Lesser Prairie Chicken – ESAWatch Fri, 13 May 2016 19:42:33 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.4.3 Weekly Newsletter 5-13-16 /weekly-newsletter-5-13-16/ /weekly-newsletter-5-13-16/#respond Fri, 13 May 2016 19:42:33 +0000 /?p=6466 Issues Administration won’t appeal Texas court’s decision on lesser prairie chicken. The Obama Administration said Wednesday that it would not appeal recent court rulings by a U.S. District Court that removed Endangered Species Act protections for the lesser prairie chicken. […]

The post Weekly Newsletter 5-13-16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

Administration won’t appeal Texas court’s decision on lesser prairie chicken. The Obama Administration said Wednesday that it would not appeal recent court rulings by a U.S. District Court that removed Endangered Species Act protections for the lesser prairie chicken. Critics of the agency’s 2014 decision to list the chicken as “threatened” had said the designation was unnecessary because of efforts by landowners, industry, and states to protect the bird and its habitat. The Fish and Wildlife Service said that it still “intends to reassess the status of the species based on the court’s ruling and the best available scientific data.”

In February, a U.S. District Court judge upheld his September 2015 ruling that overturned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to list the lesser prairie chicken as threatened, denying the Department of Interior and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s motion to amend his judgement. Federal attorneys had asked the judge to amend his ruling instead of vacating the listing decision so the Fish and Wildlife Service could make a new determination that appropriately considered a range-wide conservation plan the judge had cited in his decision to overturn the listing. The federal lawyers also asked the judge to limit his ruling to Texas and New Mexico, a request the judge denied.

Senator Jim Inhofe (OK), chairman of the Environment and Public Works Committee, called this week’s announcement “welcome and different news from this administration.” Kansas Senator Jerry Moran said the decision to drop the appeal “highlights administration’s flawed approach to listing the lesser prairie chicken as a threatened species in the first place. Stakeholders in Kansas need certainty on the listing.” Representative Kevin Yoder (KS), who added an amendment to delist the chicken to the Interior appropriations bill last year, feared the fight is not yet over, stating “I’m skeptical this is the end of the road.”

IPAA and API submit comments on proposed Mitigation Policy revisions. Earlier this week, the Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) and the American Petroleum Institute (API) submitted joint comments on the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s proposed revisions to its Mitigation Policy. The Mitigation Policy provides guidelines  to limitadverse impacts of land and water development on species and their habitats. The agency says the policy revisions are needed to bring the policy in line with changes in conservation practices since the policy was implemented in 1981.

“The Draft Policy improperly expands the Service’s authority beyond that delegated by Congress, and lacks statutory and regulatory justification,” IPAA and API wrote in their comments. “Its onerous requirements and ambiguous standards will lead to delays in federal approvals and authorizations, both by the Service and other federal agencies.” The groups specifically took issue with the Service’s ambiguous new standards and the expansion of its authority over unlisted species, among other changes. “The Service’s asserted authority is defined so broadly that it effectively would allow the Service to require mitigation of any impacts to the natural environment in the United States,” they explained.

Native American tribes work together to help monarch butterflies. At a news conference on Tuesday, seven Native American tribes in Oklahoma announced they will work together to create habitat and food on tribal lands for monarch butterflies, whose population has declined in recent years from a variety of factors. The tribes will plant milkweed and native nectar-producing plants on their land and will coordinate with the University of Kansas’ Monarch Watch program, which is supported by a $250,000 grant from the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation.

The new partnership is the continuation of tribes’ previous work to support pollinators, said Thalia Miller, director of the Chickasaw Nation Horticulture Department. “For the last several years, we have been raising bees and pollinators, so when this opportunity came along, it fit with what we were doing,” she told reporters. Monarch butterflies have faced an increasing number of threats in recent years, including the loss of milkweed and threats to their wintering habitat in Mexico. Researchers believe improved weather and the end of a severe drought in Texas were likely responsible for a recent bump in the monarch population this year.

In the News

Resources riders unlikely in Senate authorization markup. E&E News (sub req’d). The Senate Armed Services Committee is set to take up its version of the defense authorization bill this week. Unlike the House Armed Services Committee, the Senate committee has historically shied away from including natural resources language in its version of the bill. Committee Chairman John McCain (R-Ariz.) is known for asking members to pass a clean bill, and has also expressed his distaste for attempting to address current hot-button issues like the endangered species listing of the greater sage grouse. “I hope it is not,” he said. “I have heard that is the case, but I hope that it will not be the result, because the sage grouse was removed from the prospect of being listed as endangered, and I thought that had taken off a lot of the pressure on that.”

Feds allow wind industry to kill more eagles. Washington Examiner. It’s open season for bald eagles under a new proposed federal plan to increase the number birds that can be killed by wind farms and other energy projects. The Fish and Wildlife Service is publishing a proposed rule Friday upping the number of eagles currently allowed to be incidentally killed by an energy project from 1,130 to 4,200. The agency says the bald eagle population is healthy enough to sustain added losses. “We estimate there are about 143,000 bald eagles in the United States, and that populations continue to increase,” according to a pre-publication copy of the proposed rule to be published Friday in the Federal Register. “Given their continued population growth above the 2009 baseline, there is considerable capacity to sustain take of bald eagles.”

Conservationists consider legal options to fight seismic testing for oil in Big Cypress National Preserve. Naples Daily News. Conservation groups are considering their legal options in the wake of a final sign-off by the National Park Service on a Texas company to look for oil in the Big Cypress National Preserve. Burnett Oil Co. wants to use specially designed off-road vehicles to drive through 70,000 acres of the 700,000-acre preserve in eastern Collier County, stopping at spots to vibrate steel plates against the ground and see whether seismic signals from underground indicate geologic formations that might contain oil or gas. After a nearly two-year review that triggered protests and political maneuvers, federal regulators issued a finding late Friday that the work would have “no significant impact” on the preserve’s forests and wet prairies or the wildlife that live there, including endangered Florida panthers.

Meet the Army guy who fights for the sage grouse. E&E News (sub req’d). As the Air Force’s deputy director of logistics, Eugene Collins looked after pilots, making sure they had what they needed to soar. Now the Army’s deputy assistant secretary for environment, safety and occupational health, Collins is looking out for a feathery squadron. “My new pilots are endangered species,” the retired colonel said. “I’ve gone from worrying about pilots and missiles and bombs to being concerned about tortoises, northern long-eared bats and greater sage grouse, making sure that we can respect and live in harmony with the environment.”

Big Cypress OKs oil exploration in panther habitat. E&E News (sub req’d). Trucks may soon be crisscrossing wetlands in the Big Cypress National Preserve as part of a Texas company’s bid to find underground oil and gas reserves in the vast South Florida swamp. The National Park Service approved the plan last week, saying the effort would have “no significant impact” on wildlife and environment in the 70,000-acre exploration area. The decision will open Big Cypress to oil exploration for the first time in 17 years — and could potentially kick off a new period of litigation at a preserve whose conflicting mission seems to always lead it to court. In its environmental assessment, NPS reasons that vegetation will grow back and trucks will avoid sensitive habitat and endangered species with the help of NPS staff and field observers.

Trump’s son woos sportsmen, covets top job at Interior. E&E News (sub req’d). As Donald Trump seeks to win over skeptical Republicans on Capitol Hill and fence-sitting voters, he seems to have wooed one important voting bloc: sportsmen. The Trump campaign has pledged to nominate a hunter to lead the Fish and Wildlife Service, aggressively fight lawsuits by anti-hunting groups, make wildlife habitat more productive, and control predators like wolves that prey on game species like elk. Would Trump roll back Obama administration oil and gas leasing reforms designed to keep drilling farther from national parks and backcountry areas while tightening regulations on hydraulic fracturing? Would he dismantle Obama’s sage grouse plan by loosening restrictions on drilling, mining and grazing? What kind of influence would Trump exert on Endangered Species Act decisions that can affect hunters and energy companies?

Counties, state decry ‘D.C. down’ land management changes. Deseret News. The nation’s largest landlord wants to change how it manages public lands, hoping for what it says is more flexibility to institute plans that encompass sweeping landscapes not beholden to artificial boundaries. Sage grouse, wildlife and winding rivers don’t recognize man-carved field office boundaries within the Bureau of Land Management’s inventory of public lands, so the BLM wants greater latitude to manage for those large-scale issues. County leaders in Western states with vast amount of public lands, however, said the proposed BLM Planning 2.0 rule diminishes the role of local input by giving those closest to the land less deference at the planning table.

Expert says habitat loss to blame for rapid decline of the monarch butterfly population. Orlando Sentinel. With the population of monarch butterflies only making marginal advances in growth, botanist Scott Davis wants you to know there’s something you can do. “If every yard in the state had milkweed, preferably native, the monarch butterfly population would explode,” he said. Certainly it’s not as simple as that, but small steps can make huge advances in a butterfly population that is dying off from a severe shortage of essential native milkweed, an overuse of pesticides and the proliferation of a protozoan parasite. Davis said the leading factor that has led to the rapid decline in Florida is habitat loss, which has significantly reduced native milkweed. Another factor is the Ophryocystis elektroscirrha protozoan parasite that can build up on non-native milkweed plants and kill the insects.

Butterfly recovery receives blow from winter storm kill. Detroit Free Press. An unusually cold, fierce winter storm in Mexico over a few days last March could mean seeing less of a once-regular summertime sight in Michigan — monarch butterflies. The storm hit around March 10 with snow, high winds and freezing temperatures in some of the prime over-wintering grounds for the migrating monarchs, the high mountain oyamel fir forests in southern Mexico, places where they congregate in the tens of millions for winter. Monarchs are essentially tropical insects, but can tolerate cooler temperatures. However, they can freeze to death in sub-freezing temps over prolonged periods. “The mortality was really high; I would say in the millions,” said David Mota-Sanchez, a Michigan State University entomologist who is helping research the impact of the winter storm on the butterflies.

Push to start pipeline construction meets firm opposition. Associated Press. Opponents of a proposed oil pipeline slated to run through four Midwestern states pressed Iowa regulators Thursday to keep a Texas-based petroleum company from starting construction before all federal permits are approved. Dakota Access planned on beginning construction by now on the 1,150-mile pipeline that’s designed to carry a half-million barrels of oil a day from the Bakken oil fields in northwest North Dakota to a tank storage facility in south-central Illinois. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers was notified by the federal Interior Department earlier this month that its responsibilities under the federal Endangered Species Act have not been met and further study is required into the project’s impact on the endangered Dakota skipper butterfly — an assessment that could take as long as 90 days.

