Weekly Newsletter | April 17,  2020 

Issues

Judge hears arguments in BLM leasing fight over sage grouse. In a tele-hearing held this week, attorneys for environmentalist groups and the federal government argued over a set of Bureau of Land Management (BLM) leasing directives green groups claim violated Obama-era protections for the greater sage grouse. The lawyers clashed over whether the guidance from BLM under the Trump administration undermined a directive in the 2015 sage grouse plan to prioritize lease sales outside the bird’s habitat.

Chief Judge Brian Morris for the U.S. District Court of the District of Montana, an Obama appointee, pressed both parties on whether a memorandum from the former Interior Department (DOI) chief counted as a binding agency action that could be challenged in court and asked about the legal consequences of an instruction memorandum from the agency.

The lawsuit filed by the Montana Wildlife Federation, the Wilderness Society, the National Audubon Society, the National Wildlife Federation and Montana Audubon challenged BLM’s 2018 instruction memorandum (IM) and former Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke’s memorandum on implementing the 2015 plan. The environmentalist groups contend that the actions of DOI violated the Federal Land Policy and Management Act and the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA).

Attorneys for Earthjustice alleged BLM’s directives shifted the agency from seeking to defer parcels on sage grouse habitat to not withholding any leases on the grounds that the agency should prioritize leases elsewhere.

The Department of Justice (DOJ) pushed back, maintaining that the determination not to list the bird was based on the protections of the 2015 amendments not just the prioritization requirement. DOJ attorney Luther Hajek said the resulting arrangement gave BLM the option to prioritize leases outside sage grouse habitat but did not require it. Hajek also said the directives could not be reviewed by the court under the Administrative Procedure Act.

He described the Zinke memorandum as “an internal memo to agency staff to clarify policies related to sage grouse conservation.”

“It is to explore agency options,” he said. “The memo itself does not include agency policies. … This memo doesn’t revoke prior policy, it looked at ways to make them more efficient.”

Hajek added that the 2018 instruction memorandum did not open or close any areas to leasing or make any final leasing decisions.

In the News

Carbon Dioxide Pipelines May Spare Sage-Grouse Home in Wyoming. Bloomberg, Sub req’d.  Plans for a 1,914 mile network of carbon dioxide pipelines in Wyoming may sidestep the habitat of the greater sage-grouse, a bird whose fate is linked to U.S. energy development. The Wyoming Pipeline Corridor Initiative is a state-proposed project providing rights of way, up to 300 feet wide, for pipelines that would supply oil fields with carbon dioxide to boost crude oil production and sequester carbon. The pipelines would be built across federal land supervised by the Bureau of Land Management. The BLM’s draft environmental review of the proposal, scheduled to appear in the Federal Register Friday, says the corridors ill be designed to avoid the most sensitive greater sage-grouse habitat. No new corridors will be proposed for that habitat, it says.The draft review is open for public comment for 90 days beginning Friday.

Judge weighs killing Trump’s Keystone XL permit. E&E News, Sub req’d. One day after axing a key water permit for the Keystone XL pipeline, a federal judge took to the bench to consider arguments on whether he should follow suit for President Trump’s authorization of the project’s international border crossing. Chief Judge Brian Morris for the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana closely questioned attorneys in a marathon hearing yesterday about Trump’s authority to issue a 2019 permit allowing the 1.2-mile northern border-crossing segment of the oil pipeline. Developer TC Energy began work on the segment earlier this month, a move that drew fierce pushback from tribal leaders and some residents concerned about construction crews spreading the coronavirus. Morris, an Obama appointee, heard combined arguments for a pair of cases from tribes and environmental groups alleging the president had violated the Constitution by infringing on Congress’ authority to regulate international commerce. The groups also warned that the international permit effectively authorized the entire length of the pipeline, endangering tribal lands.

