] within threatened, endangered species habitat and that’s a good thing for any industry that has impact on threatened and endangered species and their habitats.”

The public has until Monday, Sept. 24, to weigh in on the proposed changes.

In the News

Grijalva launches drive to save turtle research lab. E&E News. NOAA has long touted its Galveston Sea Turtle Facility as the only one of its size and class in the world. Today Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-Ariz.), the ranking member of the House Natural Resources Committee, launched a drive to save it. In a letter to Chris Oliver, the head of NOAA Fisheries, Grijalva said he was “alarmed” with NOAA’s plan to “effectively terminate the laboratory” to save between $600,000 and $800,000 a year in operating costs. Grijalva said he became aware of NOAA’s plan from a recent email sent to congressional staff, in which he said NOAA cited “budget restraints” as the reason for the cutback. “As you are aware, all species of sea turtles in U.S. waters are listed as either threatened or endangered under the Endangered Species Act,” Grijalva wrote in his letter. Grijalva also told Oliver that it does not appear NOAA has a clear plan in place for its transition. He asked Oliver to provide detailed information on how and when NOAA plans to scale back its operations and to elaborate on the agency’s budget constraints. A spokesman for NOAA Fisheries had no immediate response to the letter, saying the agency had not yet received it. According to the agency’s website, NOAA has been involved in international sea turtle research since 1978. Part of the work involves studying the molecular, cellular and biological effects of environmental pollutants on sea turtles.

Our view: ESA is good; so is vital development. Grand Forks Herald. The trendy term is “charismatic megafauna,” and it’s used to describe large animals of the world that have universal, popular appeal. Think bald eagles, grizzly bears and the like. It’s what most people likely consider when thinking of the Endangered Species Act, the landmark legislation signed by President Nixon in 1973. Conversely, probably few have heard of the sheepnose mussel, the Topeka shiner minnow or the Poweshiek skipperling butterfly. Yet it’s those tiny creatures — and not necessarily the popular “charismatic megafauna” — that grab the bulk of the attention as controversy grows around the ESA. The ESA’s chief goal is to determine endangered species, meaning those likely to become extinct. It also is used to determine threatened species and to protect habitat needed for a declared species’ survival. It passed Congress with almost unanimous approval and is notably credited with the rebound of the bald eagle, which teetered near extinction a half-century ago. Today, however, the ESA is a political issue. Republicans are pushing for new standards that would reduce problems created when humans and certain species collide.

DOJ rebuffs challenge to otter management, deference standard. E&E News. The Trump administration is urging the Supreme Court to reject an endangered species case that centers on sea otters but has bigger implications for agency deference questions. In a brief filed Friday, Justice Department lawyers argued that a petition from the Pacific Legal Foundation challenging the Fish and Wildlife Service’s management of threatened sea otters in California should not be accepted for review. Government lawyers dismissed PLF’s argument that a lower court issued an overly broad ruling based on what is known as Chevron deference — a legal standard under which judges defer to agency interpretations of ambiguous laws — when it upheld FWS’s decision to scrap an unusual otter management plan. The litigation stems from a 2012 decision by FWS to shut down a controversial program that established a “no otter zone” in certain Pacific fishing areas so fishermen could do their work without triggering liability for harming the at-risk creatures. Under the program, officials moved southern sea otters from the zone to San Nicolas Island off the coast of Los Angeles. But the effort was deemed unsuccessful, as many of the otters died or swam away. The agency suspended the program in the 1990s and canceled it in 2012.

International 10-year salmon preservation plan advances. Associated Press. Canada and the U.S. states of Alaska, Oregon and Washington would all reduce their catch of fragile salmon species under the terms of an updated international agreement that, if approved, will spell out the next decade of cooperation between the U.S. and Canada to keep the migratory fish afloat in Pacific waters. Members of the Pacific Salmon Commission on Monday recommended a conservation plan that stretches to 2028 after two years of intense negotiations involving fishermen, tribes on both sides of the border and state and federal officials. It must be approved by both the U.S. and Canadian governments. The international commission first met in 1985 to create more cooperation between Canada and the U.S. on protecting salmon, which migrate thousands of miles from inland streams to the Pacific Ocean and then back to their spawning place. The agreement covers pink, Coho, sockeye, chum and chinook salmon and spans a territory from Cape Falcon, Oregon, in the south to southeast Alaska in the north. The current agreement expires Dec. 31.