The post Weekly Newsletter 5-13-16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-5-13-16/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 5/6/16 /weekly-newsletter-5616/ /weekly-newsletter-5616/#respond Fri, 06 May 2016 21:55:06 +0000 /?p=6461 Issues Federal government pledges to restore 500K acres of lesser prairie chicken habitat. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) vowed last week to restore an additional 500,000 acres of lesser prairie chicken habitat across five states via a voluntary landowner […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 5/6/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

Federal government pledges to restore 500K acres of lesser prairie chicken habitat. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) vowed last week to restore an additional 500,000 acres of lesser prairie chicken habitat across five states via a voluntary landowner incentive program. Because over 95 percent of prairie chicken habitat is privately owned, the USDA believes cooperation with landowners and ranchers is essential to recovering the species. Last week’s announcement is just the most recent action under the Lesser Prairie-Chicken Incentive, a program that began in 2010 and has so far restored over one million acres of lesser prairie chicken habitat.

Though the bird was listed as ‘threatened’ in 2014, many raised objections over proposed federal management plans out of concern that they would negatively impact development activities. A federal judge in Texas removed the bird’s ‘threatened’ status last year following a lawsuit filed by the Permian Basin Petroleum Association against the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. This action led the USDA to propose the voluntary three-year conservation strategy under the farm bill that allows landowners and ranchers to receive fiscal incentives for adopting conservation practices on their properties that support the lesser prairie chicken.

Obama administration proposes changes to voluntary agreements. The Obama Administration proposed changes earlier this week to the voluntary agreements the federal government makes with landowners to help protect imperiled species and prevent their listing under the Endangered Species Act. The draft policy and rule proposed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service would alter the criteria used to approve candidate conservation agreements with assurances (CCAAs). The CCAAs allow landowners and developers to conserve or restore habitat for species undergoing a population decline in exchange for assurances that they won’t be impacted by additional regulations if the species is eventually listed. The agencies also finalized a policy in February that clarified that lands enrolled in CCAAs and other conservation programs will be excluded from designation as critical habitat for listed species.

Currently, agencies need to conclude that the benefits of conservation offered by the landowner, when combined with actions from “other necessary properties,” would “preclude or remove any need to list the covered species.” Fish and Wildlife Services faults the current language for relying on other landowners to undertake additional actions that are beyond an individual landowner’s control. The new language would eliminate references to “other necessary properties” and merely require a CCAA to provide a “net conservation benefit” to the specified species. The agencies hope the new language will encourage more landowners to enter into CCAAs.

FWS proposes 30-year permits to kill bald and golden eagles. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) announced this week that it was reviving a proposal to allow energy companies to receive 30-year permits to disturb and kill bald and golden eagles, in hopes of encouraging more companies to commit to eagle conservation measures. The Service has only allowed five-year eagle “take” permits since 2009, though the agency first proposed 30-year permits in 2013 – a move that was struck down last August by a federal judge who required FWS to prepare a National Environmental Policy Act review evaluating the new rule’s impact. The FWS released a draft programmatic environmental impact statement this week alongside the draft rule to fulfill the judge’s requirement.

Though companies are not required to obtain eagle take permits, without them they are more vulnerable to prosecution under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act. Under the proposed rule, companies would be required to fund conservation measures that would protect more than one eagle for every eagle expected to be killed or harmed. The wind industry welcomed the expanded permits, but was hesitant to embrace the proposal, which would require potentially costly reviews every 5 years to ensure the predicted take levels are not being exceeded.

Conservation groups welcomed the increased government oversight, but resisted endorsing a program that allows eagles to be killed. Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe responded to concerns over the new rule in an op-ed. “Under no circumstances will we jeopardize the success of bald eagle recovery or create impediments to healthy, thriving golden eagle populations,” he wrote. “That’s our commitment to you, and our obligation under the law.”

In the News

US agency’s Nevada boss urges roundup of 4,000 mustangs. Associated Press. The U.S. Bureau of Land Management’s Nevada director wants to free up more federal rangeland for livestock grazing this summer by rounding up 4,000 wild horses in Elko County— more than were gathered across 10 Western states combined last year. BLM Nevada Director John Ruhs, Gov. Brian Sandoval and state wildlife officials say removing the mustangs from four herd-management areas in Elko County near the Utah line would also benefit the greater sage grouse. Conservationists say the call for more roundups is a misguided attempt to placate ranchers at the expense of horses and grouse. Cattle do far more damage than mustangs to the drought-stricken range and the imperiled bird, they say.

Town supports mine in butterfly reserve. Mexico Daily News. Plans to reopen a copper mine located within the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve are moving forward, according to the mayor of Angangueo, who says the Michoacán state government is directly involved. Leonel Martínez Maya also denies that the reactivation of mining activities in the municipality would have a detrimental effect on the monarch butterflies or their habitat. The mine, owned by Grupo México, the largest mining conglomerate in the country, has been performing exploration and maintenance activities, he said.

Rosemont Mine won’t affect endangered species. Arizona Daily Star. The proposed Rosemont Mine will not jeopardize the existence or illegally destroy habitat for 12 imperiled species living in and around the mine site, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said Tuesday. The agency, however, said it will cause significant adverse effects on many of them. The new, long-awaited report, said that many of the mine’s negative impacts on species will be ameliorated by a host of mitigation measures, some new, some previously disclosed. The new ones include financing of a biologist/project manager for monitoring of impacts on wildlife, a $3 million program to manage and remove invasive species and a $1.25 million program to upgrade habitat for the endangered Southwestern willow flycatcher and the Western yellow-billed cuckoo. Note: Associated Press also reports.

Biological reviews don’t stop projects, study says. Arizona Daily Star. It’s no surprise that the new Rosemont Mine Final Biological Opinion concluded the mine won’t illegally jeopardize imperiled species or destroy their habitat — or that it’s not proposing to stop the project. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service didn’t stop a single project nationally over a seven-year period ending last year due to an endangered-species review, a recent study found. In that time, out of 6,829 formal reviews, the service only twice found that a project would jeopardize species’ existence and once concluded a project would illegally destroy critical habitat, said the study, written by two Defenders of Wildlife scientists.

Property owners ask Supreme Court to review sturgeon ruling. E&E News (sub req’d). West Coast property owners challenging habitat protections for the threatened green sturgeon are asking the Supreme Court to hear their complaints. A three-judge panel on the 9th Circuit last July unanimously sided with the government in the case, upholding the National Marine Fisheries Service’s designation of critical habitat for the threatened fish on the West Coast. The bottom-dwelling species lives in coastal estuaries and marine waters from Mexico to Alaska. The sturgeon’s southern population segment is only known to spawn in the Sacramento River, and its population has been hurt by construction of dams, pesticides, bycatch, poaching and the introduction of exotic species.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 5/6/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-5616/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 4/29/16 /weekly-newsletter-42916/ /weekly-newsletter-42916/#respond Fri, 29 Apr 2016 18:41:31 +0000 /?p=6458 Issues U.S. decides against setting aside protected habitat for northern long-eared bat. Federal wildlife officials announced Monday that they would not set aside protected habitat for the caves inhabited by northern long-eared bats, explaining that doing so may draw the […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 4/29/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

U.S. decides against setting aside protected habitat for northern long-eared bat. Federal wildlife officials announced Monday that they would not set aside protected habitat for the caves inhabited by northern long-eared bats, explaining that doing so may draw the attention of delinquents seeking to harm the bats or their habitats. The northern long-eared bat population has been devastated in recent years by white-nose syndrome, widely-present in the Eastern U.S. and recently discovered on the West Coast.

The northern long-eared bat was listed as a threatened species last year, a designation that limited the seasons during which developers can remove trees within the bats’ habitat. “While critical habitat has a fundamental role to play in recovering many of our nation’s most imperiled species, in the case of the northern long-eared bat, whose habitat is not a limiting factor in its survival, designating it could do more harm than good,” said Tom Melius, a regional director for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

New research suggests lack of milkweed ‘unlikely’ to be driving species’ decline. A Cornell University study has cast doubt on the widely accepted claim that the recent decline in monarch butterfly populations is a result of disappearing milkweed. The study suggests that “sparse autumnal nectar sources, weather and habitat fragmentation” are largely responsible for the species’ plight. Milkweed is the sole source of food for the butterfly’s caterpillars in summer but not as the monarchs depart for their migration to Mexico in autumn. “The problem appears to occur after they take flight in the fall,” said Anurag Agrawal, a Cornell University professor and the senior author of the paper.

Agrawal said improved weather and the end of a severe drought in Texas were likely responsible for the recent monarch population rebound. “Given the intense interest in monarch conservation, the blame being put on herbicide use and the national dialogue about potentially listing monarchs under the Endangered Species Act, we have to get the science right,” Agrawal said. Mexico recently announced it was creating a new police force dedicated to protecting the country’s protected habitats, including the Monarch Butterfly Sanctuary where tens of millions of monarchs spend the winter.

In the News

Feds vow to restore 500K acres to lesser prairie chicken. Santa Fe New Mexican. The U.S. Department of Agriculture pledged Thursday to restore 500,000 acres across five states, including the eastern plains of New Mexico, as habitat for the lesser prairie chicken through a voluntary landowner incentive program. Objections have been raised about a proposed federal management plan for the bird, and industries say protections would infringe on their activities, particularly in oil and gas production. In 2015, a federal judge in Texas removed the bird from the endangered species list, stripping its protections, after the Permian Basin Petroleum Association sued the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Instead, the USDA has proposed a voluntary, three-year conservation strategy that courts landowners and stakeholders in recovery efforts. Under the farm bill, landowners and ranchers are able to receive monetary incentives for implementing conservation practices on their property that encourage the prairie chickens to thrive. Note: Wichita Eagle also reports.

Miners sue over sage grouse land lockup. Capital Press. The American Exploration & Mining Association, in Spokane, has filed a lawsuit in federal district court in Washington, D.C., challenging federal restrictions on mineral exploration and development in Western states. Allegedly to protect sage grouse, federal agencies have restricted mineral exploration and development on more than 10 million acres of federal land in California, Oregon, Idaho, Nevada, Montana, Utah and Wyoming. The association, formerly the Northwest Mining Association, represented by Mountain States Legal Foundation, Denver, filed suit April 19 alleging federal agencies lack authority to withdraw the land from operation of the General Mining Law of 1872 and failed to provide for adequate public participation in the process by which federal land use planning documents are amended and revised.

U.S. claims success in efforts to save endangered species. The Guardian. The world may be hurtling to the worst extinction crisis since the dinosaurs were wiped out, but the US is claiming success in its own efforts to prevent species following the path of titanosaurs, dodos and passenger pigeons. A total of 34 species have been removed from federal Endangered Species Act protections since 1978 due to them recovering, rather than becoming extinct. This pace has accelerated under Barack Obama’s presidency – 16 of the 34 recovered species have been delisted during the current administration.

Monarch butterflies face ‘quasi-extinction’ – but hope is on the wing. NBC News. The iconic North American monarch butterfly is in “substantial” danger of becoming “quasi-extinct” — despite recent population growth, according to a new study. The beautifully delicate creature may no longer fill North American skies in the next 20 years, according to the study published at the end of March in the journal Scientific Reports. Dan Ashe, the director of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, told the Associated Press in February that the United States had managed to restore about 250,000 acres of milkweed in the first year, and raised about $20 million for the program.