Eastern Sierra Land Trust touts success on Bi-State sage-grouse protections. Sierra Wave. Our conservation community has something to celebrate! That’s because on March 30th this year, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (“USFWS”) announced it is withdrawing a 2013 proposed rule to list the Bi-State sage-grouse as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. USFWS made this decision after an “extended and comprehensive analysis of the best available science.” They concluded that local conservation actions have and will continue to successfully reduce threats to the Bi-State sage-grouse. This is good news for all the Eastside conservation professionals and community members who have unified to form what’s called the Bi-State Local Area Working Group (“LAWG”), a group of diverse stakeholders dedicated to bringing the power of local land protection to care for the Bi-State sage-grouse. The LAWG is made up of state and local officials, public and tribal land managers, ranchers, private landowners, scientists, and conservationists like the Bishop-based nonprofit organization Eastern Sierra Land Trust.

Greens seek to block oil exploration at Fla. preserve. E&E News, Sub req’d. Environmental groups have revived a fight over oil and gas exploration at the Big Cypress National Preserve in Florida. Four organizations sent a letter to the Army Corps of Engineers yesterday asking that any seismic surveying at the site follow federal protections required under the Clean Water Act. In addition, the groups — the Natural Resources Defense Council, Center for Biological Diversity, Conservancy of Southwest Florida and National Parks Conservation Association — requested a meeting “to obtain clarification” after the Army Corps suddenly reversed course on its handling of the issue last week. In March, the Army Corps said it had found evidence of damage from prior seismic surveying done at the preserve by Texas-based Burnett Oil Co. As a result, the corps said, any future surveying had to comply with the Clean Water Act.

State panel grants temporary endangered species status to Southern California cougars. Los Angeles Times. The state Fish and Game Commission on Thursday set the stage for a fierce environmental battle by granting temporary endangered species status to the several hundred cougars still roaming Southern California and the Central Coast. The protection came with the 5-member panel’s unanimous decision to consider a petition filed by environmentalists to list as threatened or endangered six, isolated clans of cougars hemmed in by sprawl and freeways. The move is considered preliminary under terms of the state Endangered Species Act. Next, the commission will hold public hearings. A permanent decision could go into force in 2022. If the big cats are permanently listed, the law requires state wildlife managers to devise a recovery plan for them, raising the prospect of constraints on development and highway construction from Santa Cruz to the U.S.-Mexico border, according to the petition submitted by the Center for Biological Diversity and the nonprofit Mountain Lion Foundation.

Trump admin reopens Mexican wolf study. E&E News, Sub req’d. The Fish and Wildlife Service today reopened a debate over the best way to protect the Mexican wolf. Facing legal pressure, the agency announced plans to revise the “nonessential experimental population” designation and management of the wolves living in Arizona and New Mexico. The plans require drafting an environmental impact statement supplement. “We intend to ensure the new revised rule supports population-level genetic health for the Mexican wolf … as a key component of the long-term conservation and recovery of the Mexican wolf,” FWS stated, among other objectives. The Mexican wolf has been protected under the Endangered Species Act since 1976, when seven wolves began captive breeding. The latest count showed there were 163 wild Mexican wolves living in the United States. FWS established a nonessential experimental population of Mexican wolves in Arizona and New Mexico in 1998, and in 2015 published a final rule governing the animal’s designation and management.

Endangered Species Program Challenge Pushed to Appeals Court. Bloomberg, Sub req’d. Environmentalists are heading to a federal appeals court in a bid to put biologists, not bureaucrats, in charge of reviewing endangered animals and plants. The Center for Biological Diversity filed a notice of appeal April 10 to challenge a recent court decision upholding the Interior Department’s process for analyzing scientific information related to Endangered Species Act protections. The case centers on the agency’s Species Status Assessment program, which synthesizes scientific information about at-risk species and informs subsequent decisions about protections. The Center for Biological Diversity says Interior should have consulted the public on its implementing guidelines for the program, which they say leave too much decision-making power to the Fish and Wildlife Service’s regional directors and other leaders instead of scientists. The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia in February concluded the Center for Biological Diversity lacked standing to bring the case. The center is taking the case to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.