Enviros threaten lawsuit on giraffe protections. E&E News. Environmentalists will likely sue to force a Fish and Wildlife Service decision on whether giraffes deserve Endangered Species Act protection, multiple organizations announced today. Citing a missed deadline that’s incited litigation on other species, the Center for Biological Diversity and allied groups filed a required notice of intent to sue. The suit will target the Fish and Wildlife Service’s failure to meet deadlines triggered by an ESA petition. “As giraffe populations plummet, the Trump administration won’t even take the first step toward protecting these beautiful animals,” Tanya Sanerib, international program legal director at the Center for Biological Diversity, said in a statement. The notice of intent to sue gives the Fish and Wildlife Service 60 days to act before the environmental groups go to court. There’s no disputing FWS missed deadlines set under the 1973 law. On April 19, 2017, environmental groups filed their 124-page petition to list giraffes as endangered under the ESA. “The giraffe has suffered a major reduction in population size across its range primarily due to habitat loss, commercial overutilization, and severe poaching, and such decline continues unabated,” the petition stated, adding that “the Service has a duty to protect the iconic giraffe.”

State rejects protection for small redwoods forest predator. E&E News. Oregon fish and wildlife officials have rejected a request from six conservation groups to protect a small predator that inhabits old-growth redwood forests. The Oregon Fish and Wildlife Commission on Friday denied the petition by the conservation groups to protect the Humboldt marten under the Oregon Endangered Species Act. The sleek predator with an elongated body of about 14 inches eats mostly rodents but also birds and reptiles. Oregon allows it to be trapped for its fur. The species was thought to be extinct until it was found in redwoods in 1996. It’s believed that about 200 Humboldt martens live in two Oregon locations. Another small population is in California. The conservation groups have said the martens living on the southern Oregon coast are threatened by wildfires and rodent poisons used by marijuana growers. Populations in the state’s central coast are vulnerable because of a lack of mature forests and because they get hit by cars and die. The separate groups of martens are geographically isolated due to lack of connecting habitat, making them more susceptible to extinction, experts have said. The Center for Biological Diversity and Cascadia Wildlands were among the groups seeking protections for the martens.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/21/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Weekly Newsletter – 9/14/18 /weekly-newsletter-9-14-18/ Fri, 14 Sep 2018 17:46:12 +0000 /?p=7227 Issues Interior defends ESA changes. A top Trump administration official on Monday defended a plan to refurbish the Endangered Species Act (ESA), saying the proposed changes would result in more efficient and effective listing decisions. At a forum hosted by the Heritage Foundation think tank, Deputy Interior Secretary David Bernhardt said that lawmakers who passed the [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/14/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Interior defends ESA changes. A top Trump administration official on Monday defended a plan to refurbish the Endangered Species Act (ESA), saying the proposed changes would result in more efficient and effective listing decisions. At a forum hosted by the Heritage Foundation think tank, Deputy Interior Secretary David Bernhardt said that lawmakers who passed the ESA four decades ago created “a degree of ambiguity” that led to legal controversies in the following years. Bernhardt explained that the Interior Department worked with other agencies to craft a plan that would provide “clarity and predictability” to regulations covering endangered or threatened wildlife.

“We are intent on maintaining our environmental standards, but we are equally intent on leaving a reliable, efficient, and defensible regulatory regime in place that better serves the American people than what we found when we walked into the department, and I’m confident that we’ll be able to do this,” Bernhardt said in his remarks.

The Trump administration proposed a regulatory revamp in July that would end automatic protections for threatened animals and plants and opens the possibility of including cost-benefit analysis in listing decisions, making the process of removing a species from endangered or threatened status more efficient. “What we’re thinking about is how can we make the law work in a way that’s good for species and good for people,” he said.  Comments on the proposed changes will be accepted through Sept. 24.

Sue and Settle Secretarial Order. Last Friday, U.S. Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke signed a Secretarial Order to prevent the practice known as “sue and settle” by promoting public engagement, transparency, and accountability in Consent Decrees and Settlement Agreements. Over the past five years, the Department of Interior (DOI) has been party to a staggering number of settlement agreements and consent decrees, often with no input from or notice to the American people, leaving the door open for potential abuse. Secretarial Order 3368 is intended to alleviate concerns the litigation process has been used to undermine the procedural safeguards Congress put in place by giving the American people a window into where the money is going and a voice before DOI makes a recommendation to accept or enter into a settlement with large policy or budgetary implications. Read more on S.O. 3368 here.

Colorado Dems pushback on industry lease sales. Debate over the balance between energy development and sage-grouse conservation continues this week, with top Colorado Democrats objecting to public land leases in sage-grouse habitat. Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet (D) has joined Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper (D) in pushing the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to scale back a December oil and gas lease sale that he says could negatively affect more than 108,000 acres of greater sage-grouse habitat, as well as the state’s sensitive North Fork Valley region.

In letters to the U.S. Bureau of Land Management Tuesday, the two Democrats also asked the government not to go ahead with plans to let energy companies drill on habitat for the grouse. Similar discourse emerged late last year when the Department of Interior (DOI) and BLM issued notices announcing its intention to reconsider land use plans and withdraw provisions for 10 million acres of habitat on federal land. At the time, Gov. Hickenlooper welcomed the news with little trepidation, but recent lease sales have received pushback from the governor.