Wildfire rehab effort going well so far in Idaho, Oregon. Associated Press. Scientists say a $67 million rehabilitation effort following a wildfire in southwest Idaho and southeast Oregon is starting off well thanks to good precipitation over the winter. The new wildfire approach ordered by Interior Secretary Sally Jewell last year is credited with preventing many small rangeland wildfires from getting big. But the Soda Fire scorched 436 square miles of sagebrush steppe that supports cattle grazing and some 350 species of wildlife, including sage grouse. Jewell’s order calls for a “science-based” approach to safeguard greater sage grouse while contending with fires that have been especially destructive in the Great Basin. The bird did not receive federal protections under the Endangered Species Act last fall.

Dems seek to block Atlantic surveys over ‘negative impacts’. E&E News (sub req’d). More than a dozen Democratic senators are asking President Obama to prevent seismic surveys along the Atlantic Coast, citing “serious negative impacts” to marine mammals and fishing. The letter to Obama comes after the administration announced it would not open Atlantic waters to oil and gas drilling, eliminating lease sales from the Interior Department’s 2017-22 plan. Seismic tests, which use air guns to create images of the geology beneath the seafloor, could still go forward. With drilling now off the table in the Atlantic Ocean, activists have focused their efforts on stopping the seismic tests, pointing to the population of endangered right whales along the coast. The senators’ letter references 95 localities that have passed resolutions opposing seismic tests.

Annual seminar brings environmental regulators, energy industry together. Midland Reporter-Telegram. With the oil and gas companies currently facing new or expanded regulations covering everything from air emissions to water emissions to endangered species, a better understanding of the regulations is becoming more important. Such understanding is the goal of the annual Permian Basin Environmental Regulatory Seminar. “The PBPA is giving an inside look at how we successfully challenged the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s listing of the lesser prairie chicken under the Endangered Species Act. If the listing of the lesser prairie chicken had been upheld, the results would have been devastating for our industry in at least five states, and especially here in the Permian Basin, with potential costs in the billions of dollars,” Robertson said.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 4/29/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-42916/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 4/8/16 /weekly-newsletter-4816/ /weekly-newsletter-4816/#respond Mon, 11 Apr 2016 18:31:47 +0000 /?p=6444 Issues Lesser Prairie Chicken Population Increases Again. The Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (WAFWA), the group tasked with overseeing the Lesser Prairie-Chicken Range-wide Conservation Plan, released its second annual report this week. The report indicated the prairie chicken’s […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 4/8/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

Lesser Prairie Chicken Population Increases Again. The Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (WAFWA), the group tasked with overseeing the Lesser Prairie-Chicken Range-wide Conservation Plan, released its second annual report this week. The report indicated the prairie chicken’s population increased by 25 percent over last year to over 29,000 birds and industry partners had paid almost $51 million in mitigation actions.

The good news comes one month after Senior U.S. District Judge Robert Junell upheld his September 2015 ruling that overturned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to list the chicken as a threatened species. The judge specifically cited the WAFWA’s range-wide plan for the prairie chicken in his decision to overturn the listing. The 25 percent increase reported this year follows the first annual report, which saw a 20 percent increase in the prairie chicken population between 2013 and 2014.

WNS reaches West Coast, scientists search for key to survival. Scientists confirmed last week the presence of white-nose syndrome in bats in Washington, the first time the lethal disease has appeared in the Western United States. Some biologists believe the disease has already killed roughly 7 million bats and has been found in 28 states and five Canadian provinces.

State and federal officials in nearby Montana are reportedly on “heightened alert” for signs of white-nose syndrome spreading to their state’s bat population. Because the fungus can be spread by the clothing and equipment of recreational cavers, caver groups are working to educate their members on proper decontamination techniques to prevent the spread of the disease.

Meanwhile, researchers are working to figure out why some populations of bats in affected areas appear to have stabilized. Some populations of little brown bats have stabilized in upstate New York and Vermont, near the area where white-nose syndrome was first discovered in America a decade ago. Some hypothesize the fungus is unable to spread as easily in the thinned cave populations following the massive die-off, while others point to evidence that bats can adapt to the disease.

Texas Comptroller selects new team to manage dunes sagebrush lizard habitat. After Texas Comptrollers ended their four-year partnership with the Texas Habitat Conservation Foundation last month, the Comptrollers have turned to a new team of biologists, scientists, and managers from Bio West to continue administering the conservation plan for the dune sagebrush lizard. The Texas Conservation Plan strikes a balance between protecting the lizard as well as oil and natural gas development, and was cited in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to not list the lizard as a threatened species.

Glenn Hegar, the Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, addressed concerns of his office’s decision in an op-ed this week. Hegar sought to reassure the public of the ability of the conservation plan to protect the lizard, noting that “less than 300 acres of the 200,000 acres of [dunes sagebrush lizard] habitat has been disturbed.” The Texas Conservation Plan is “something of which Texans can and should feel proud,” Hegar concluded.

In the News

State effort struggles to buy prairie chicken habitat. E&E News (sub req’d). A state-led effort to offset the impacts of development on the lesser prairie chicken continues to struggle with purchasing permanent conservation areas for the bird, according to an annual report released yesterday by the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies. In its second year implementing a rangewide plan that seeks to conserve the lesser prairie chicken with voluntary cooperation of landowners and industry, WAFWA secured its first permanent conservation site. The 2013 document set a goal of establishing “one or more strongholds” in each of the four eco-regions in which the bird is found and offsetting 25 percent of the acreage affected by development with permanent conservation. But WAFWA reported yesterday that it has permanently conserved a 1,604-acre track of Texas native rangeland, which represents 10 percent of the habitat used for oil and gas development, wind turbines or other developments.

The Birds: Concerns over grouse populations are delaying lease sales in the West. BOE Report. The Endangered Species Act protects the grouse bird species, found across the western half of the country. Concerns over protection of these birds have further delayed the sale of over 60,000 acres of oil and gas leases across Montana and surrounding states. This delay adds to the already 8 million acres of leases deferred for sale across Colorado, North Dakota, and other western states. Several oil and gas companies are keeping a watchful eye on these resources as the delays get longer and longer.

Greens demand info on sage grouse habitat. Courthouse News Service. Environmentalists sued the Bureau of Land Management for information about the effect cattle grazing in Idaho and Nevada have on the greater sage grouse. Western Watersheds Project claims the BLM and Department of the Interior are way past their deadlines to respond to freedom of information requests about two livestock grazing allotments. The FOIA requests concern the Garat grazing allotment in the Owyhee Canyonlands of southwest Idaho and the Argenta allotment in northern Nevada. Both allotments provide habitat for important populations of sage grouse.

Grouse suit seeks to block new fences on BLM land in Nevada. Associated Press. Conservationists are suing the Bureau of Land Management to block the construction of fences in northern Nevada they say are intended to appease livestock ranchers at the risk of harming sage grouse and the drought-stricken federal rangeland. The Western Watersheds Project filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Reno last week on the heels of a broader one it filed last month challenging the Obama administration’s overall protection plan for the greater sage grouse across 10 western states. Leaders of the Idaho-based group say the 3 miles of new fence planned near key grouse habitat flies in the face of BLM’s own research showing the low-flying, hen-sized birds often die when they strike fences.

Petition demands EPA revoke license for weed-killer ingredient. The Hill. More than 14,000 people have signed a petition that asks the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to revoke the license for glyphosate — the active ingredient in Monsanto’s herbicide Roundup. Last April, the United Nations World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) released a scientific assessment that found glyphosate is “probably carcinogenic to humans.” In an email Tuesday, an EPA spokesperson told The Hill the agency is “working through some important science issues,” by doing an in-depth human incidents and epidemiology evaluation of glyphosate residue in human breast milk and doing a preliminary analysis of glyphosate’s toxicity to milkweed, which is a critical resource for the monarch butterfly.

Laxalt: Interior’s ‘Grouseketeers’ violated law in sage grouse ruling. Elko Daily Free Press. Attorney General Adam Laxalt is asking a federal court to rule in favor of the state’s and Elko County’s lawsuit over sage grouse, claiming that Department of Interior officials who called themselves “Grouseketeers” illegally met with environmental groups after the agency’s public comment period ended. In a release Tuesday afternoon, Laxalt’s office announced that the plaintiffs, which include nine counties as well as mining and ranching interests, had requested a summary judgment in the case involving land-use restrictions.

Further review on species effects needed for three pesticides. Agri-Pulse. Federal wildlife agencies will have to prepare detailed analyses on how three widely used pesticides affect endangered species, the EPA has concluded. The agency released draft biological evaluations today on the effects of chlorpyrifos, diazinon and malathion on threatened and endangered species and designated critical habitat, updating evaluations it released in December. The “effects determinations” indicate that the Fish and Wildlife Service or National Marine Fisheries Service will have to prepare Endangered Species Act (ESA)-required Biological Opinions on 1,725 species for chlorpyrifos and malathion, and on 1,416 species for diazinon. Those species are “likely to (be) adversely affected” by use of the three chemicals, EPA found.

Restrictions and protection efforts still underway. Argus Observer. The Southeast Oregon RAC met Monday and Tuesday in Ontario. The group advises federal land-management agencies about management issues and policies. Greater sage grouse populations have been of concern for years — so much so that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service was considering listing the bird as an endangered species. Oregon’s Sage-Grouse Action Plan to protect grouse habitat was one of several measure cited by the Fish and Wildlife Service in its September decision not to list the bird as endangered. There are still restrictions related to greater sage grouse, however. One of the current restrictions on sage grouse habitat is a suspension, for at least two years, on all new mining permits in focal areas of sagebrush habitat.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 4/8/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-4816/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 3/4/16 /weekly-newsletter-3416/ /weekly-newsletter-3416/#respond Mon, 07 Mar 2016 14:38:08 +0000 /?p=6428 Issues ***IPAA holds call up on Capitol Hill. This week, IPAA and over 70 of its member companies held 115 meetings on Capitol Hill, highlighting the key role of independent producers to the U.S. economy and the current regulatory concerns […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 3/4/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

***IPAA holds call up on Capitol Hill. This week, IPAA and over 70 of its member companies held 115 meetings on Capitol Hill, highlighting the key role of independent producers to the U.S. economy and the current regulatory concerns facing operators. IPAA’s President and CEO Barry Russell was also featured in the Washington Times regarding the current environment, stating “strengthening, not degrading, American oil and natural gas production is a much better option for our country.” For more information on the call up contact SMcdonald@IPAA.org.

Environmental groups sue for more sage grouse protections. Conservations groups, including the Center for Biological Diversity and WildEarth Guardians, have filed a lawsuit challenging the Obama administration’s greater sage-grouse plans, claiming they are scientifically flawed, contain loopholes, and will ultimately fail to protect the bird or its habitat. The groups are seeking to force the administration to impose more restrictions on oil and gas production, mining, and other activities within the sage-grouse’s habitat, advocating for more uniformity across states.

Kathleen Sgamma, vice president of the Western Energy Alliance, countered these allegations, writing, “the environmental groups are not interested in sage grouse conservation, but rather with greater centralized control of the West by the federal government. Their goal is to push any productive activities that form the basis of rural communities such as ranching and energy development off public lands.”

