Weekly Newsletter |August 16, 2019
Issues
Trump administration rolls out ESA revisions, IPAA praises logical changes that provide clarity and couple development with mindful conservation. Earlier this week, the Trump administration announced significant changes to the Endangered Species Act (ESA) in an effort to improve transparency and effectiveness in how regulations are implemented.
One key change focuses on the distinction between threatened and endangered designations. Threatened and endangered species have enjoyed some identical protections since 1978, when the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) used its authority to automatically grant threatened species the same safeguards as endangered ones through a provision under section 4(d) of the act known as the “blanket rule.” Under the newly proposed rules, FWS will now have to craft individual regulations for each threatened species.
Further, the ESA currently mandates that wildlife is deemed threatened when it’s at risk of becoming endangered in the “foreseeable future.” The administration wants to require higher standards for government action and consider only future factors that it deems “likely,” not just possible. The regulations also call for greater emphasis on economic impact analysis and allow the government to present economic impacts alongside a listing decision. To stay within the law, separate teams would work in parallel on the listing decision and the economic analysis, officials said.
The new rules will apply only to future listing decisions. Plants and animals with existing protections won’t be affected unless their status changes. These revisions track with the administration’s draft regulations, making the biggest change in a generation to a broad swath of the federal conservation regime. Administration officials hailed the reforms as balancing conservation with economic interests and claimed the new provisions would encourage better conservation plans, including more voluntary programs.
“The best way to uphold the Endangered Species Act is to do everything we can to ensure it remains effective in achieving its ultimate goal — recovery of our rarest species. The Act’s effectiveness rests on clear, consistent and efficient implementation,” Interior Secretary David Bernhardt said in a statement.
The rules also change the way officials designate critical habitat for a species’ recovery. Under the new version, only areas occupied by a species would be recognized as critical habitat, when before any area that could be potentially be occupied by a species would receive a critical habitat designation. This change reduces the potential for additional regulatory burden from a designation when a species is not present in an area. .
Shortly following the Department of Fish and Wildlife Services’ announcement of these regulatory reforms, Independent Petroleum Association of America (IPAA) Senior Vice President of Operations and Public Affairs Jeff Eshelman praised the reforms in a statement, pointing to the potential for enhanced interagency cooperation, clarified standards, and a much-needed shift away from inappropriate one-size-fits-all practices:
“IPAA is pleased with Fish and Wildlife Services’ commonsense reforms to streamline the Endangered Species Act. The final rule is an important step towards getting back to the original intent of the ESA as designed by Congress. After decades of working under a broken system, these reforms will help provide clarity to the process that will engender development coupled with our responsibility for mindful conservation of species. Specifically, IPAA applauds the Services’ clarity for the Section 7 consultation undertakings as well as rescinding of the Blanket 4(d) rule, as this shows the differences between a ‘threatened’ and ‘endangered’ listing.
“IPAA applauds the Agency for diligently working through reforms by engaging stakeholders at every point along the way. These thoughtful reforms take steps to ensure that the ESA will not be used as an environmental weapon to halt all other activities without science-based facts.”
Senate Environment and Public Works Chairman John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) also signaled that these new rules are just the beginning, calling for further updates to the ESA and claimed he is working on additional legislation in the Senate to strengthen the law so it can “meet its full conservation potential.”
In the News
AGs, greens plan legal assault on regulations. E&E News, Sub req’d. Blue states and environmental groups are plotting a major legal attack on the Trump administration’s new Endangered Species Act regulations. California Attorney General Xavier Becerra and Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey today laid out a swift plan to challenge the rules, which the Interior and Commerce departments unveiled today (Greenwire, Aug. 12). Trump officials billed the updated rules as an attempt to “modernize” implementation of the Endangered Species Act, but the Democrats and environmentalists say it will undercut enforcement and add red tape to species protections (see related story). In a press call today, Healey outlined the lawsuit she and other attorneys general expect to file after today’s changes are published in the Federal Register. She explained that the lawsuit will allege that the new regulations are illegal because they ignore scientific evidence, environmental impacts and public comments and that they violate the text of the Endangered Species Act.
Groups to court: Kill FWS permit for Mountain Valley. E&E News, Sub req’d. A coalition of eight environmental groups are seeking to pull a key federal permit for the controversial Mountain Valley pipeline using the same legal strategy that halted construction of another pipeline. The groups filed a petition for review yesterday in a federal appeals court in an effort to halt construction of the 303-mile natural gas pipeline after alleging that the biological opinion from the Fish and Wildlife Service failed to properly consider Mountain Valley’s impacts on three endangered species. A similar strategy was used by environmental groups to undercut Dominion Energy Inc.’s Atlantic Coast pipeline, a 600-mile project that is sitting in limbo as the developer looks to secure renewed permits from FWS and the Forest Service to continue construction (Energywire, Feb. 7). The coalition is led by the Sierra Club and Center for Biological Diversity, among others. “Regulators can’t keep shrugging off the environmental harms of pipeline projects,” said Jared Margolis, Center for Biological Diversity senior attorney. “We need to stop destroying habitats and waterways for fossil fuels that are driving the climate catastrophe.”
Joshua tree loses out on listing bid. E&E News, Sub req’d. The Fish and Wildlife Service ruled out federal protections today for the famed Joshua tree, disappointing environmentalists already alarmed over new Endangered Species Act rules. While acknowledging that “wildfire, invasive plants, effects of climatic changes, and habitat loss” all continue to stress the tree found in and around the Mojave Desert, the service concluded the tree remains resilient and in fine shape. FWS evaluated what are now considered two distinct species of the Joshua tree, designated as Yucca brevifolia and Yucca jaegeriana. “Because the two species are long-lived, have such large ranges and distributions, mostly occur on Federal land, and occupy numerous ecological settings, we have determined that future … events would not lead to population- or species-level declines in the foreseeable future,” the agency stated. The conclusions reached in the so-called 12-month review rejected a 2015 petition filed by WildEarth Guardians, which sought to add the tree to the ESA list of threatened species. The decision not to list the Joshua tree, along with other ESA decisions announced today, was also made under rules that in some cases differ from those that will apply in the future.
Removing Klamath dams estimated to cost more than $400M. E&E News, Sub req’d. Removing four hydroelectric dams along the Lower Klamath River in southern Oregon and Northern California is expected to cost just under $434 million and could happen by 2022, according to a new filing with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The Capital Press reports that the nonprofit Klamath River Renewal Corp. (KRRC) submitted plans to FERC in 2018 to decommission and demolish the J.C. Boyle, Copco Nos. 1 and 2 and Iron Gate dams, which block about 400 miles of upstream habitat for migratory salmon and steelhead. Regulators are now considering whether to transfer the dams’ operating license from PacifiCorp to KRRC before the project can move forward. A general contractor, Kiewit Infrastructure West Co. of Fairfield, Calif., is already on board and working on a plan for razing the dams. But first, KRRC must answer questions from a six-member independent board of consultants appointed by the feds to prove they have the money, insurance and contingency for such a large proposal. (…) Built between 1911 and 1962, the Lower Klamath River dams are currently operated by PacifiCorp and have a total generation capacity of 169 megawatts. Efforts to remove the dams date back to 2010, when farmers, tribes, environmental groups and government agencies all signed on to the Klamath Hydroelectric Settlement Agreement. By restoring a more free-flowing river, the parties hope to improve spawning and survival of fish species protected under the Endangered Species Act.