Oil and gas leases in key sage grouse habitat will still come with protective restrictions, notes Bob Budd, who chairs Wyoming Governor Mead’s sage grouse implementation team. For instance, permits prohibit companies from disturbing the ground on or near a lek, where sage-grouse gather for mating displays. “We were leasing in core areas before this,” he says. “It’s how you do it, not where you do it.” Industry officials agree, saying there is no need to limit leasing because modern drilling techniques allow companies to reach oil and gas deposits from a mile or two away.

“America’s independent oil and natural gas producers work hard every day to ensure that energy development, environmental stewardship, species conservation, and economic growth can thrive together across the nation,” wrote Barry Russell, President and CEO of the Independent Petroleum Association of America, in a 2015 op-ed recognizing the collaborative efforts between state governments, federal agencies and conservation groups to ensure the sage-grouse’s protection.

The comment period for the lease sale ended on September 11th. A notice of sale will be posted on October 22nd, 2018.

In the News

Duffy Wants Wolves Removed from Endangered Species List. WSAU. U.S. Representative Sean Duffy wants to remove gray wolves from the endangered species list. WAOW-TV reports Duffy introduced legislation this week to give management of endangered species lists to the states. He said in a statement, “Wisconsin deserves the opportunity to use science-based wildlife management for our own gray wolf population because we know what’s better for our state’s ecosystem better than activist judges in Washington.” The bill has bipartisan support in the House. This summer the state Department of Natural Resources reported between 900 and 950 wolves roamed the state during the winter and that there is evidence indicating the population is stabilizing. Wolves were initially removed from the list in 2011 but legal challenges led them to be put back on in 2014.

Forest Service proposes expedited energy permitting. E&E News, (Sub req’d). The Trump administration is proposing streamlined permitting for oil, gas and mineral projects in federal forests and grasslands. In two notices of proposed rulemaking slated for publication in tomorrow’s Federal Register, interim Forest Service chief Victoria Christiansen says the efforts are part of President Trump’s push to spur energy development. “The changes listed here have the potential to decrease the burden on industry, thus promoting domestic energy production primarily by making the leasing decision process simpler, and by aligning the Forest Service process with the [Bureau of Land Management] so that operators have one simplified permitting system,” the oil and gas notice says. The service said it intends to identify National Forest System tracts that BLM could offer for oil and gas leasing. Environmental groups and conservation groups protested, calling on the White House to cease its search for federal minerals.

Dems hope to improve landmark law in 2019. E&E News, (Sub req’d). Democrats hope an abbreviated fall congressional session coupled with electoral victory in November will help stave off Republican efforts to overhaul the Endangered Species Act.  GOP lawmakers in both chambers this year have introduced several legislative measures — stand-alone bills, packages and policy riders — to reform the 1973 law protecting imperiled wildlife. While Republicans view the proposals as much-needed updates to an outdated, ineffective and overly litigious law, Democrats perceive the efforts as transparent attempts to gut a landmark conservation law that has helped save wolves, bears and other iconic animals. “If we take the House back, none of these will ever get a vote in the 116th Congress,” Rep. Don Beyer (D-Va.) told E&E News after his remarks at a Capitol Hill press conference with other Democrats and environmental advocates to defend the ESA. Many Democrats, however, view that package and similar legislation from Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) as nothing more than initiatives to roll back protections for species and their habitat, as well as a disregard for the effect of climate change on animals such as the polar bear. Beyer said that if the lower chamber does manage to bring to the floor some of those Republican-led ESA bills this fall, “unfortunately, these attacks are likely to pass the House.” But, he added, “it’s very difficult to see how they get 60 votes in the Senate.”

Push to change wildlife act sparks lobbying blitz. The Hill. Action in Congress and the Trump administration to overhaul the Endangered Species Act (ESA) is spurring a lobbying frenzy. Industries that have long sought to reduce the compliance burden of protecting imperiled animal and plants species are seizing a rare moment with a Republican Congress and White House that are sympathetic to their cause. It’s been more than a dozen years since policymakers have shown such an interest in overhauling the ESA, and industries including agriculture, energy and developers are working hard to get something across the finish line. “This is an extremely important time, because the opportunity is there to make changes,” said Richard Pombo, a lobbyist and former congressman from California who led the last major effort, in 2005, to comprehensively change the ESA. His measure passed the House, but not the Senate, and he lost reelection in 2006, due in part to those efforts. “It’s probably the best we’ll have in terms of Congress and an administration willing to make changes that in previous years were much more difficult,” he said. Even if significant reform doesn’t happen this time around, lobbyists are happy that the issue has taken on such a high profile.