Western states and the mining and ranching industries have also filed lawsuits against the federal government’s conservation plans, stating that they are too restrictive and ignore the state conservation plans that prevented the sage-grouse’s ESA listing in the first place.

Oil and gas producers win sagebrush lizard lawsuit. A panel of three judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals ruled against conservation groups who had challenged the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to withdraw its decision to list the dunes sagebrush lizard as endangered. Oil and gas producers had feared that listing the lizard as endangered would make drilling in the Permian Basin more difficult. The court found the conservation groups’ arguments against state plans to protect the lizard “unpersuasive,” siding with the Obama administration and the American Petroleum Institute.

Lesser prairie chicken ruling upheld. A U.S. District Court judge this week upheld his September 2015 ruling that overturned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to list the lesser prairie chicken as threatened under the Endangered Species Act, denying the Department of Interior and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s motion to amend his judgement. Federal attorneys had asked the judge to amend his ruling instead of vacating the listing decision so the Fish and Wildlife Service could make a new determination that appropriately considered a range-wide conservation plan the judge had cited in his decision to overturn the listing. The federal lawyers also asked the judge to limit his ruling to Texas and New Mexico, a request the judge denied.

Permian Basin Petroleum Association President Ben Shepperd stated the ruling “serves as vindication of the unprecedented stakeholder participation across the lesser prairie chicken range.” Immediately following the judge’s decision, the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (WAFWA) also fired its lesser prairie chicken program manager. Representing regulators from 23 states and Canadian provinces, the WAFWA had created the range-wide plan cited by the judge in his decision to overturn the listing.

Monarch butterfly population rebounds more than 200 percent. Researchers have observed a 225 percent increase in monarch butterflies following their annual winter migration to Mexico. Monarch butterflies fly thousands of miles from across North America to arrive in northern Mexico where they spend the winter hibernating in pine and fir forests. Scientists report that monarchs have rebounded from a low of 42 million last winter to 150 million this winter, though this year’s tally is still below historical totals.

Monarchs are currently imperiled by a loss of milkweed across their migratory path. The butterflies depend on milkweed for food and the plant serves as a host for the eggs they leave behind over the course of their migration. Scientists attributed this year’s population boom to efforts to increased milkweed plantings in North America, mild weather, and improved efforts to protect Mexican forests.

In the News

Wyoming counties, conservation districts sue over sage grouse. Associated Press. A group of counties and conservation districts in western Wyoming is suing over the federal government’s sweeping plans to protect habitat for the greater sage grouse. The Wyoming Coalition of Local Governments filed a petition for review Monday in federal court in Wyoming. The greater sage grouse is a ground-dwelling bird that has lost much of its habitat to development and declined significantly in number. The birds live in 11 states from Oregon to the Dakotas. The Interior Department announced in September that it would not pursue federal protection for the greater sage grouse but would implement a series of land-use plans to help protect the bird. Those suing include Uinta, Lincoln and Sublette counties. They say the federal government oversteps its authority with the new sage grouse plans.

Report: More pollinators species in jeopardy, threatening world food supply. NPR. A major global assessment of pollinators is raising concerns about the future of the planet’s food supply. A U.N.-sponsored report drawing on about 3,000 scientific papers concludes that about 40 percent of invertebrate pollinator species (such as bees and butterflies) are facing extinction. Vertebrate pollinators (such as bats and birds) are somewhat better off by comparison — 16 percent are threatened with extinction, “with a trend towards more extinctions,” the researchers say. About 75 percent of the world’s food crops, the report notes, depend at least partly on pollination. Note: E&E News (sub req’d) and Newsweek also report.

Appeals court upholds designation of polar bear habitat. Associated Press. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service followed the law when it designated more than 187,000 square miles — an area larger than California — as critical habitat for threatened polar bears in Alaska marine waters and its northern coast, an appeals court ruled Monday. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeal reversed a 2013 lower court decision that the designation was too extensive and not specific. A spokesman for the Center for Biological Diversity, which petitioned to designate polar bears as a threatened species, called it a victory for the marine mammal. The federal government in 2008 declared polar bears threatened under the Endangered Species Act, citing melting sea ice. Polar bears need ice for hunting, breeding and migrating.

Pipeline project spurs new tussle over trees. Daily Star. Constitution last week asked the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to reconsider its request for permission to fell trees in New York, something the company has already been doing in Pennsylvania, where the required state permits have been issued to the developers of the natural gas transmission line. On Monday, Stop the Pipeline responded Monday with its own legal papers, urging FERC to spurn the company’s application. Constitiution spokesman Tom Droege said the tree clearing must be done by March 31 to accomplish the company’s goal of constructing the 125-mile pipeline this year. “The March 31 deadline to avoid impacting migratory birds and the Northern long-eared bat is approaching and it’s imperative that we start the tree felling work now in order to keep the project on schedule and begin providing low-cost natural gas to millions of consumers in the Northeast,” Droege said.

Washington goes farther than feds on sage grouse. Capital Press. The Washington Fish and Wildlife Commission has affirmed state-protected status for the greater sage grouse, exasperating agriculture groups that argue the state’s inventory of endangered and threatened species shouldn’t include wide-ranging species not on the federal list. “We think it’s redundant and unnecessary — an additional layer of state regulation that affects farmers and ranchers,” Washington Farm Bureau director of governmental relations Tom Davis said. The commission unanimously approved Feb. 26 a staff recommendation to keep the greater sage grouse, Western gray squirrel, northern spotted owl and snowy plover on the state protected species list. Note: Spokesman-Review and Yakima Herald also report.

Industry, greens call for annual $1.3B for species conservation. E&E News (sub req’d). A panel of energy, business and conservation leaders today called on lawmakers to direct $1.3 billion each year from federal energy and mineral development revenues into state-led conservation. The new funding is necessary to avert a growing endangered species crisis, according to the coalition led by John Morris, the founder of Bass Pro Shops, and David Freudenthal, former Democratic governor of Wyoming. Other members of the group include executives from Shell America, EDF Renewable Energy, Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America Inc. and the National Audubon Society.

Livestock grazing draws ravens that eat eggs, chicks – study. E&E News (sub req’d). A federal study has found a negative association between livestock grazing in the sagebrush that’s home to greater sage grouse and the abundance of ravens that are a major threat to the survival of the grouse, a conclusion that is soundly rejected by the cattle industry. The chief concern is not so much the cattle themselves, but rather other aspects of grazing, particularly water troughs for livestock that attract the ravens that eat sage grouse eggs and chicks. Researchers found the odds of ravens present on the landscape in southeast Idaho, an area where livestock grazing is common, increased 45.8 percent where cattle were present, according to the study, published in the journal Ecosphere.

Move considered to remove grizzlies from endangered species list. Reuters. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service on Thursday proposed stripping Endangered Species Act protections from the grizzly bear in and around Yellowstone National Park, saying the animal’s numbers have rebounded sufficiently in recent decades. The number of grizzlies in the greater Yellowstone region, encompassing parts of Wyoming, Montana and Idaho, has grown to an estimated 700 or more bears today, up from as few as 176 in 1975, when they were formally listed as a threatened species throughout the lower 48 states. At that time, the grizzly had been hunted, trapped and poisoned to near-extinction. Its estimated population well exceeds the government’s recovery goal of 500 animals in the region.

New maps may help reduce threats for whales, dolphins in U.S. waters. Duke University (Press Release). Scientists have created highly detailed maps charting the seasonal movements and population densities of 35 species of whales, dolphins and porpoises — many of them threatened or endangered — in the crowded waters of the U.S. East Coast and Gulf of Mexico. The U.S. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has proposed opening a large portion of the Atlantic continental shelf to oil and natural gas development, as well as expanding oil and gas leasing in the Gulf of Mexico, Halpin noted. “Insights provided by these new maps can be very influential in shaping the outcomes of these decisions because population density estimates are used by U.S. government agencies to enforce the Marine Mammal Protection Act and Endangered Species Act,” Halpin said.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 3/4/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-3416/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 2/5/16 /weekly-newsletter-2516/ /weekly-newsletter-2516/#respond Mon, 08 Feb 2016 01:08:14 +0000 /?p=6400 Issues ICYMI: New species page on the monarch butterfly. IPAA has created a new species page for the monarch butterfly. In March 2015, IPAA submitted joint comments with the American Petroleum Institute (API) to the Fish and Wildlife Service in response to […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 2/5/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

ICYMI: New species page on the monarch butterfly. IPAA has created a new species page for the monarch butterfly. In March 2015, IPAA submitted joint comments with the American Petroleum Institute (API) to the Fish and Wildlife Service in response to a request for comment on the status of the monarch butterfly, highlighting the negligible impact of oil and gas operations on the butterfly’s population and its expansive habitat range. As the comments highlight, “no evidence exists in the literature of adverse effects from oil and gas industry operations on the species itself or on the destruction, modification, or curtailment of the species’ habitat or range.” Check out the new page HERE.

Obama administration halts ESA protections for lesser prairie chicken. The debate over the lesser prairie chicken listing continues, with Congressman Tim Huelskamp (R-KS) stating last week that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service will not enforce its “threatened” listing of the lesser prairie chicken anywhere in the country. Meanwhile, federal attorneys asked a federal judge to amend their previous ruling overturning the listing, warning that the species risks a “death spiral” towards extinction.

At issue is a federal judge’s decision last year to overturn the Fish and Wildlife Service’s 2014 decision to list the chicken as a threatened species, impacting it’s habitat range in Texas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Kansas and Colorado. Until Congressman Huelskamp’s announcement, it had been unclear whether the Service would still enforce its listing outside of Texas.

The Obama administration, however, is worried about proposed development projects capable of fragmenting the chicken’s habitat that do not presently require consultation with the Fish and Wildlife Service as a result of the judge’s ruling. Federal attorneys want the judge to amend their previous ruling to allow the Service to make a new listing determination that fully takes into account a range-wide conservation plan by the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies, something the judge believed the Service did not adequately consider in 2014.

Nevada governor proposes change to sage grouse plan. Nevada Governor Brian Sandoval (R) offered a proposal to the Bureau of Land Management last week that would free up mining claims in the state, claims that have been frozen by the agency’s sage grouse protection plan. The Department of the Interior decided last September not to list the greater sage-grouse, but instead adopted new regulations restricting development within sage-grouse habitat across 11 states. IPAA commented at the time that while avoiding a federal listing was necessary, these land use restrictions would harm energy producers and American taxpayers, calling the management plans “unworkable.”

Sandoval’s plan would reduce the total withdrawn area by roughly one-fifth and swap that land with other areas that contain higher quality habitat for the grouse, protecting 49 additional leks while only dropping protection for five leks included in the government plan. Such a shift would release all but one percent of the nearly 4,000 mining claims currently on hold in Nevada as a result of the federal plan. A BLM spokesperson in Nevada said that the agency would give “serious consideration” to the governor’s proposal.

