Weekly Newsletter | April 3, 2020
Issues
BLM drops appeal of Idaho injunction blocking sage-grouse plan. In October of last year, Judge B. Lynn Winmill of Idaho, a Clinton appointee, sided with activists in granting a preliminary injunction that stoped the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) from implementing amended plans for oil and gas permitting and licensing on greater sage grouse habitat in seven states. By December, BLM had appealed the decision with several states, Wyoming and Idaho among them, joining to push back on the temporary freeze.
As of last Friday, however, BLM is dropping its appeal; the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted the federal government’s request to voluntarily dismiss the case.
BLM did not comment on the reason for dismissing the appeal but defended the Trump administration’s analysis of its proposed sage grouse plan amendments.
“BLM believes the sage-grouse management plans adopted in 2019 with strong, bipartisan support from the states involved are in the best interest of the American people, local communities who value public lands and conservation and habitats on which sage-grouse and more than 300 other wildlife species depend,” wrote Derrick Henry, a BLM spokesperson, in an email to E&E News, (Sub req’d).
He added that a supplemental environmental effects analysis for the 2019 plan was currently available for public comment. Henry said the two phases of analysis show the agency had taken the required “hard look” at the effects of the Trump plan.
Trump administration will not extend ESA protections for bi-state grouse. The Trump administration has formally decided not to extend Endangered Species Act (ESA) protections to a distinct population of greater sage grouse found only along the California-Nevada border. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS), in a notice published in the Federal Register, said that after a yearlong review of the bi-state population, it has determined that the threats “no longer are as significant as believed” when FWS first proposed a rule listing the bird as a threatened species in 2013.
The bi-state sage grouse is a geographically isolated and genetically distinct population of the greater sage grouse. It was originally proposed for listing as threatened in 2013, but FWS abandoned the proposal in 2015. In 2018, a federal court found the agency had wrongly denied Endangered Species Act protection to the bi-state sage grouse and required the agency to re-evaluate the bird’s situation.
FWS will also withdraw a proposed rule that would have designated thousands of acres of critical habitat for the bird, according to the notice.
“The Service is humbled and proud to work with such a committed group of partners to conserve the bi-state sage-grouse and its habitat in California and Nevada,” said Paul Souza, director of FWS’s California-Great Basin region, in a statement. “This partnership shows that conservation for at-risk species can be successful when we work together and leverage our resources.”
State plans to protect the California and Nevada greater sage-grouse, in addition to federal efforts to remove pinyon and juniper forests to expand sage-grouse habitat, are sufficient to avoid future threats to the sage-grouse in those states and will prevent the population from declining further, Tuesday’s notice adds.
California and Nevada created the Bi-State Action Plan during the Obama administration to protect the sage-grouse. A senior FWS official pointed to ongoing efforts by “a coalition of federal, state, tribal, private and non-governmental partners” as sufficient to protect the bi-state population. Draft plans for the sage-grouse in seven states are open for public comment until April 6.
“The May 2018 court ruling that required another look at this species has provided our agencies an opportunity to tell the story of effective science-based collaborative conservation with five additional years to develop cutting edge science and deliver conservation for sage-grouse. The bi-state sage grouse conservation model is the epitome of collaborative science based conservation,” Tony Wasley, director of the Nevada Department of Wildlife, said in a news release. “Our department supports this decision, and I’m grateful to have another chance to showcase this conservation story.”
The final decision allowed FWS to meet a court-ordered April 1 deadline to make a final determination on the status of the bi-state population.
In the News
Trump admin appeals ruling nixing $125M lease sale. E&E News, Sub req’d. The Trump administration is once again challenging a federal judge’s decision blocking revisions to greater sage grouse protections. And the state of Wyoming and the oil and gas industry are joining them in the fight. The Justice Department yesterday filed a formal notice of appeal to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on behalf of the Interior Department and Bureau of Land Management. They plan to challenge a judge’s February order that tossed out BLM-adopted rule changes shortening public comment and protest periods involving oil and gas lease sale parcels that overlap sage grouse habitat. In addition, Wyoming yesterday filed a separate notice with the appeals court challenging the order by Chief Magistrate Judge Ronald Bush in the U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho. And Denver-based Western Energy Alliance, an oil and gas trade group, today filed its own appeal notice. Wyoming and the Western Energy Alliance were formal intervenors in support of Interior and BLM in a federal lawsuit filed by environmental groups challenging the revisions.
Bernhardt approves 11K miles of fire breaks out West. E&E News, Sub req’d. The Interior Department announced today that it has formally approved a sweeping plan designed to protect communities and wildlife habitat in six Western states from the threat of wildfires. The plan involves constructing and maintaining 11,000 miles of so-called fuel breaks across 223 million acres of federal lands in California, Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, Utah and Washington. Constructing fuel breaks, usually along dirt roads, involves cutting or mowing vegetation, or using prescribed fires, chemical treatments and “targeted” livestock grazing, to remove flammable materials that provide fuel for wildfires that can rapidly tear across hundreds of acres. The Bureau of Land Management says extensive research of more than 1,400 fuel breaks has documented that they are an effective tool firefighters can use to control catastrophic blazes. The bureau says that between 2009 and 2018, wildfires burned more than 13.5 million acres of historical sagebrush habitat on BLM-managed lands.
Ex-FWS chief: Rule change could kill billions of birds. E&E News, Sub req.d. Critics say the Trump administration’s proposed changes to the Migratory Bird Treaty Act could devastate threatened and endangered species and accelerate a bird population decline across North America since the 1970s. Former Fish and Wildlife Service Director Dan Ashe says the law’s threat of prosecution served as “a brake on industry” that has saved probably billions of birds. “Removing that obligation, if it stands, over the next several decades will result in billions of birds being casualties,” Ashe, who served in the Obama administration, told the Associated Press. “It will be catastrophic.” The Trump administration wants to end the 50-year practice of using the criminal penalties under the migratory bird law to pressure companies into taking measures to prevent unintentional bird deaths.
Greens plot ESA lawsuit over Trump’s WOTUS rule. E&E News, Sub req’d. A coalition of conservation groups yesterday told the federal government they stand ready to launch a legal challenge against the Trump administration’s revamped protections for waterways and wetlands. Attorneys for the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Conservation Law Foundation and other groups said President Trump’s EPA and Army Corps of Engineers violated consultation requirements under the Endangered Species Act in shaping their new definition of the Waters of the U.S., or WOTUS, rule. “The Rule is a ‘discretionary’ action … that ‘may affect’ endangered and threatened species,” the groups wrote. “The Agencies therefore had a legal duty to complete consultation with the [Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA Fisheries] before promulgating the Rule.” Clean Wisconsin, the Connecticut River Conservancy, Bangor Land Trust, the Massachusetts Audubon Society, the Merrimack River Watershed Council, the New Mexico Wilderness Alliance and the Prairie Rivers Network also signed on to the notice of intent to sue EPA and the Army Corps.