Interior Deferring to States, Reviewing Fish, Wildlife Protections. Natural Gas Intelligence. In a development sure to impact the oil and gas industry, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke said state regulatory agencies should have a higher profile in protecting fish and wildlife and asked his department to identify federal regulations that are more restrictive than those enacted by states. Zinke’s plans for the review were outlined in a two-page memo posted Tuesday by the nonprofit group Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER). Although the memo doesn’t specifically mention the greater sage grouse or the lesser prairie chicken, it appears the scope of the review should encompass efforts to protect the ground-dwelling birds. The industry has been working with federal and state regulators for years to protect the birds’ habitat from infrastructure such as well pads and pipelines. Zinke asked the officials to provide Interior’s deputy secretary with “a report containing detailed recommendations for the respective bureau or office to better align its regulations, policies and guidance with state provisions” within 90 days. The deputy secretary would then consult with state fish and wildlife agencies regarding the recommendations and deliver an implementation plan to Zinke within 180 days of the memo’s issuance.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/14/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Weekly Newsletter – 9/7/18 /weekly-newsletter-9-7-18/ Fri, 07 Sep 2018 16:34:44 +0000 /?p=7224 Issues Dispute over American Burying Beetle sparks lawsuit against USFWS. This week, a national conservation organization filed suit against the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) over a public records dispute involving the American burying beetle. Oklahoma State University entomologist, Wyatt Hoback, was once recruited by the Fish and Wildlife Service to study the high-profile [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/7/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Dispute over American Burying Beetle sparks lawsuit against USFWS. This week, a national conservation organization filed suit against the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) over a public records dispute involving the American burying beetle.

Oklahoma State University entomologist, Wyatt Hoback, was once recruited by the Fish and Wildlife Service to study the high-profile American burying beetle but after an experience Hoback described as “
frustrating and disheartening,” he ended his work with the agency. Hoback claimed “the Fish and Wildlife Service wanted to conclude that agriculture is not a risk to the beetle and were going to use the data in a way that made that conclusion, no matter what.” In particular, Hoback cited problems with how the agency has assessed the potential impact of agricultural development on the beetle currently listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act.

In 2015, an industry coalition that included the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA), petitioned Fish and Wildlife to delist the beetle as endangered. The government responded by beginning the species status assessment, which includes population trends and threats impacting the species. In support of the assessment, former director of government relations for IPAA, Sam McDonald, told The Washington Post, “The [Fish and Wildlife] Service should be expending its time on imperiled species. The American burying beetle isn’t one of them.”

After receiving a letter from one of Wyatt Hoback’s peers in the review process that voiced concerns similar to Hoback’s, the Center for Biological Diversity filed suit against USFWS because they did not receive public documents about the review process that were filed for in February. According to the U.S. Interior Department’s Freedom of Information Act request tracking page, USFWS categorized the center’s request as “exceptional/voluminous” and estimated it would be completed “after 05/23/2018.”

USFWS declined to comment since the litigation is pending and are referring all requests for comment to the U.S. Justice Department.

Rocky Mountain Governor, GOP reject sage grouse rules and pursue lawsuit. A lawsuit filed in April by Oakley-based brothers Douglas, Don and David Pickett, who own Tugaw ranch, has attracted the attention of top Idaho Republicans, including Governor C. L. “Butch” Otter. The suit alleges that the U.S. Bureau of Land Management and U.S. Forest Service failed to submit certain regulations regarding the Greater sage-grouse to Congress for review.

Idaho U.S. Attorney Bart Davis has asked the federal court to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing the plaintiffs do not have standing to sue. However, last month, Otter – along with Idaho House Speaker Scott Bedke and State Senate President Pro Tempore Brent Hill, requested permission from a federal judge to intervene. In a brief from Bedke, he cited the strong interest of the Idaho Legislature in such a case and the need to consider how federal land use issues concern citizens.

The regulations in dispute establish buffer zones as large as 3 miles in diameter around sage grouse “leks,” the traditional breeding grounds for the chicken-sized bird whose numbers have dwindled from 16 million to between 200,000 and 500,000 due in large part to wildfires, mining, livestock grazing and other development across 11 Western states.

The rules have sparked multiple lawsuits, but this is the first complaint to target the validity of the process used to create and implement the rules. Ultimately, the goal of this particular suit is to evoke the Congressional Review Act and have Congress review and reject the sage grouse rules.