Federal wildfire plan is praised by experts and ranchers. Public land experts are calling Interior Secretary Sally Jewell’s wildfire plan one of the most significant federal land policy changes in 80 years. The plan directs federal resources to fight the enormous fires that burn in sagebrush habitat that supports cattle ranching and is home to the greater sage-grouse. Experts say the plan better enables authorities to respond to fires in one of the worst wildfire seasons.

Ranchers, despite their usual distrust of federal oversight, have also signaled support for the plan, with some joining together to form Rangeland Fire Protections Associations to stop small fires from exploding and charring their rangeland. Jewell’s plan improves on previous rehabilitation attempts by using local seeds to restore sagebrush habitat and includes plans to fight invasive cheatgrass that fueled a massive fire in Idaho and Oregon last summer.

In the News

Utah sues to halt plan for sage grouse proposal. Salt Lake Tribune. Utah officials on Thursday filed a lawsuit seeking to invalidate federal land-use plan revisions aimed at conserving imperiled greater sage grouse, but critics say the state should be careful of getting what it’s asking from the courts. Utah Attorney General Sean Reyes says the feds ignored what scientific evidence indicates would be best for Utah sage grouse and illegally trampled on the state’s own conservation plan that Gov. Gary Herbert approved in 2013. But conservationists wonder if Utah is courting trouble with this suit. “The decision to not list was very much based on those plan revisions, 99 of them, to protect sage grouse, because the bar was set high enough and promises were made. If you undo all that, of course they are going to revisit the listing decision. That’s opening a can of worms,” said biologist Allison Jones, executive director for the Wild Utah Project.

Natural habitats and natural resource extraction: Battle continues. National Law Review (Opinion). Most, if not all of you, are very familiar with the tensions between natural resource extraction – be it coal or oil and gas – and environmentalists. In Texas, these tensions manifested in the proposed listing of the Dunes Sagebrush Lizard (also known as the Sand Dune Lizard) that lives in the Permian Basis. The lizard’s chief threat is habitat loss due to oil and gas development operations, the conversion of native ecosystems to cropland and rangeland, and increased use of off-road vehicles. Industry and state and local government responded by preparing a voluntary, long-term conservation plan through which landowners and industry agreed to undertake specified conservation practices believed to ensure the lizard’s survival. This worked because the lizard’s chief threat was man-made activity. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for three species living in the Appalachian Basin being considered for listing. Specifically, the Northern Long-eared Bat, the Monarch Butterfly, and the Rusty-Patched Bumble Bee.

Manatees and power plants: an unlikely love story. E&E News (sub req’d). More than 70 years ago, Florida manatees made a life-changing discovery: The warm water pouring out of power plants makes excellent winter refuges. Such industrial discharges have been crucial to the ongoing recovery of the West Indian manatee. When it was first listed as endangered in 1967, fewer than 1,000 manatees remained in Florida. Today that number has jumped to more than 6,300, with more than half using man-made warm water refuges. This month, the Fish and Wildlife Service announced that the population no longer qualifies as endangered under the Endangered Species Act. The agency is proposing to reclassify the species as threatened. But FWS has yet to tackle the biggest threat facing manatees: the loss of those power plant hot tubs.

Senators say coal rules are illegal ‘power grab.’ Register-Herald. Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla., calls tougher rules on the coal industry a “power grab” by federal mining regulators who want more leverage over states. He and other senators grilled the director of the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement for more than an hour Wednesday over a package of rules that include closer monitoring of streams near coal mines. The Department of Fish and Wildlife, for example, could hold up mining permits to protect species being considered as potentially endangered. That expands the scope of the Endangered Species Act, Inhofe and others argue, beyond protecting those already designated as endangered.

Obama’s use of ESA ‘loophole’ undermines protections – report. E&E News (sub req’d). The Obama administration is using an Endangered Species Act provision to allow oil and gas drilling, logging, ranching and commercial wind development in sensitive wildlife habitat, according to a report released today by an environmental group. The report from the Center for Biological Diversity takes aim at special rules that let people incidentally kill, harm or harass listed species if they commit to certain conservation practices. The Fish and Wildlife Service under President Obama has issued more so-called Section 4(d) rules than under any president other than Gerald Ford, according to a paper authored by Ya-Wei Li, senior director of endangered species conservation at Defenders of Wildlife.

NOAA approves 10-fold increase in right whale habitat. E&E News (sub req’d). The National Marine Fisheries Service announced today that it is dramatically increasing the critical habitat for endangered North Atlantic right whales, with protections for feeding grounds and calving areas along the East Coast. The final rule expands the whales’ habitat tenfold, to almost 30,000 square nautical miles. That includes Northeast feeding areas in the Gulf of Maine and calving grounds between north Florida and North Carolina. The agency — a division of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration — hopes the new designation will help protect an endangered species that was once hunted to near-extinction. Today, about 500 of the whales remain in the North Atlantic, where their biggest threats are ship strikes and fishing entanglements.

Aerial surveys could delay pipeline permits – FERC official. E&E News (sub req’d). Legislation to incorporate aerial survey data into the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s approval process for natural gas infrastructure could lead to unintended consequences by delaying or adding costs to some projects, a senior FERC staffer told a House panel today. Ann Miles, director of FERC’s Office of Energy Projects, said commission staff currently accepts aerial survey data, though most project applications include ground surveys for a significant portion of the right of way. She expressed concern that waiting to verify large amounts of aerial data until late in the project development process, or after a certificate is issued, could pose difficulties. Miles suggested a project’s impact on historical properties or endangered species might be hard to determine without ground surveys.

Washoe County proceeds with litigation over federal sage grouse rules. This is Reno. Washoe County announced yesterday that it intends to continue in litigation against the federal government over sage-grouse conservation rules released last fall. The county is protesting the Department of Interior’s (DOI) sage-grouse land-use plans that are designed to protect the bird from being listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act. Washoe County is a party to the suit with other Nevada counties and two mineral exploration companies. Nevada Attorney General Adam Laxalt also signed on to the lawsuit, a move that irked Nevada Governor Brian Sandoval. Sandoval has been in direct negotiations with federal officials over the issues raised in the suit. He announced in December that U.S. Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell would use Nevada’s sage-grouse habitat maps, rather than the federal maps.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 2/5/16 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-2516/feed/ 0
ESA Watch Special Report /esa-watch-special-report/ /esa-watch-special-report/#respond Tue, 05 Jan 2016 18:42:31 +0000 /?p=6367 Over the past year, the IPAA team has continued its efforts to advocate for the appropriate and effective use of the Endangered Species Act (ESA), balancing the protection of critical species and habitats with economic development and sound science. With […]

The post ESA Watch Special Report appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Over the past year, the IPAA team has continued its efforts to advocate for the appropriate and effective use of the Endangered Species Act (ESA), balancing the protection of critical species and habitats with economic development and sound science. With the New Year now underway, let’s take a look back at some of the top issues from 2015 and key issues on the horizon that IPAA will be following in 2016.

A Look Back at 2015

From the greater sage-grouse to new procedural rule-makings, IPAA has been at the forefront of advocacy and education efforts around the ESA. The following provides a report of some of the major issues from the last year.

  • Greater Sage-Grouse. This past September, the Secretary of the Interior decided not to list the greater sage-grouse under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). In doing so, the Secretary announced new plans to limit land use activities on 10 million acres of sagebrush habitat in the West. IPAA President and CEO Barry Russell responded with an Op-Ed in The Hill, warning of the economic impacts these federal restrictions would place on the western economy while highlighting the benefits of a carefully balanced approach to conservation currently employed by local stakeholders and state officials throughout the West. IPAA’s Russell has also been featured in the Salt Lake Tribune and Casper Star-Tribune, highlighting the key role of states in the conservation of the sage-grouse.

In addition, IPAA supported efforts to ensure the inclusion of language on the sage-grouse and other species in the Fiscal Year 2016 Interior Appropriations bill by defeating an amendment from Congresswoman Niki Tsongas (D-MA) that would have stripped the provisions from the bill. The Tsongas amendment failed 186-243 with only nine Republicans and 177 Democrats supporting the amendment. IPAA also supported Congressman Frank Lucas’ (R-OK) amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act that would reverse and delay for five years the listing of the lesser prairie chicken, delay the listing of the greater sage-grouse for ten years, and delist the American burying beetle. The Lucas amendment passed 229-190 with strong bipartisan support.

  • Northern Long-Eared Bat. IPAA joined with numerous other industry groups inJanuary 2014, August 2014, December 2014, and March 2015 urging the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS or the Service) not to list the northern long-eared bat as endangered. In their March 2015 comments, IPAA and the American Petroleum Institute (API) specifically requested that all oil and gas development activities be exempted from the prohibition against incidental take of the bat through the proposed special rule. In July 2015, the associations again urged the Service to amend the Interim 4(d) Rule for the northern long-eared bat to reflect the fact that oil and gas development activities do not pose a significant threat to the existence of the bat. In June 2015, IPAA also took the lead in coordinating a congressional staff briefing on the bat with the House Natural Resources Committee. The meeting focused on the current stipulations included in the Interim 4(d) Rule, the treatment of oil and natural gas activities, and the potential impacts the rule will have on energy and economic development if the final language is not altered.
  • Lesser Prairie Chicken. In September, a Senior U.S. District Judge in Texas overturned the Service’s decision to list the lesser prairie chicken as threatened under the ESA. Permian Basin Petroleum Association President Ben Sheppard hailed the decision, telling the Associated Press the ruling “serves as vindication of the unprecedented stakeholder participation across the lesser prairie chicken range.” Despite the Court’s decision, FWS has asked the judge to reconsider the ruling, warning that there was a “serious possibility” that the Agency would arrive at the same threatened conclusion it had reached in 2014, even after re-evaluating the conservation plan in the manner prescribed by the Court. Federal attorneys are now fighting the decision in court, arguing that state-led plans have been unsuccessful. IPAA continues to monitor the situation and what it means for operators within the bird’s habitat range.
  • Meetings with Administration and Congressional Leaders on ESA. IPAA led a number of high-profile meetings with senior Interior Department officials in 2015, including U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe and Bureau of Land Management Director Neil Kornze. Additionally, IPAA led meetings with FWS officials in multiple regions, including organizing a rig tour for officials in Pennsylvania as part of advocacy efforts in relation to the northern long-eared bat. IPAA has also worked with Members of Congress and congressional staff on drafting and providing feedback on policy and legal defensibility for dozens of bills and amendments.
  • ESA Reform: Critical Habitat Designations and Modifications. Throughout the year, IPAA has actively engaged with the federal government on several proposed changes to critical habitat designations that could potentially affect America’s independent producers. The first proposal would give the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service vast new authority to designate new areas as “critical habitat” that are not currently (and never have been) occupied by a listed species. The second proposal would change the definition of “destruction or adverse modification.” The third proposal is a draft policy that would clarify how the Service exercises its authority to exclude certain areas from designation, even though the areas may qualify for such designation. These proposed changes would result in a significant expansion of the Service’s authority to designate and control habitat under the ESA.