In the News

Kavanaugh’s claims of pro-environment rulings face backlash. E&E News, (Sub req’d). President Trump’s pick for the Supreme Court sought to defend his environmental record yesterday while fielding wide-ranging questions from the Senate Judiciary Committee. Brett Kavanaugh, a judge for 12 years on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, came to his confirmation hearing armed with a list of cases that he says favor environmental interests. Kavanaugh briefly opined yesterday on legal issues affecting property rights and Western lands. He also offered a 2017 critical habitat ruling as an example of his property rights jurisprudence. In that case, he reversed a lower court decision and found that a council representing lumber companies had standing to challenge a designation that affected timber lands. “I found standing because I think it’s important to understand that when something like that happens, there are lots of affected parties,” he said. The first case on the Supreme Court’s schedule this term deals with critical habitat for an endangered frog in the South. Environmentalists worry Kavanaugh’s record doesn’t bode well for the species if he is confirmed to the bench.

Zinke hires Endangered Species Act critic for senior post. The Hill. Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke has hired an outspoken critic of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) for a senior position as the Trump administration undertakes a historic effort to ease industry compliance with the law. Robert Gordon — who recently penned a report alleging that the ESA has cost the country hundreds of billions of dollars — recently started work at the Interior Department as deputy assistant secretary for policy, management and budget, said Interior spokeswoman Faith Vander Voort. He works under Susan Combs, who is the acting assistant secretary for policy, management and budget, a position akin to a chief financial officer for the 70,000-person agency. “He has extensive experience working on natural resource issues in Congress and at national think tanks,” Vander Voort said in a statement. “Interior is proud to welcome top-tier talent. Rob Gordon brings impressive and diverse experience to the department, and we are excited to have him on our team.” Gordon has fought for decades while in positions both in an out of government to change the ESA. He most recently worked as an adjunct fellow at the conservative Competitive Enterprise Institute. Days before leaving for the government, he published a major report arguing that official estimates have dramatically underestimated the cost to industry and states for complying with the ESA, and that some single species can cost billions of dollars to protect.

BLM agrees to contested Utah mine expansion. E&E News, (Sub req’d). The Trump administration approved a Utah coal mine expansion yesterday to cheers from the state’s lawmakers, after years of environmental opposition. The Bureau of Land Management yesterday issued a record of decision that will allow the sale of another 30.8 million tons of coal at the Coal Hollow mine, roughly 10 miles from Bryce Canyon National Park. Alton Coal Development LLC originally filed an expansion application in 2004, eventually configured to include nearly 45 million tons of coal under 3,581 acres of public and private land near the town of Alton, Utah. BLM completed an environmental impact statement (EIS) for the project in 2011, but outcry over industrial development so close to Bryce Canyon led the agency to conduct additional analysis. Coinciding with the coal market’s collapse nationwide, the supplemental EIS was only completed in 2015. The final EIS, published in July, identified a preferred alternative that mined less coal on 2,114 acres. Interior Assistant Secretary for Land and Minerals Management Joe Balash selected that alternative yesterday based on potential impacts to water quality and habitat for the greater sage grouse.

Supreme Court To Evaluate Critical Habitat Limits As Services Ramp Up ESA Reform Efforts. Mondaq. As the Trump administration is pushing forward on its deregulatory agenda and, in particular, its efforts to improve the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and its implementation by the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) (together, the Services), the Supreme Court is poised to hear a landmark case on designation of critical habitat under the ESA that could provide some guideposts for the Services’ new regulations. On April 2, 2018, the Services sent over a package of proposed ESA regulations to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) that would likely result in significant changes for the ESA program and could streamline certain ESA-related federal permitting requirements. At the same time as these ESA reforms are under consideration by the White House, the Supreme Court is set to review the extent of the Services’ authority to designate critical habitat in Weyerhaeuser Co. v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, a timber company’s challenge to the FWS designation of approximately 1,500 acres of private land in Louisiana as critical habitat for the endangered dusky gopher frog. A divided panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit upheld FWS’s designation, even though the land at issue is unoccupied by the frog, cannot be occupied by the frog unless the land is significantly altered for the frog’s benefit, and does not play any supporting role in sustaining the frog or its habitat. The case, which is set for oral argument on October 1, 2018, will be the first case the Justices hear upon return from their summer recess and, if Judge Brett Kavanaugh is confirmed by then, it could be his first case on the bench. It will be the first ESA case decided by the Supreme Court in more than a decade.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/7/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Weekly Newsletter – 8/31/18 /weekly-newsletter-8-31-18/ Fri, 31 Aug 2018 16:13:08 +0000 /?p=7219 Issues Northern California Judge reverses FWS decision on grouse listing. This week, U.S. District Chief Magistrate Judge Joseph Spero of San Francisco restored protections for the bi-state sage grouse in California and Nevada. The judge had previously ruled federal wildlife officials illegally denied Endangered Species Act (ESA) protection for a population of bi-state sage grouse [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 8/31/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

Northern California Judge reverses FWS decision on grouse listing. This week, U.S. District Chief Magistrate Judge Joseph Spero of San Francisco restored protections for the bi-state sage grouse in California and Nevada. The judge had previously ruled federal wildlife officials illegally denied Endangered Species Act (ESA) protection for a population of bi-state sage grouse in California and Nevada in 2015. Under this new ruling, the bird will be listed as threatened until a new review determines its status.