IPAA’s senior vice president of government relations and political affairs Dan Naatz discussed these proposed rule changes in the Casper Star Tribune last November in an effort to increase awareness around the proposal and its impact. IPAA also has a new fact sheet on the issue, available HERE.

  • ESA Reform: Petitions & Settlements. IPAA and API submitted joint comments in September on proposed revisions to the regulations for petitions under the ESA. IPAA suggested that petitions should be limited to a single species, require consultation with states prior to submission, and require petitioners to attach all relevant information to their petition, including information that may support a finding that the petitioned action is not warranted. In May, IPAA and five other associations also wrote a letter to Senator John Cornyn (R-TX) expressing their support for S. 293, a bill to amend the Endangered Species Act to establish a procedure for the approval of certain settlements. The letter highlights how the legislation would improve the legal framework of the ESA by increasing transparency and accountability during settlement negotiations in lawsuits that challenge the Services’ failure to meet deadlines.
  • Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA). IPAA is engaged in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s process as it looks at permitting incidental take under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, submitting joint comments to the Service in July 2015. The comments question whether the approaches described in the Service’s Notice of Intent are authorized by or consistent with the intent of the statute upon which the Service relies. The associations are also concerned with the efficacy of the program proposed, and whether it singles out activities of the oil and gas industry over a more comprehensive assessment of the threats that avian species face.
  • Monarch Butterfly. In March 2015, IPAA submitted joint comments with API to the Fish and Wildlife Service in response to a request for comment on the status of the monarch butterfly, highlighting the negligible impact of oil and gas operations on the butterfly’s population and its expansive habitat range. According to the comments, “no evidence exists in the literature of adverse effects from oil and gas industry operations on the species itself or on the destruction, modification, or curtailment of the species’ habitat or range.” In June, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced a proposed plan to protect the butterfly just months after the Natural Resources Defense Council filed a suit alleging EPA did not sufficiently take warnings about the impact of a widely used herbicide on the species. The Service has also announced $3.2 million in funding to help protect the monarch population.

In addition to these key issues from 2015, IPAA has analyzed and submitted comments on a variety of species and issues as they are proposed to be listed or finalized, including co-signing a petition requesting that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service delist the American burying beetle from the ESA and responding to a petition to list the Bryde’s whale in the Gulf of Mexico.

Issues to Watch in 2016

Building off of IPAA’s efforts in 2015, below are some of the key issues to watch for as we head into the New Year.

  • Pollinator Petitions on the Rise. Going into 2016, IPAA expects to see additional proposals to list pollinator species on the Endangered Species Act. To date, the Service has issued a 90-day finding for the rusty-patched bumble bee following a 2013 petition from the Xerces Society and partners. IPAA submitted comments with API to the Service, noting the petition to list the bee relies on incomplete data and does not present sufficient information to warrant listing the bee at this time. The bee occupies an extensive range across 25 states from the East Coast to North Dakota.

Last fall, Defenders of Wildlife also sent a petition to FWS to list the western bumble bee under the ESA, citing concerns over the impacts of disease on the bee and reduced population levels at historic sites. According to the petition, the bee’s historic range includes northern California, Oregon, Washington, Alaska, Idaho, Montana, western Nebraska, western North Dakota, western South Dakota, Wyoming, Utah, Colorado, northern Arizona, and New Mexico. The Service will now decide whether to proceed with a 90-day determination period to consider if the listing might be warranted.

  • Split over Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA). In addition to IPAA’s existing comments around the MBTA, a current court split around the theory of unintentional take under the act stands to pose new changes to how industry is treated under the law. In September 2015, the Fifth Circuit rejected the United States’ theory of unintentional take under the 1918 Migratory Bird Treaty Act, reversing a Citgo Petroleum Corporation’s conviction related to proposed violations of the Clean Air Act and the Migratory Bird Treaty Act at a facility in Corpus Christi. According to the Fifth Circuit panel, the scope of takings under MBTA only prohibits intentional acts that directly kill migratory birds. The decision splits the circuit courts on the issue of enforcement of MBTA in the oil and natural gas sector, placing the Fifth Circuit in agreement with the Eighth and Ninth Circuits, both of which have limited “takes” to hunting and poaching activities and have stated that “taking” is limited to deliberate, intentional acts to migratory birds. Meanwhile, the Second and Tenth Circuits “have read the MBTA broadly” and “hold that because the MBTA imposes strict liability, it must forbid acts that accidentally or indirectly kill birds.” This court split over the implementation of the MBTA will continue to be an important issue for the oil and gas industry to monitor heading into 2016.
  • ESA Reform Efforts Continue. Building off the previous work in 2015, IPAA will continue to monitor and advocate for effective, common sense reform of the Endangered Species Act, notably the importance of using sound science and appropriate regulatory powers to make decisions. IPAA will continue to support Senator Cornyn’s bill (S. 293) establish a procedure for the approval of certain settlements and will track any additional legislative proposals that are introduced in Congress.
  • FWS Releases Candidate Species List. On December 24, 2015, FWS released its Candidate Notice of Review, a yearly status appraisal of plants and animals that are candidates for protection under the ESA. The list highlights 60 species recognized by the Service as candidates for ESA protection and, most importantly, are species being monitored by the Service. Read the full document in the Federal Register HERE.
  • Turtles and Mussels to Watch. In May 2015, the Service announced a final rule designating 1,920 river miles of critical habitat across 12 states for two mussel species—the rabbitsfoot and the Neosho mucket. Both species occur in waters where many oil and natural gas companies conduct operations, notably in Arkansas, and the critical habitat listing will affect any Section 7 consultations that occur for projects with a federal nexus in the listed region. The Service also recently listed two mussels found in Florida, including the Florida bristle fern and the Suwannee moccasinshell mussel, as endangered and threatened respectively under the ESA.

Last month, the Center for Biological Diversity also issued notices of intent to sue the Service for failing to act in a timely manner on its petitions to list the wood turtle, found in the Northeast and Midwest, and the alligator snapping turtle, found in the Southeast, under the ESA. The Service issued affirmative 90-day findings on both species this summer, and proposed listing decisions for both species may arise in the next 6-12 months.

Efforts & Education Continues

IPAA is continuing its educational outreach to the public through its ESA Watch campaign and website www.ESAwatch.org. IPAA has been an ESA thought leader, working with the Administration and Congress and hosting numerous briefings, meetings, tours and workshops. Over the past year, IPAA has served as a leading voice on ESA issues, calling for thoughtful, common sense decision-making in prominent publications around the country, including the Casper Star-Tribune in Wyoming, The Billings Gazette in Montana, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in Pennsylvania, the Wall Street Journal in New York, the Salt Lake Tribune in Utah, and The Hill in Washington, D.C. IPAA looks forward to continuing engagement on the ESA in 2016 and will continue to serve as a leading resource for those monitoring these critical issues.

The post ESA Watch Special Report appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/esa-watch-special-report/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 11/13/15 /weekly-newsletter-111315/ /weekly-newsletter-111315/#respond Fri, 13 Nov 2015 21:58:53 +0000 /?p=6330 Issues WAFWA urges companies enroll in lesser prairie chicken conservation programs. This week, the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (WAFWA) released a statement, urging oil and natural gas companies to enroll leases and projects into voluntary programs, known […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 11/13/15 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

WAFWA urges companies enroll in lesser prairie chicken conservation programs. This week, the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (WAFWA) released a statement, urging oil and natural gas companies to enroll leases and projects into voluntary programs, known as a Candidate Conservation Agreement with Assurances, to conserve the lesser prairie chicken.

Earlier in September, a senior U.S. District Judge in Texas overturned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to list the lesser prairie chicken as threatened under the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA). The bird was originally listed in April 2014 with a 4(d) rule that specified take of the bird was authorized when undertaken by participants in the Lesser Prairie Chicken Range-Wide Conservation Plan. Based on the decision, WAFWA’s conservation agreement program is again open for energy companies to join in the chicken’s five range habitat in Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Texas.

According to WAFWA’s announcement, it is unclear how long this opportunity will be available given Fish and Wildlife’s challenge to the federal judge’s decision. As such, WAFWA is encouraging “all interested companies to enroll as soon as possible.” Sean Kyle, WAFWA’s industry services director, highlighted in E&E News that since 2014 “more than 180 oil, gas, wind, electric and pipeline companies have enrolled about 11 million acres in the WAFWA plan, committing $47.5 million for habitat conservation.”

Hearings scheduled on Interior proposal to withdrawal rights on sage-grouse habitat. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) announced it will hold nine public hearings over the month of December regarding its proposal to withdraw 10 million acres of federal land identified as “sagebrush focal areas” in Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming from location and entry of new mining claims. According to the notice in the Federal Register, the announcement “extends the comment period for both the proposed withdrawal and initial scoping for the environmental impact statement (EIS) being prepared to consider the merits of the proposed withdrawal and announces the times, dates, and locations of public meetings.” A full list of meetings is also available in the notice.

As IPAA noted before on ESA Watch, both new and existing mining projects would be impacted under the proposed plan. According to E&E News (sub req’d), “while BLM and the Forest Service will honor all ongoing mining activity, as well as all valid claims made before the sage grouse plans were approved, all 10 million acres have been ‘temporarily segregated’ from new mining claims for up to two years while the EIS is completed.” The BLM is now accepting public comments on the plan until Jan. 15, 2016.

Western leaders call for ESA reform. This week, Wyoming Gov. Matt Mead and the Western Governors’ Association hosted the first of a series of workshops under its Species Conservation and Endangered Species Act Initiative.  The event included panels and roundtable discussions focused on Energy and Mining, Sportsmen, Recreation and Environmental Interests, Agriculture and Forestry, Government and Quasi-Governmental Entities, Recovery and Delisting, and Innovative Conservation Practices and Tools.  Watch the videos from the workshop HERE.

As reported by the Associated Press, Gov. Mead emphasized the low recovery rate of species under the ESA, stating “We need better than a 1 percent success rate. It’s critical in the West to get this right.” Gov. Mead also highlighted the importance of collaboration and  transparency, noting “we need to get to a place where the Endangered Secies Act can provide predictability for species, our citizens and for industry.” Upcoming workshop locations this winter include Idaho, Hawaii, and Colorado.

 

In the News

Conservationists come to BLM’s defense in grouse lawsuits. E&E News (sub req’d). Conservation groups have decided to defend the Bureau of Land Management’s sage grouse conservation plans in federal courts in Nevada and Washington, D.C., against legal challenges by states, counties, miners and ranchers. Several counties, miners and the state’s attorney general are challenging BLM and Forest Service land-use plans designed to prevent sage grouse from becoming listed under the Endangered Species Act. The entrance of conservationists represents a significant new juncture in a legal battle that could affect the long-term status of sage grouse and administrative protections spanning 10 states.

USDA offers $4M to boost monarch protection. E&E News (sub req’d). Farmers in monarch butterfly fly-through country are getting an extra incentive to invest in the survival of the imperiled black-and-orange winged insect. The Natural Resources Conservation Service, a division of the Department of Agriculture, today announced a $4 million investment spanning 10 Midwestern states. At a Farm Foundation event Tuesday, division Chief Jason Weller said the goal is to keep monarchs off the endangered species list. Butterfly populations have dwindled to 34 million today from more than 1 billion in 1995. The destruction of milkweed, the sole source of food for monarch caterpillars, and other native species in recent decades is blamed for the population crash.

Simpson and Otter weigh in on Idaho sage grouse debate. Boise State Public Radio. Governor C.L. “Butch” Otter filed a lawsuit challenging the BLM and Forest Service for the changes in land-use regulations that came with the ESA decision. Otter said at the time he was supportive of the decision to not list the native bird, but accused federal officials of creating “legally flawed” last-minute changes to the plans. But according to a story from the Associated Press, Otter may have changed his mind since then. The Governor told land management officials Tuesday he would have rather seen the sage grouse receive ESA protections than work under the new federal land regulations. Rep. Mike Simpson doesn’t agree. Simpson says listing the sage grouse would mean ranchers would have to “consult on every decision that [they] make on [their] allotments.”

White-nose fungus found in Neb. bats. E&E News (sub req’d). Researchers have found the fungus that causes white-nose syndrome in Nebraska bats, marking the westernmost detection of the cold-loving P. destructans. Nebraska is now one of 30 states where researchers have found either the fungus or white-nose syndrome, which has killed more than 6 million North American bats since 2007. Researchers from the commission and several University of Nebraska colleges found the fungus in samples from northern long-eared bats, tri-colored bats and big brown bats. None had signs of the disease, which causes white fungal growth on the nose, among other symptoms. Earlier this year, FWS listed the northern long-eared bat as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. Republicans have objected, opposing restrictions on industries — such as timber and energy — that are unrelated to the white-nose syndrome that poses the biggest threat to the species.

BLM open to sage-grouse mapping changes. Citizen Telegram. Garfield County officials remain optimistic over possible changes to habitat mapping for the greater sage-grouse in Colorado, changes that those officials said could ease restrictions on development, specifically in the oil and gas industry, while protecting the bird’s habitat in an area northwest of Parachute. The optimism stems from two recent developments: an assurance from the Bureau of Land Management that habitat mapping can change as new data becomes available; and an effort by Colorado’s northwest communities to conduct new habitat mapping across the region.

Governor: Now is not the time for litigation. Elko Daily Free Press. County commissioners voted Wednesday to send a letter to Gov. Brian Sandoval requesting his support of a lawsuit challenging land use restrictions in sage grouse habitat. Sandoval, who was visiting parts of Elko County that day, told the Free Press that his response is still the same: “I am very supportive of litigation, but not at this time.” Defending his position to not support litigation at this time, the governor noted that there is still an opportunity to be heard. “… there’s still a public comment period, which I intend to participate in with the Secretary of the Interior,” he said. “There’s an ongoing process to work with the secretary in terms of getting to the place where I want the state to go and where I’m sure Elko County wants to go that we’re comfortable with. “If we don’t achieve that, then I will lead the way when it comes to litigation,” Sandoval said.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 11/13/15 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-111315/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 10/13/15 /weekly-newsletter-101315/ /weekly-newsletter-101315/#respond Tue, 13 Oct 2015 17:51:43 +0000 /?p=6274 Issues Fish and Wildlife asks judge to reverse lesser prairie chicken delisting ruling. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has asked a federal judge in Texas to rethink his ruling that overturned the agency’s March 2014 decision to list the […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/13/15 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

Fish and Wildlife asks judge to reverse lesser prairie chicken delisting ruling. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has asked a federal judge in Texas to rethink his ruling that overturned the agency’s March 2014 decision to list the lesser prairie chicken as threatened under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The agency warned that the court’s ruling would result in a fragmented habitat, endangering conservation efforts aimed at protecting the bird.

In September, Judge Robert Junell of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas ruled that the agency’s decision to list the prairie chicken failed to consider the extent to which a range-wide conservation plan created by the states would mitigate threats to the bird. The Fish and Wildlife Service told the judge that there was a “serious possibility” that the agency would arrive at the same threatened conclusion they had reached in 2014, even after re-evaluating the conservation plan in the manner prescribed by the court.  In a statement to the court, the Service said that since the court’s ruling the agency had already been notified of “several potential development projects” that would harm the prairie chicken without adequate ESA protections in place.

In September, Permian Basin Petroleum Association President Ben Shepperd stated the ruling “serves as vindication of the unprecedented stakeholder participation across the lesser prairie chicken range.” Senator Jim Inhofe (R-OK) also praised the decision, stating “the court’s decision to vacate the listing demonstrates that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service did not adequately consider these conservation plans prior to the listing decision, which is a binding requirement.”

BLM releases report in response to sage grouse plans by Western governors. The Bureau of Land Management released a report today in response to challenges submitted by the governors of Idaho, Nevada, North Dakota, South Dakota and Utah surrounding the department’s federal land use plans for the greater sage-grouse.

Concerns put forward by the governors include upset over the lack of flexibility for oil and gas development in priority habitat areas and the current development caps on total surface disturbance activities in the federal plans. As reported in E&E News, Kornze responded to each state’s challenges, noting they are “inconsistent with the federal objectives of implementing ‘consistently strong’ protection measures for sage grouse habitat on federal lands.”

Some governors have now expressed interest in joining a court challenge to the federal land use plans currently put forward by Idaho Gov. Butch Otter, counties in Nevada, and mining groups. Read the full report HERE and more from E&E News.

Nevada official says land use plans are “1,000 percent worse” than listing the sage grouse. In September, Elko County joined Eureka County and two exploration companies in Nevada in filing a lawsuit against the Bureau of Land Management’s land use plan amendments in U.S. District Court. The amended land use plans are meant to preserve sagebrush habitat critical to the greater sage-grouse and could restrict mining, energy development, and grazing on public lands.

The lawsuit, which was later denied, challenged the legality of the land use plan and “its draconian land use prohibitions and restrictions that affect 20 million acres in Nevada.” Elko’s Assistant County Manager Randy Brown called the plans a “devastating” decision, warning that the plans give BLM the power to shut down federal land “whenever they see fit.” Brown has also stated the county will continue to consider if it wants to go further with the lawsuit.

BLM proposed withdrawal to impact 10 million acres across six states. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) has proposed to withdraw 10 million acres of federal land identified as “sagebrush focal areas” in Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Wyoming from location and entry of new mining claims. According to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the proposal “aims to protect the greater sage-grouse and its habitat from adverse effects of mineral exploration and mining,” including habitat fragmentation.

Both new and existing mining projects will be impacted under the proposed plan. According to BLM, the proposal kicks-off a two-year segregation period, preventing new mining claims on federal lands in sagebrush focal areas. During this time, BLM will prepare an Environmental Impact Statement to determine the impacts of the proposed withdrawal. At the conclusion of the segregation period, the Bureau will decide whether or not to withdraw the area for up to 20 years, with the possibility of further extensions.

During the segregation period, BLM may also require mineral examination reports to demonstrate the profitability of mineral deposits located in the segregated area. If this requirement is not satisfied, BLM can terminate the mining claim. If the proposed withdrawal is approved, the mining claim validation procedure becomes mandatory. The BLM is accepting public comments on the plan until December 23, 2015.

In the News

FWS concludes 20 species don’t need federal protections. E&E News (sub req’d). The Fish and Wildlife Service announced Wednesday that Endangered Species Act protections are not warranted for most populations of the Sierra Nevada red fox and 19 other species. “We are proud of our close work with so many diverse stakeholders, and of the role of the Endangered Species Act in supporting these collaborations,” FWS Director Dan Ashe said in a celebratory statement.

A Shifting Approach to Saving Endangered Species. New York Times. To many conservationists, although, the federal government’s resolution to keep away from itemizing the grouse displays a bigger shift in considering that’s taking maintain in educational departments and advocacy circles across the nation, even because it stirs controversy.

FWS acts to save rare fern and mollusk in Fla. E&E News (sub req’d). The Fish and Wildlife Service is moving to protect two Florida species that are found on opposite ends of the state but are similarly imperiled by agriculture, development and climate change. The Florida bristle fern, found on public lands in Miami-Dade and Sumter counties, will be added to the endangered species list, and the Suwannee moccasinshell mussel, which lives in a northern Florida river basin, will be proposed as a “threatened” species under the Endangered Species Act in tomorrow’s Federal Register.

Researcher Finds Way to Fight Cheatgrass, a Western Scourge. New York Times. Interest is high because the need is urgent. Earlier this year, Interior Secretary Sally Jewell ordered a new strategy to address the wildfires — fueled by cheatgrass — that are torching huge parts of the West’s sagebrush landscapes. The resulting losses of habitat were a big reason the greater sage grouse was considered for the endangered species list. (The federal government declined to list the bird last month, citing new recovery plans by state and federal agencies.)

Federal sage grouse plans abandon scientific integrity. The Hill (Op-Ed). The Obama administration’s public lands legacy may well be attempting the largest conservation effort by acreage, then botching it by ignoring their own scientists. Today there are more federal regulations, but they’re ineffectual, and sage grouse still don’t have the protection they need to survive.

FWS declines to list Sonoran Desert tortoise. E&E News (sub req’d). The Fish and Wildlife Service has decided that the Sonoran Desert tortoise found primarily in Arizona does not warrant federal protection under the Endangered Species Act, angering some environmental groups that say the decision could push the tortoise to extinction. Fish and Wildlife determined that the tortoise does not face an immediate threat of extinction across its narrow range in Arizona and the Mexican state of Sonora, according to an advance notice in today’s Federal Register.

Two Rare Macaws Get Federal Protection. Courthouse News Service. Two macaws found in Central and South American now have federal Endangered Species Act protection in an attempt to curb poaching and illegal trade. The great green macaw and the military macaw are now listed as endangered species under the ESA due to habitat loss and fragmentation, small population size, and poaching. Both species are at risk of extinction throughout their ranges.

FWS adds Black Pinesnake to threatened and endangered species list. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Press Release. The black pinesnake, which can grow to six feet in length and is now only found in parts of Mississippi and Alabama, will be protected as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA).

The post Weekly Newsletter – 10/13/15 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-101315/feed/ 0
Weekly Newsletter – 9/11/15 /weekly-newsletter-91115/ /weekly-newsletter-91115/#respond Fri, 11 Sep 2015 16:51:27 +0000 /?p=6219 Issues 5th Circuit rejects theory of unintentional take under Migratory Bird Treaty Act. The Fifth Circuit recently rejected  the United States’ theory of unintentional take under the 1918 Migratory Bird Treaty Act, reversing a Citgo Petroleum Corporation’s conviction related to […]

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/11/15 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
Issues

5th Circuit rejects theory of unintentional take under Migratory Bird Treaty Act. The Fifth Circuit recently rejected  the United States’ theory of unintentional take under the 1918 Migratory Bird Treaty Act, reversing a Citgo Petroleum Corporation’s conviction related to proposed violations of the Clean Air Act and Migratory Bird Act at a facility in Corpus Christi. The court concluded that birds killed in a refinery’s oil-water separator is not a violation of the Act, and concludes that collisions with power lines are also not takes.