Until that review, more than 2,800 square miles of critical habitat along the Sierra eastern front will be under a protected designation, another reinstatement of Judge Spero’s doing. The latest order follows Spero’s ruling last spring in which he agreed with a coalition of environmental groups that the service’s decision on the bi-state population was “arbitrary and capricious”.

The lawsuit filed two years ago by four environmental groups specifically challenged Fish and Wildlife’s decision to withdraw its October 2013 proposal to list the bi-state population as “threatened” under ESA. That decision, issued in April 2015, also involved withdrawing a proposal to designate 1.8 million acres of mostly federal land as critical habitat for the bird. The groups argued that nothing had changed since 2013, when the service proposed protections due to population declines from the loss and fragmentation of habitat due to urbanization, infrastructure development, conifer tree encroachment and changing wildfire patterns.

Spero agreed with the environmental groups that Fish and Wildlife “failed to adequately explain why it reversed course and denied protection” to the bi-state population. Spero’s ruling directs Fish and Wildlife to “provide a new opportunity for public comment on the Proposed Listing and shall prepare and publish in the Federal Register a new and final listing determination on the proposed rule.” The service has until Oct. 1, 2019 to respond.

New gas project approved in Wyoming Sage Grouse habitat. On Tuesday, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) approved Jonah Energy’s 3,500-well natural gas project in Sublette County, Wyoming. The project is one of the largest to be approved on public land in Wyoming and could contribute up to $17 billion in revenue over its 40-year lifespan, according to Bureau of Land Management estimates. It is expected to spearhead an economic boon as nearly 1 million acres of federal land in Wyoming will be offered for lease to oil and gas by the end of the year, and more projects are expected to follow.

The important project has also received attention due to its location in prime Greater sage-grouse habitat in southwest Wyoming. Numerous environmental groups are now looking into options to reverse the BLM’s decision as the project will affect more than 48,000 acres of what BLM classified in Obama-era federal sage grouse conservation plans as “priority habitat management areas.” The project area also includes 27,000 acres of “winter concentration areas” that the grouse use during the snowy season.

Jonah Energy, however, has continued to go above and beyond to protect the species while supporting critical energy and economic development in the region. According to the Casper Star Tribune, “Jonah has fostered a reputation for environmental stewardship over its lifetime in Wyoming.” Brian Rutledge, director of the National Audubon Society’s Sagebrush Ecosystem Initiative, has also expressed his optimism about the bird’s preservation in the area given that Paul Ulrich, Jonah Energy’s director of government and industry regulatory affairs, is a member of the Governor’s Sage-Grouse Implementation Team and has included him in project planning efforts to avoid harming the sage-grouse and their habitat.

In the News

Republicans say Endangered Species Act no longer working, call for major makeover. USA Today. Conservative Republicans are targeting the Endangered Species Act for a major makeover, arguing that the decades-old law is a failure. Their primary piece of evidence: Of the 2,493 species listed as threatened or endangered, only 54 have ever been recovered enough to be removed from the list – a delisting success rate of less than 3 percent. “As a doctor, if I admit 100 patients to the hospital and only three recover enough under my treatment to be discharged, Governor, I would deserve to lose my medical license with numbers like that,” said Sen. John Barrasso, of Wyoming, at a recent hearing on proposed reform legislation he drafted. The Republican lawmaker is a doctor. Democrats and environmental groups look at the law, passed in 1973 under a GOP president, and see a different picture. “They define success as delisting,” said Derek Goldman, with the Endangered Species Coalition that includes more than 400 national, state and local environmental and conservation groups. Instead, he said, the key statistic is 99 – the percentage of species listed under the law that have been saved from extinction. Work continues in both the House, under the leadership of House Natural Resources Chairman Rob Bishop of Utah, and the Senate to promote reasonable and measured changes to the law.

How Trump’s legal woes may alter enviro, energy issues. E&E News, (Sub req’d). Political fallout from President Trump’s mounting legal troubles is reverberating in Congress, with Democrats and Republicans jostling over how it will affect the ongoing Supreme Court battle, spending fights and the midterm elections. It is too soon to know whether this week’s guilty plea by former Trump attorney Michael Cohen and the federal convictions of former campaign manager Paul Manafort will turn GOP fortunes. Another possibility, as has often been the case in the Trump era, is that the latest political storm will pass while Republicans, who control all of government, press their agenda with Democrats having few options to halt it. Almost immediately, Senate Democrats used the legal woes to push back against Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, Brett Kavanaugh, and call for at least slowing his confirmation process. Any delay in seating Kavanaugh to the bench would have an immediate impact for the environmental community. The first case the high court will consider when it convenes on Oct. 1 is its first review of the Endangered Species Act in nearly a decade.

US government failing to provide recovery plans for some endangered species. Nature. The number of endangered species that the United States government has no recovery plans for has grown steadily over the past decade, according to an analysis published this month in Conservation Letters1. The plans detail the specific threats against a species as well as the ‘nuts and bolts’ strategies that will help the species recover. They are also mandated under the Endangered Species Act, the country’s key conservation law. Researchers used publicly available data from the US Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, the agencies tasked with developing recovery plans, to determine how many species lacked such safeguards and how that has changed since 1978. They found that of 1,548 species eligible for a plan, 24.5% were currently still without. Furthermore, the analysis showed that the number of recovery plans has always lagged behind the number of species listed, but that the gap between the two has widened since 2009, when the rate of species listings increased (See ‘Endangered Plans’). “There isn’t enough funding for the services to close that gap,” says lead author Jacob Malcom, a conservation biologist at the Defenders of Wildlife in Washington DC. And without the plans, he says, people won’t know what threatens a species and may be unwittingly preventing their recovery.

Armed Services’ climate focus will be different with Inhofe. E&E News, (Sub req’d). Inhofe is now widely expected to succeed McCain as Senate Armed Services Committee chairman, a perch that gives him oversight of all Pentagon energy and environmental policies. The military has long been one of the world’s largest consumers of oil, propelling its jet planes and powering military bases around the globe. Although Inhofe and McCain might have long-standing political ties and records as military hawks, there are notable breaks in how the senators have approached energy and environmental issues facing the Defense Department. And like their onetime campaign flight, their arguments over those topics could get heated. McCain and Inhofe also broke over a push by conservatives to attach provisions to this year’s defense bill that would have prevented the sage grouse and prairie chicken from being listed under the Endangered Species Act for 10 years and would have delisted the American burying beetle. McCain’s opposition was seen as crucial to the ESA provisions being dropped from the final bill, despite House support. Inhofe said it would be up to the committee to decide whether the same language would be proposed next year, but his support makes it more likely than not it would stay in.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 8/31/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Weekly Newsletter – 8/24/18 /weekly-newsletter-8-24-18/ Fri, 24 Aug 2018 15:56:48 +0000 /?p=7217 Issues While ESA reform is considered, cost for maintaining the program cannot be forgotten. The Department of the Interior recently proposed targeted changes to the rules implementing the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA). While examining and modernizing parts of the ESA that have gone untouched for four decades is a welcomed change, a new [...]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 8/24/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>
Issues

While ESA reform is considered, cost for maintaining the program cannot be forgotten. The Department of the Interior recently proposed targeted changes to the rules implementing the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA). While examining and modernizing parts of the ESA that have gone untouched for four decades is a welcomed change, a new report highlights one aspect of the law that requires increased attention — its ballooning costs.

According to a new study released on Tuesday, protecting endangered species likely costs the economy hundreds of billions of dollars more than the federal government’s official estimates. The libertarian think tank responsible for the study, Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), explained that the government does not factor in broader economic cost, such as lost investment opportunities for energy development.

“Whatever the [Endangered Species Act’s] cost is, it is much larger than generally acknowledged, and likely measured in the hundreds of billions of dollars,” the report concludes. “Unfortunately, the ESA’s poor record of recovering species does not indicate that we are getting what we pay for.” The federal government’s estimates “woefully lowball” the actual costs to taxpayers, landowners, and state and local governments for protecting endangered and threatened wildlife, according to the report’s summary.

The report is being released as the Trump administration is taking comment on three proposed regulations to update and reform the management of endangered species, which are expected to be more beneficial for local state economies and energy development. IPAA plans to submit detailed comments to the docket.

Sage grouse hunting domain shut done following habitat-destroying wildfires. Wildfires in Nevada have destroyed a significant amount of sage grouse habitat, prompting the Nevada Board of Wildlife (NBW) to approve an emergency closure of two hunting units in Humboldt and Elko counties. Last month, the Martin Fire destroyed 39 known breeding sites supporting 750 male grouse, according to NBW. The agency says the fire that started in Paradise Valley north of Winnemucca burned 689 square miles of mostly rangeland — the largest fire in Nevada history.

The hunting ban covers an area twice the size of Delaware – accounting for more than 3,500 square miles to recoup the losses of the Martin fire after it destroyed a key winter habitat. “This fire negatively affected one of the few remaining stronghold habitats for greater sage-grouse and a myriad of other sagebrush obligate species in Nevada,” said Shawn Espinosa, a state game expert.