According to the Fifth Circuit panel, the scope of takings under MBTA only prohibits intentional acts that directly kill migratory birds. The panel states, “If the MBTA prohibits all acts or omissions that ‘directly’ kill birds, where bird deaths are ‘foreseeable,’ then all owners of big windows, communication towers, wind turbines, solar energy farms, cars, cats, and even church steeples may be found guilty of violating the MBTA. This scope of strict criminal liability would enable the government to prosecute at will and even capriciously.”

Friday’s decision also splits the circuit courts on the issue of enforcement of MBTA in the oil and natural gas sector. As Law 360 reports, the decision puts the Fifth Circuit in agreement with the Eighth and Ninth Circuits, both of which have limited “takes” to hunting and poaching activities and that “taking” is limited to deliberate, intentional acts to migratory birds.  Meanwhile, the Second and Tenth Circuits “have read the MBTA broadly” and “hold that because the MBTA imposes strict liability, it must forbid acts that accidentally or indirectly kill birds.”

Court overturns lesser prairie chicken listing. Last week, a Senior U.S. District Judge in Texas overturned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s decision to list the lesser prairie chicken as threatened under the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA). The bird was originally listed in April 2014 with a 4(d) rule that specified take of the bird was authorized when undertaken by participants in the Lesser Prairie Chicken Range-Wide Conservation Plan.

Since 2014, the decision has received numerous legal challenges from both sides of the issue, including the Permian Basin Petroleum Association and a group of New Mexico counties who argued the listing did not adequately account for the conservation efforts underway in the Range-Wide plan. This argument was upheld in federal court this week, with the court finding “that the FWS failed to properly apply the Policy for Evaluation of Conservation Efforts When Making Listing Decisions (PECE) to its evaluation of the Range-Wide Plan, and that that failure resulted in material error,” according to Law 360.

Permian Basin Petroleum Association Ben Shepperd stated in the Associated Press that the ruling “serves as vindication of the unprecedented stakeholder participation across the lesser prairie chicken range.” Senator Jim Inhofe (R-OK) also praised the decision, stating “Oklahoma and the four other states in the LPC’s range established non-federal conservation plans prior to the administration’s decision to list the species. The court’s decision to vacate the listing demonstrates that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service did not adequately consider these conservation plans prior to the listing decision, which is a binding requirement.” IPAA supports the court’s ruling and will continue to monitor the results and implementation of the decision in the weeks ahead

IPAA coordinates Pennsylvania rig tour for federal agency. At the end of August, Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) Manager of Government Relations Samantha McDonald and Manager of Communications & Public Affairs Neal Kirby joined Chesapeake Energy and the American Petroleum Institute (API) in hosting a rig tour for seven U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service employees in Bradford County, Pennsylvania. The tour was a follow-up from a meeting held on the northern long-eared bat earlier this year in Hadley, Massachusetts between IPAA, API, and Fish and Wildlife in which they expressed interest in learning more about the oil and natural gas industry. In a thank you note, Assistant Regional Director for Region 5 Paul Phifer wrote, “Actually seeing an operation gives me a much greater appreciation for the thoughtfulness you all bring to the work.” IPAA thanks Chesapeake Energy for their hard work coordinating such a thorough and informative tour. A photo of the tour is also available HERE.

USDA pledges funds to conserve greater sage-grouse. Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack announced new plans in August to provide over $200 million in funding to enhance conservation of the greater sage-grouse, building off the Department’s Sage Grouse Initiative and providing additional resources to ranchers who implement projects to conserve the grouse and rangelands. According to the Denver Post, the Sage Grouse Initiative to date has partnered with over 1,100 ranches in the west, spending nearly $300 million to help conserve 4.4 million acres of land.

Under the new plan, referred to as Sage Grouse Initiative 2.0, USDA and its partners hope to nearly double the amount of protected land for the grouse, investing roughly $760 million and conserving 8 million acres of habitat by 2018. The plan was greeted as a positive step by many, including Wyoming Governor Matt Mead and the Oregon Cattleman Association, in both protecting the species and avoiding a federal listing of the bird later this month.

While Secretary Vilsack declined to comment on the upcoming September listing deadline for the greater sage-grouse, he did note the success of USDA programs in supporting the grouse’s population and providing “the best of all worlds: better habitat, better protection and better assurance for producers.” Review the full Sage Grouse Initiative 2.0 strategy HERE.

State land commissioners call for ESA reform. The Western States Land Commissioners Association unanimously approved a resolution last week, calling on Congress to reform the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and end the practice of “sue and settle” to promote listing decisions. According to Texas Land Commissioner George P. Bush, who brought forward the resolution to the association, “we’ve joined with our Western allies to put an end to ‘sue and settle’ and force the Obama administration to be upfront with the American people. It’s time to prioritize scientific assessments in conservation when dealing with property rights and our national security.”

The resolution calls on Congress to enact legislation to increase transparency around ESA listing decisions, limit legal fees currently allowed for decisions, and provide deference to state conservation and management plans to protect candidate species. The resolution also asks that federal critical habitat designations defer to state determinations and that Congress enact legislation to change the statutory deadlines currently outlined in the ESA to provide more time and transparency around candidate listing proposals and decisions. Read the full resolution HERE.

In the News

Oil and gas group urges beetle delisting. E&E News. “Under the requirements of the Endangered Species Act, we believe the case for removing the American Burying Beetle is clear and look forward to the Service’s serious consideration of this petition,” Dan Naatz, IPAA’s senior vice president of government relations and political affairs, said in a statement. “The Service’s legal obligation to evaluate the potential delisting of species under the ESA should be subject to the same care and attention as petitions to list.”

Bogus assumptions helped drive prairie chicken regulations. The Oklahoman (Editorial). A federal judge has ruled that the Obama administration’s efforts to declare the lesser prairie chicken “threatened” under the federal Endangered Species Act were done “arbitrarily and capriciously.” That conclusion isn’t shocking given this administration’s track record. The ruling by Robert A. Junell, a Texas district judge, is a victory for Oklahoma. Had the chicken been declared “threatened,” economic activity in much of the state would have been severely curtailed.

BLM director says state, federal sage grouse plans not that different. Great Falls Tribune. Jamie Connell, Montana and Dakotas director of the Bureau of Land Management, told members of a Montana legislative committee Wednesday that BLM and Montana sage grouse conservation plans aren’t that far apart, despite criticism from Montana Gov. Steve Bullock that the federal agency’s proposed rules are too restrictive on oil and gas development.

 Sagebrush restoration has helped songbirds – study. E&E News (sub req’d). Efforts to remove juniper trees in southern Oregon to make room for the greater sage grouse have already benefited a pair of sensitive songbirds that share the grouse’s sagebrush habitat, according to a new study. In the Warner Mountains, the abundance of Brewer’s sparrows, whose plain-brown plumages belie the diversity of their trills and songs, increased by 55 percent after junipers were culled from the landscape, according to the study shared with Greenwire.

Fight to save the sage grouse finds friends in all corners of the West. NPR. A widely-accepted study estimates that $5.6 billion of economic output would be lost if the bird was listed as endangered, which has spurred a lot of people into action. “Certainly, the Endangered Species Act is a huge hammer that’s motivated a lot of people to come to the table,” says Tom Christiansen, Wyoming’s Sage Grouse Program Coordinator.

Sage grouse study aims to keep bird off endangered species list. East Idaho News. The Idaho Fish and Game Department and the Bureau of Land Management’s study is designed to see what habitat is best for nesting and brooding and overall survival of adult birds. The possibility of the nation’s largest grouse being on the Endangered Species List looms over users of desert areas in 11 states. The bird being listed could close large portions of sage grouse habitat for all human use, including grazing cattle, drilling for oil and gas, recreation, and travel.

New drilling could stymie Wyo. sage grouse recovery – report. E&E News (sub req’d). The Obama administration has postponed approving most oil and gas wells within Wyoming’s prime sage grouse habitat, but the industry has over 27,000 wells in the project pipeline in the Cowboy State that could greatly fragment the bird’s best breeding grounds and drive it closer to extinction, according to a report released last week by WildEarth Guardians. Since 2009, the Obama administration’s permitting of industrial projects within core areas has “virtually ground to a halt,” the WildEarth report found. It was a major factor allowing sage grouse numbers to roughly double in Wyoming over the past two years, according to WildEarth’s Erik Molvar, who authored the report.

White House takes up hot-button habitat rule. E&E News (sub req’d). The White House’s regulatory arm this week began reviewing a controversial final rule to redefine the threshold for when projects such as mines, roads, pipelines or drilling harm or destroy critical habitat for threatened and endangered species. Environmental groups have praised the agencies for acknowledging the role critical habitat plays in the recovery of a listed species — as opposed to just its survival — but they’ve warned that the draft rule still fails to stem “incremental and cumulative impacts” to habitat that could push a species to the brink of extinction.

Sage-grouse Priority Areas Function as an Interdependent Network. U.S. Geological Survey (Press Release). The network of greater sage-grouse priority areas is a highly centralized system of conservation reserves. The largest priority areas likely can support sage-grouse populations within their boundaries, but smaller priority areas will need to rely on their neighbors in the surrounding network to sustain local populations, according to new research by the U.S. Geological Survey.

Land commissioners blast ‘sue and settle’ process. E&E News (sub req’d). Two dozen state land commissioners are asking for reforms to the Endangered Species Act, saying the process for animals being added to the list needs reform. “The Endangered Species Act was designed to preserve biodiversity, not enrich trial lawyers and political activists,” said Texas Land Commissioner George P. Bush (R) in a statement. “It’s time to prioritize scientific assessments in conservation when dealing with property rights and our national security.”

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Issues Proposed Rule Regarding Critical Habitat Determination for the Marbled Murrelet. JD Supra. On August 25, 2015, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) published a proposed rule relating to the existing critical habitat for the marbled murrelet (Brachyramphus marmoratus).  The murrelet is listed as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA).  The proposed rule does not purport to change the Service’s previous designation of critical habitat for the murrelet in 1996, as amended in 2011.

Voluntary Conservation Works Across Party Lines. Roll Call (Op-Ed). In just the past four years, voluntary conservation efforts through NRCS partnerships have helped protect and restore habitat on more than 4.4 million acres at a cost of $300 million. We are particularly pleased the NRCS has just reaffirmed its commitment to investing about $211 million more through 2018 through its Sage Grouse Initiative 2.0, conserving 8 million acres of sage grouse habitat. Voluntary conservation is a strategy that works for landowners, for wildlife and for taxpayers. It’s a triple win that cuts across party lines and fence lines to improve biodiversity and preserve landowners’ land use options. And it’s an approach we need to continue to support on a bipartisan basis.

The post Weekly Newsletter – 9/11/15 appeared first on ESAWatch.

]]>
/weekly-newsletter-91115/feed/ 0