In the News

Trump administration order may put sage grouse on endangered list. Las Vegas Review-Journal. A Trump administration directive eliminating industry and developer payments for habitat protection in exchange for use of public lands has officials in Western states scrambling for answers and worried about economic consequences if the threatened greater sage grouse is listed as endangered. The Bureau of Land Management issued the directive in July to discontinue “compensatory mitigation,” a tool that provided funds to protect wildlife habitat. Governors in Western states agreed in 2015 to a plan that used compensatory mitigation to offset environmental damage, which kept the Obama administration from listing the sage grouse as endangered. The agreement allowed public land use by ranchers and oil, gas and mining interests, which provide local jobs. Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke has been critical of compensatory mitigation, and the BLM directive claimed the practice could not be legally enforced. The new directive does allow for voluntary participation. But without dedicated funds to protect habitat, and with the loss of state control over public land use, the federal directive poses new problems and concerns about the long-term economic impact on communities.

Citing climate change, court slaps FWS for not listing fish. E&E News, (Sub req’d). Federal judges on Friday struck down a 2014 Fish and Wildlife Service decision against listing an imperiled cold-water fish, holding the agency failed to consider how warmer temperatures and decreased stream flows due to climate change would affect the species. At issue is the arctic grayling, a relative of salmon, that was historically found in Montana, Wyoming and Michigan. Its populations have plummeted, leaving only one population in the Upper Missouri River Basin in Montana. Conservationists have pressed regulators for more than three decades to extend Endangered Species Act protections to the fish. After a legal settlement, FWS in 2014 promulgated a policy that didn’t list the fish as threatened or endangered. The Center for Biological Diversity, the Western Watersheds Project and others quickly sued. A lower court deferred to FWS, but the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals struck down part of that ruling Friday, stating that FWS acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner by failing to explain why the uncertainty of climate change favors a not listed status. The 9th circuit remanded the case to the lower court for further deliberation.

Can markets save the lesser prairie chicken? The Garden City Telegram. The booming calls of the lesser prairie chicken once rung out across western Kansas. Accounts from the 1800s mention bands of hunters bagging dozens of birds each. Railways advertised special trains that brought sportsmen to shoot the birds in the Texas panhandle, complete with ice cars to preserve the meat on the ride home. Then, over a century of plowing prairies into farmland decimated the birds. More recently, droughts brought their numbers to an all-time recorded low in 2013. Today, the birds aren’t listed as endangered, but they’re considered a conservation-dependent species — meaning without consistent protection they’ll go extinct. For decades, endangered listings — and the regulations that come with them — have pulled animals back from the brink of extinction. In western Kansas, those restrictions hinder development, which is primarily oil and gas extraction, and family farms — the lifeblood of many Kansans. To try and keep the birds off the endangered list, Kansas and nearby states are trying a new proactive plan. They’re telling developers, if you voluntarily help protect the birds, you’ll be exempt from future regulations.

New Mexico’s birds and trees are dying. Daily Lobo. Bird populations in New Mexico are failing to take off — in fact, they’re nosediving. A study conducted by scientists at the Los Alamos National Labs (LANL) found that piñon pine trees are dying in growing numbers, which is having adverse effects on wildlife in the area — especially birds. Researchers believe climate change is one of the reasons. The study, conducted by Jeanne Fair and Charles Hathcock, concluded that “piñon mortality may be a significant threat to bird communities in the southwestern U.S.” It also stated that piñon-juniper woodlands, in which piñon trees thrive, may disappear completely by the year 2100, according to a LANL press release. Piñon pines are the state tree of New Mexico and are found throughout the Southwest. “It’s really quite disturbing,” said Jonathan Hayes, vice president and executive director of Audubon New Mexico, a nature sanctuary in Santa Fe. “The Pajarito Plateau is named that for its bird abundance, so it’s really ironic that we’re seeing huge bird decline in that area.”

Utah Sen. Mike Lee’s bill mandates northern corridor route across Red Cliffs. The Spectrum. U.S. Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, took his turn Wednesday pushing legislation that would require federal land managers to make room for a controversial “northern corridor” highway across protected tortoise habitat in the Red Cliffs National Conservation Area north of St. George. The bill — S. 3297, the Washington County, Utah, Public Land Act — would expand protected habitat into a separate area west of the city as a way to mitigate any impacts to tortoises living in the conservation area. Lee’s bill is a Senate companion to a similar measure introduced in the House by Rep. Chris Stewart, R-Utah. Lee said the proposal would balance the needs of Mojave tortoise, which is listed as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act, with fast-growing Washington County’s increasing demands for a new transportation and utility corridor. He said the measure would also push the Bureau of Land Management to live up to a requirement first included in a 2009 public lands bill that directed the agency to “identify” a route for the highway.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 8/24/18 appeared first on Endangered Species Watch - ESAwatch.org.

]]>